Navigation Links
Mom was right: Nice guys don't always finish last
Date:11/5/2009

BINGHAMTON, NY -- Picture it: One jerk in a bar spends the night delivering bad come-ons to women. By the end of the evening, the women aren't receptive to even the nicest guys around.

It's a scenario with a basis in evolutionary theory. Males increase their fitness by acquiring more mates; however, this is often not the case for females and therein lies the conflict.

Researchers at Binghamton University and the University of Arizona studied sexual conflict in water striders, an insect that's a common model system. They found that, given a choice, females will group themselves around the gentlemen.

The results of the groundbreaking experiment in which the insects had a freedom of movement not possible in most studies of sexual conflict appear in the Nov. 6 edition of the prestigious journal Science.

"The original title of the paper was 'Nice Guys Don't Always Finish Last,'" lead author Omar Tonsi Eldakar said. "I find that statement to be quite descriptive of the project."

Previous studies of sexual conflict generally have limited individual movement, emphasizing local competition, noted Eldakar, a 2008 PhD graduate of Binghamton University and a post-doctoral fellow with the Center for Insect Science at the University of Arizona.

Eldakar said he perceives sexual conflict as an example of the "tragedy of the commons," a situation in which the most exploitive strategy benefits the individual at the expense of the group. (The classic example is of a shepherd who adds another animal to his herd even though the shared pasture is overgrazed.) Few researchers have framed sexual conflict in these terms; however, Eldakar sees a parallel between that shared pasture and the availability of females.

"When you pit exploitation against prudence in direct competition over a shared resource, you're putting them into a scenario that favors the short-term, exploitative strategy, making it difficult to observe the advantage of prudence," he said. "This does not accurately reflect what occurs in natural populations. But given a choice, females look for a way to get away from persistent males. If you allow individuals to self-organize, females find these nice guys and group around them, changing the landscape of competition."

Eldakar and his colleagues have shown through previous studies that groups in which a more gentlemanly approach to mating prevails do better on the whole, even though jerks generally outperform the nice guys when they have to compete one-on-one.

Eldakar thought of the insects as "nice guys" vs. "jerks;" his adviser, David Sloan Wilson, a co-author of the paper and a distinguished professor of biological sciences at Binghamton, termed them "gentlemen" vs. "psychopaths."

"The presence of psychopaths dramatically reduced the productivity of the population," Wilson said. "When all the males were gentlemen, the females laid about three times more eggs than they did when all the males were psychopaths. And yet within each group the psychopaths were doing better than the gentlemen. How do the gentlemen persist if they're disadvantaged within the group?"

Once the females could move between groups, the researchers had their answer. Eldakar and Michael J. Dlugos, then also a Binghamton graduate student, devised a wading pool equipped with special doors that could restrict movement between groups or allow the insects to move freely.

"When they opened the doors, the females would leave whenever a psychopath came around," Wilson said. "The whole thing resulted in a heterogeneity in which the females were clustered with the gentlemen. It's the movement of individuals that creates these differences between groups that favor nonaggressive males."


'/>"/>

Contact: Gail Glover
gglover@binghamton.edu
607-777-2174
Binghamton University
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Scientific Journal Gene Therapy Reports That Cardiums Gene Activated Matrix Technology Accelerates Periodontal Tissue Regeneration
2. Florida Gentle Dental Dentists Giving Away Smile Makeover and Orthodontic Braces at 7th Annual Our Kids World Family Fun Festival
3. Patients with moderate to severe periodontitis need evaluation for heart disease risk
4. Top Dentist Issues Opinion on Health Benefits of Cutting-Edge Orthodontics
5. Over half of people with rheumatoid arthritis have periodontitis
6. Journal of Periodontology and the American Journal of Cardiology develop joint clinical recommendations
7. Scientists find shared genetic link between the dental disease periodontitis and heart attack
8. New Jersey Orthodontist Patrick T. Cuozzo Launches User-Friendly, State-of-the-Art New Website
9. The American Academy of Periodontology issues statement on periodontal treatment during pregnancy
10. Dental Implants Effective for Orthodontic Treatment
11. Dr. Ron Greenspan has Been Selected for the 2008 Best of San Diego Award in the Orthodontists Category by the U.S. Local Business Association
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/26/2016)... ... , ... North Cypress Medical Center hosted its 9th Annual Spring ... the help of community partners, the event organizers raised $45,000 for the Lone ... members and their families through health, wellness, and therapeutic support. , A special ...
(Date:5/26/2016)... ... May 26, 2016 , ... The MIAMI Institute for Age Management ... Dr. Adonis Maiquez MD, ABAARM. Dr. Adonis , Wellness Physician of the MIAMI ... member of the Institute for Functional Medicine. , He also heads up FITTLab, the ...
(Date:5/26/2016)... ... May 26, 2016 , ... Bunion Bootie , the ... bunionette) treatment was more than humbled by customer demand over the Mother’s Day Weekend ... mid sale. Now that Bunion Bootie has completely replenished its inventory levels, it hopes ...
(Date:5/26/2016)... ... May 26, 2016 , ... A health conscious snack ... The Dough Bar, has ignited an undeniable buzz in the protein product community ... not just any doughnut.  These doughnuts are packed with 11 grams of protein and ...
(Date:5/26/2016)... ... 2016 , ... Metcalf & Associates’ Maureen Metcalf ... in leading technology and human resources operations for health care, education, banking, and ... featured on Metcalf’s VoiceAmerica radio show , Innovative Leaders Driving Thriving Organizations. ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/25/2016)... and GERMANTOWN, Maryland , May 25, ... QGEN ; Frankfurt Prime Standard: QIA) today announced that the ... Therawis Diagnostics GmbH to develop and commercialize predictive assays in ... PITX2 as a marker to predict effectiveness of anthracycline treatment ... "We are pleased to partner with Therawis, which developed ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... NEW YORK , May 25, 2016 ... Device Market Size, Share, Development, Growth and Demand Forecast ... Insulin Syringe, Insulin Pump and Others)" published by P&S ... valued at $9,998.3 million in 2015, and it is ... 2016-2022. Based on type, the insulin pump segment is ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... Digital Health Dialog, LLC dba EngagedMedia ... US Patent and Trademark Office of U.S. Patent ... for electronic opt-­in and processing of discount coupons ... compliance and otherwise. Logo - http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20160524/371583LOGO ... "Our technology allows for individuals to opt­-in to ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: