Navigation Links
New JAMA Study Raises Issue of How Nutrients Should Be Researched
Date:12/4/2007

WASHINGTON, Dec. 4 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- A study published in the December 5 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA) (See Note 1) raises important philosophical issues with regard to researching the effects of nutrients in humans and demonstrates the confusion that persists when new research contradicts earlier research.

According to Andrew Shao, Ph.D., vice president, scientific and regulatory affairs, Council for Responsible Nutrition, "The problem that we have for the scientific community in evaluating the effects of nutrients in people is that everyone from scientists to journalists to consumers -- wants conclusive answers, consequently we're always looking at what the 'study du jour' tells us and trying to make it answer all questions. But the reality is that science doesn't always move forward -- there is some back and forth -- and while research may seem to contradict itself, that should not be interpreted to mean one type of study trumps another, particularly when different studies ask and answer different questions. Seemingly conflicting data can exist side by side, when one understands that not all studies are asking the same questions in the same populations."

The JAMA review set out to evaluate the change over time in the quantity and content of citations for two highly cited observational studies that found major cardiovascular benefits associated with vitamin E supplementation and to understand how these benefits continue to be defended in literature, despite contradicting evidence from large RCTs. In order to make the findings more generalized, the study also examined the citations for observational studies showing the protective effects of beta-carotene on cancer and estrogen on Alzheimer's disease. The study authors conclude that there is "an apparent split of stance in the scientific literature" when it comes to these substances.

The researchers gathered and reviewed 172 articles on vitamin E and cardiovascular health, 16 articles on beta-carotene and cancer prevention and 47 articles on estrogen for dementia prevention, rating them as favorable, equivocal and unfavorable. The sampled articles were published in 1997, 2001 and 2005 (before, early and late after publication of refuting RCTs) related to vitamin E and cardiovascular health and in 2006, which referenced highly cited articles proposing benefits associated with beta-carotene and cancer.

Pertaining to vitamin E the researchers found that, despite the large RCTs that received a great deal of media attention, more than half of the articles that cited the observational studies were favorable towards a beneficial effect of supplemental vitamin E. The study authors write, "Even among articles that cited the contradicting HOPE [RCT] trial, rather than the positive epidemiological studies, the majority in 2005 still could not conclude that vitamin E was ineffective."

Dr. Shao says "this suggests that researchers interpret research differently, depending on their bias and expertise. For pure scientific purposes, here's a valid hypothesis to test: conduct a trial on secondary prevention in heart patients with a lifetime of bad habits that likely contributed to their heart disease to determine if a nutrient might provide some benefit. But it's not valid to conclude from the results of that study that the nutrient doesn't work. We can't expect a simple vitamin supplement to reverse heart disease. So if that doesn't happen, we must interpret the results appropriately by placing the study in the proper context and acknowledge that the results don't answer the question of whether supplemental amounts of vitamin E in a healthy population could have prevented heart disease had it been used consistently over time in combination with other antioxidants."

The findings from the JAMA literature review related to beta-carotene and cancer and estrogen and dementia were similar, with the researchers finding that more than 62 percent of the articles in each of these subsets were favorable.

Dr. Shao states, "The RCTs with negative results attempted to answer the question, 'can a supplemental nutrient treat or reverse a disease or a lifetime of unhealthy habits in patients who are also taking prescription medications?' The observational studies with positive results attempted to answer the question, 'if we start with a mostly healthy population generally free of disease, can we identify various diet/nutrient and lifestyle factors that make them more or less prone to disease?' These are very different questions, making the studies incompatible for direct comparison and demonstrating that one type of study can't necessarily be used to refute the other. We firmly believe that RCTs should not be thought of as the only rigorous research approach. As the study authors point out, 'when randomized and observational studies disagree, it is incorrect to assume that nonrandomized studies are always wrong.' Rather, we should put studies into the appropriate context and evaluate the total body of evidence, which includes RCTs and observational studies, and other types of research. We hope that the publication of this analysis will encourage all of those within the scientific community to become more involved in this discussion."

Note 1: Tatsioni A, Bonitsis NG, Ioannidis JPA. Persistence of Contradicted Claims in the Literature. Journal of the American Medical Association (JAMA). December 5, 2007; 298 (21): 2517-2526.

Note to Editor: The Council for Responsible Nutrition (CRN), founded in 1973, is a Washington, D.C.-based trade association representing dietary supplement industry ingredient suppliers and manufacturers.


'/>"/>
SOURCE Council for Responsible Nutrition
Copyright©2007 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Penn study finds pro-death proteins required to regulate healthy immune function
2. New study shows promise in reducing surgical risks associated with surgical bleeding
3. Study, meta-analysis examine factors associated with death from heatstroke
4. Study suggests loss of 2 types of neurons -- not just 1 -- triggers Parkinsons symptoms
5. Study says COPD testing is not measuring up
6. Preclinical study suggests organ-transplant drug may aid in lupus fight
7. Ability to cope with stress can increase good cholesterol in older white men, study finds
8. High alcohol consumption increases stroke risk, Tulane study says
9. Mailman School of Public Health study examines link between racial discrimination and substance use
10. Pitt study finds inequality in tobacco advertising
11. Stanford study highlights cost-effective method of lowering heart disease risks
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:6/26/2016)... ... June 27, 2016 , ... Quality metrics are proliferating in cancer ... they remain in the eye of the beholder, according to experts who offered insights ... American Journal of Managed Care. For the full issue, click here . , ...
(Date:6/26/2016)... California (PRWEB) , ... June 26, 2016 , ... Pixel ... Cut Pro X. , "Film editors can give their videos a whole new perspective ... Christina Austin - CEO of Pixel Film Studios. , ProSlice Levels contains over ...
(Date:6/26/2016)... Charlotte, NC (PRWEB) , ... June 26, 2016 , ... Brent Kasmer, a legally blind ... able to be personalized through a fitness app. The fitness app plans to fix the ... solutions currently only offer a one size fits all type program , They ...
(Date:6/25/2016)... (PRWEB) , ... June 25, 2016 , ... ... health policy issues and applications at AcademyHealth’s Annual Research Meeting June 26-28, 2016, ... work on several important health care topics including advance care planning, healthcare costs ...
(Date:6/25/2016)... FL (PRWEB) , ... June 25, 2016 , ... The temporary closing of Bruton Memorial ... Plant City Observer , brings up a new, often overlooked aspect of head lice: the ... closing for fumigation is not a common occurrence, but a necessary one in the event ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:6/23/2016)... Capricor Therapeutics, Inc. ... company focused on the discovery, development and commercialization ... in its ongoing randomized HOPE-Duchenne clinical trial (Halt ... its 24-patient target. Capricor expects the trial to ... 2016, and to report top line data from ...
(Date:6/23/2016)... INDIANAPOLIS , June 23, 2016 ... Tomorrow,s Leaders Scholarship is any indication, the future is ... online at www.diabetesscholars.org by the Diabetes Scholars ... in the way of academic and community service excellence. ... program since 2012, and continues to advocate for people ...
(Date:6/23/2016)... 23, 2016 The vast majority of dialysis ... facility.  Treatments are usually 3 times a week, with ... including travel time, equipment preparation and wait time.  This ... grueling for patients who are elderly and frail.  Many ... and rehabilitation centers for some duration of time. ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: