Navigation Links
Most Psychiatrists Open to Discussing Spiritual Concerns
Date:12/27/2007

They're more likely to broach the topic with patients than are other doctors, study finds

THURSDAY, Dec. 27 (HealthDay News) -- Many doctors avoid issues of spirituality and faith when interacting with patients, but that's not true for most psychiatrists, a new study finds.

In fact, more than 90 percent of psychiatrists surveyed said it's always or usually appropriate to ask patients about their religious faith or spirituality, while just 53 percent of other doctors thought so.

On the other hand, psychiatrists were much more likely to report that crises of religious faith can worsen a patients' suffering.

"Although psychiatrists are not [typically] religious themselves, they are the doctors most comfortable with talking about spiritual issues," said study lead author Dr. Farr Curlin, an assistant professor of medicine at the University of Chicago.

According to Curlin, there has long been a tension between psychiatry and people of faith, in no small part because the father of modern psychology, Sigmund Freud, was deeply skeptical of religion. In addition, psychiatrists have "for a long time tended to associate religious belief and practice as being a sign of, if not mental illness, at least delusional behavior," Curlin contended.

The study does support the notion that, compared to other types of clinicians, psychiatrists are more dubious of religion. For example, 18 percent of psychiatrists surveyed said they were not religious, compared to 10 percent of other doctors. And, on a measure of "intrinsic religiosity," 47 percent of psychiatrists were rated as "low," compared to 36 percent of other doctors.

There have, however, been efforts to repair this "breach" between spirituality and psychology, said Curlin, who studies the roles of religion and spirituality within the context of medicine.

In the new study, researchers randomly surveyed 2,000 physicians about patients and religion, including 100 psychiatrists. A total of 1,144 doctors responded.

The findings were published in the December issue of The American Journal of Psychiatry; other findings from the survey were reported earlier this year.

"We found that if you look at doctors in general, the less religious they are, the less likely they think it's appropriate for them to address spiritual issues at all," Curlin said. "The opposite seems to be the case among psychiatrists. They're the least religious doctors, but they're the ones who basically see this is as part of their bailiwick, part of what they do."

Eighty-two percent of psychiatrists thought religion leads to increased suffering in some cases, compared to 44 percent of the other doctors.

"We observe that some patients really go through existential crises when they get sick -- they wonder if they've been abandoned by God, and they relive old sins," Curlin said.

On the other hand, about three-quarters of both groups said religion can help patients cope with and endure sickness.

Also in the survey, 36 percent of psychiatrists and 28 percent of other doctors said patients "sometimes" used religion or spirituality as a reason to avoid taking proper care of themselves.

Curlin believes it's appropriate for doctors to bring up religion or spirituality "anytime they think it's relevant to the patient's experience of illness or decision-making regarding course of treatment or response to that illness."

But to some doctors, he said, "there's still a strong sense that the spiritual is personal and that the practice of medicine is professional, and those two domains ought to be kept apart as far as possible."

Richard P. Sloan, professor of behavioral medicine at Columbia University, said it is disturbing that doctors believe that spiritual beliefs can lead patients to delay or refuse treatment.

Should doctors ever ask about religion in the first place? Sloan, who's written skeptically about the study of religion's role in medicine, said it can be appropriate in certain contexts.

"You need to know what characteristics of your patients might interfere with your ability to treat them well," Sloan said. Patients who are fasting during Ramadan, for example, might not be able to take four doses of a pill per day.

"The concern that I have is a number of physicians who go way beyond what's necessary and run the risk of manipulating their patients, even coercing them, invading their privacy, taking on spiritual matters as objects of intervention," he said. According to Sloan, appropriate inquiries are fine, but proselytizing has no place in the doctor's office

More information

For more on spirituality and health, visit the U.S. National Center for Complementary and Alternative Medicine .



SOURCES: Farr Curlin, M.D., assistant professor, medicine, University of Chicago; Richard P. Sloan, Ph.D., professor, behavioral medicine, Columbia University Medical Center, New York City; December 2007, The American Journal of Psychiatry


'/>"/>
Copyright©2007 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. Psychiatrists are the least religious of all physicians
2. Psychiatrists, parents significantly differ in ADHD, psychiatric comorbidities perceptions
3. Psychiatrists: Least religious but most interested in patients religion
4. Spiritual Healer/Psychic-Medium Reaches International Status!
5. Spirituality Helps Older Black Women Beat Hypertension
6. New Yorkers Deserve Access to Spiritually Based Healing
7. Health Care Bill Omits Access to Spiritual Care
8. Care reforms raise concerns over patient access to GP services
9. Healthcare Workers Rally to Address Concerns About Layoffs and Quality Patient Care
10. Scientists highlight benefits of genetic research in sport, but warn of ethical concerns
11. Concerns Rise Over U.S. Food Safety
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Most Psychiatrists Open to Discussing Spiritual Concerns
(Date:4/29/2016)... ... 29, 2016 , ... World Patent Marketing , a ... invention which aids in proper muscle development. , "The Gym & Exercise Equipment ... of World Patent Marketing. "Globalization has threatened the future growth of the industry ...
(Date:4/29/2016)... ... April 29, 2016 , ... Dr. Robert Mondavi, one of ... improve smiles. Cosmetic dentistry is a fast-growing field as more patients are discovering the ... to learn more about the options currently available to them and which ones might ...
(Date:4/29/2016)... , ... April 29, 2016 , ... For those who ... the meal to miss. That was among the many new lifestyle diet tips offered ... recent Sharon Kleyne Hour® Power of Water® radio show. Bonny and Lawrence noted that ...
(Date:4/29/2016)... ... 2016 , ... Regenerative Medicine Solutions (RMS) scored 94.8124 out of ... them second place for Tampa’s Best Places to Work. They were ranked in the ... great accomplishment for our team,” says RMS Human Resources Manager Irene Miller. “We work ...
(Date:4/29/2016)... ... April 29, 2016 , ... Nike Softball Camp at ... from July 24th – 27th for girls aged 10-18. All facets of the game ... the beautiful Clark V. Whited Complex, one of the finest softball facilities in the ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:4/27/2016)... April 27, 2016 Transparency Market ... Devices Market - Global Industry Analysis, Size, Share, Growth, ... report, the global skincare devices market was valued at ... expand at a CAGR of 10.1% from 2015 to ... Browse the full Skincare Devices Market (Treatment Device - ...
(Date:4/27/2016)... DUBLIN , April 27, 2016 /PRNewswire/ ... the addition of the  "Global Anesthesia Disposables ... (Logo: http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20160330/349511LOGO ) ,The global ... at a CAGR of 4.03% during the ... are a major threat to patients, safety. ...
(Date:4/26/2016)... 26, 2016 Diplomat Pharmacy, Inc. (NYSE: DPLO) ... Hagerman , Pharm D., to Vice President of Education ... Diplomat, Hagerman will continue to lead and oversee Diplomat ... custom education and training to Diplomat employees and external ... Diplomat University also houses the quality assurance department, which ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: