Navigation Links
New study questions the validity of publishing hospital mortality rates
Date:9/24/2007

A previous study of mortality rates for congenital heart surgery used routinely available hospital data that were misleading, according to a report published today on bmj.com which questions the validity of such data being made public.

Professor Westaby and colleagues found the system of information gathering used in the study had underestimated the number of infant deaths. In the previous BMJ study, published in 2004, Oxford had been singled out as having significantly higher mortality than the national average for open heart surgery on infants. Yet this new paper, using data from a different source - the Central Cardiac Audit Database - shows that the hospitals mortality statistics were not actually different from the mean for all the centres (10 percent compared to 8 percent between 2000 and 2002).

The authors looked at a report from the Dr Foster unit at Imperial College which was published in the wake of the inquiry into the Bristol congenital heart surgery deaths. That inquiry, which drew widespread publicity and had a profound effect on surgical practice in the UK, used Hospital Episode Statistics (HES) to compare mortality rates among cardiac surgical units across the country. The 2004 study by Dr Aylin described these mortality statistics.

The authors of the current study compared the mortality rates reported by the administrative HES database and an alternative system, the clinically based Central Cardiac Audit Database, for infants under 12 months undergoing cardiac operations. The statistics were gathered between 1st April 2000 and 31st March 2002.

They found HES did not provide reliable patient numbers or 30-day mortality data. On average HES recorded 20 percent fewer cases than CCAD and only captured between 27 percent and 78 percent of 30-day deaths, with a median shortfall of 40 percent.

In Centre A, with the largest number of operations, 38 percent of all patients were missed by HES and only 27 percent of the total deaths were recorded. Overall, mortality statistics were underestimated by 4 percent using HES data.

The authors say publication of inaccurate statistics detracts from public confidence and that: If mortality statistics are to be released their quality must be beyond reproach.

They acknowledge the media are keen to publish such statistics and pinpoint Dr Foster who have pioneered this by providing newspapers with information on heart disease, for example, in return for a fee.

They conclude: Given the problems with data quality, the imprecision of risk stratification models, and the confrontational agenda in the media, we question the value of placing mortality statistics in the public domain.


'/>"/>

Contact: Emma Dickinson
edickinson@bmj.com
44-020-738-36529
BMJ-British Medical Journal
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Rural Canadians travel far for specialists: study
2. A new study surpasses Gene Therapy Hurdle
3. Tomato Sauce reduces Cancer Risk- Study
4. A question on study of Adult Stem Cell
5. Study on obesity and heart failure
6. National Lung Study in the process
7. Marijuana gateway theory strengthened by study of twins
8. Old theory of adaptation confirmed by new study
9. Study casts doubt on keyboard ills
10. Gene study links endometriosis, infertility
11. Study reveals how stress can make you sick
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/9/2016)... ... 09, 2016 , ... METTLER TOLEDO has published a new ... basic understanding of the techniques they use so they can more easily spot ... waste and rework to create a leaner overall lab experience. , The ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... ... February 09, 2016 , ... Two renowned photographers, Robert ... a photographic adventure on the island, June 14-19, 2016, hosted by Four Seasons Resort ... , After a successful debut in 2015, the Maui Photo Expedition workshop ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... G.A. (PRWEB) , ... February 09, 2016 , ... ... and grout cleaning and sealing company , is proud to announce that many ... their superior levels of customer service. The hard surface restoration franchises received customer ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... ... February 09, 2016 , ... Shark Finds and Kevin Harrington, and the ... with GRIP-DRY. , GRIP-DRY is a newly patented product that has solved some of the ... the wet and early morning dew or right after a rain shower, might understand the ...
(Date:2/8/2016)... ... February 08, 2016 , ... CURE Media Group ... officially launched the Multiple Myeloma Heroes Awards event , which will annually honor ... lives of patients with MM. The MM Heroes Awards nomination process is ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/9/2016)... Feb. 9, 2016 The life of Dr. ... has been anything but ordinary.  Twists of fate, combined with ... II and the constraints of communist Czechoslovakia to ... would go on to make history by playing a key ... drugs in the world, Remicade.  Dr. Vilcek brings readers along ...
(Date:2/9/2016)... report "Global Anti-Bacterial Drugs Market Assessment & Forecast: 2015 - 2019" ... North America continued to lead global anti-bacterial ... into revenues worth US$ 16,907.3 million. North ... , Latin America , Middle-East ... market is inclined towards North America and ...
(Date:2/8/2016)... 2016 Alzheimer Diagnostic Tests - Medical ... Medical Devices sector report , "Alzheimer Diagnostic Tests ... overview of Alzheimer Diagnostic Tests currently in pipeline ... the pipeline products with comparative analysis of the ... reviews major players involved in the pipeline product ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: