Navigation Links
Minimally Invasive Surgery Not Better for Sciatica
Date:7/7/2009

Faster recovery, less pain with conventional operation

TUESDAY, July 7 (HealthDay News) -- Minimally invasive surgery for the excruciating back pain that can be caused by sciatica didn't work as well as the conventional procedure in a Dutch study.

"The expected treatment benefit of a faster rate of recovery from sciatica after tubular diskectomy could not be reproduced by this double-blind study," according to a report in the July 8 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Orthopedic surgeons at the Medical Center Haaglanden studied 328 people who underwent surgery for sciatic pain, and found that "the overall differences in pain intensity and recovery rates favored the conventional microdiskectomy."

Surgery is done to remove the portion of a disk that has ruptured and causes pain by pressing on the sciatic nerve. The older method, microdiskectomy, is done through a larger incision than that used for transmuscular tubular diskectomy, the minimally invasive technique that was introduced in 1997 and has gained wide popularity. But only a few studies comparing results of the two techniques have been reported.

"The reason why it [minimally invasive surgery] did not work could be because our conventional technique uses a small incision as well," said study author Dr. Mark P. Arts.

Minimally invasive surgery might still be recommended in some cases, Arts noted. "We are still working on our subgroup analysis, but possibly the tubular diskectomy is indicated in obese patients in whom a large incision and exposure is inevitable," he said.

But more patients probably will prefer the conventional approach, Arts said. "We will discuss the results of our study with our patients and their prejudiced opinion of small being better will probably change into, 'Do what's best for me,'" he said.

The results of the Dutch study were no surprise to Dr. Todd J. Albert, directo
'/>"/>

Copyright©2009 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Minimally Invasive Heart Surgery Research Wins N.I.H. Award
2. Novadaq launches PINPOINT: Companys first minimally invasive imaging system
3. Published Results Using AtriCure Minimally Invasive Products
4. Awake the Movie Highlights the Need for Goldilocks Anesthesia, Says Dr. Barry L. Friedberg, Developer of Bispectral Index (BIS) Monitored Propofol Ketamine Sedation, Now Trademarked as Minimally Invasive Anesthesia (MIA)(R)
5. Z-shaped incision enhances minimally-invasive surgery
6. Z-shaped incision enhances minimally invasive surgery
7. Minimally Invasive Surgery Fixes Aneurysms
8. Northwestern Memorials Heart Center Pioneers Minimally Invasive Surgery That Corrects Irregular Heart Beat
9. Minimally invasive fibroid treatment fares well in multicenter trial
10. Women Can Now Learn About Minimally Invasive Gynecologic Treatments at AAGL.org
11. Robot-assisted minimally-invasive CABG surgery
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Minimally Invasive Surgery Not Better for Sciatica
(Date:12/20/2014)... 2014 Parker & Sons, Inc. a ... of experience in contractor services announces reaching a milestone ... the homeowners of Arizona. Parker and Sons is comprised ... technicians that make customer service the number one priority. ... and started with one service vehicle and has since ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... It’s very easy to become overwhelmed with the holidays ... the wayside until Christmas and the New Year are over. ... that burning desire to just escape it all and get ... Telluride with a no-fuss, affordable package. Montrose Days Inn will ... and ensure that all accommodations are met. Plus, everyone has ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... FL (PRWEB) December 19, 2014 ... Revitalizing Bedsheets are now available. Celliant, the world’s ... both sheets and pillowcases. , There are a ... proven additional circulation, increased oxygenation and balanced body ... faster healing and pain relief; enhanced athletic performance; ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... SuperCloset raises the bar once again, ... to offer indoor growers the most efficient and effective ... SuperClone Rooms with the award winning SuperRooms ... grow room setup. , The SuperClone Room features the ... SuperCloner 50 . The SuperClone Room pairs ...
(Date:12/19/2014)... An evening dress is perfect for any occasion and is ... dresses retailer, has unveiled its new selection of evening dresses. ... shopping platform. Customers can view more at its ... been accepted and praised by customers for many years. It ... clients. In order to expand its market share, the company ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Parker & Sons Announces Reaching A Milestone By Providing 40 Years Of Dedicated Contractor Services For Homeowners Of Arizona 2Health News:Parker & Sons Announces Reaching A Milestone By Providing 40 Years Of Dedicated Contractor Services For Homeowners Of Arizona 3Health News:Days Inn Montrose Colorado Delivers Last Minute Holiday Season Ski Getaway Accommodations 2Health News:Energy Textiles Launches Celliant Revitalizing Bedsheets 2Health News:SuperCloset Continues to Innovate with New Complete Indoor Grow Room Packages, The SuperClone Rooms are the Newest Addition to the Award Winning SuperRoom Lineup 2Health News:Attractive Evening Dresses Announced by Discount-Dress.com 2
... Living Hope Health Fair ... County is being hosted by Living Hope Church on the Brush Prairie campus Feb. 26 from ... dads will all find fun and information at Hope 4 a Healthier You. , ... (PRWEB) February 20, 2010 -- The largest and most ...
... ... ... , ... ...
... ... ... ... ...
... Loyola University Medical Center ranked among the top hospitals ... pathologists in training. Loyola was tied for the ... accepted in the Stowell-Orbison Awards competition sponsored by the ... hundred academic programs worldwide participated in the competition. ...
... work, but application remains years away , FRIDAY, Feb. 19 ... to hint that gene therapy could become a weapon against ... far from being ready for use by patients, and would ... "a step in the direction of using gene therapy" to ...
... ... ... ... ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Vancouver, Washington -- Free Family Fun at Health Fair 2Health News:California Dental Association Foundation Expands Care to State's Underserved Communities 2Health News:California Dental Association Foundation Expands Care to State's Underserved Communities 3Health News:California Dental Association Foundation Expands Care to State's Underserved Communities 4Health News:California Dental Association Foundation Expands Care to State's Underserved Communities 5Health News:Idaho Legislators Stand for Health Care Freedom 2Health News:Idaho Legislators Stand for Health Care Freedom 3Health News:Idaho Legislators Stand for Health Care Freedom 4Health News:Gene Therapy Shows Promise Against HIV 2Health News:Health Groups Ask Supreme Court to Authorize Financial Penalties on Tobacco Companies for Decades of Wrongdoing 2Health News:Health Groups Ask Supreme Court to Authorize Financial Penalties on Tobacco Companies for Decades of Wrongdoing 3
(Date:12/17/2014)... , The new ... of information concerning the biopharmaceutical Group,s national and international clinical ... to the recently launched institutional website that is receiving accolades ... by a new chapter in the fascinating story of Drug ... and panoramic hub on the world of clinical research, ranging ...
(Date:12/17/2014)... Mass. , Dec. 17, 2014  RXi ... biotechnology company focused on discovering, developing and commercializing ... RNA-targeted technologies, today announced completion of enrollment in its ... from the 3-month observations confirmed the 1-month findings ... Logo - http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20130917/NE80755LOGO ...
(Date:12/15/2014)... , December 15, 2014 ... Am 19. und 20. Februar sind alle ... SAFE MEDICINE ECOSYSTEM PARTNER PROGRAMM ™ 2015 ... besuchen. Diese Tagung soll dazu ... Möglichkeit geben, die neue profitablen Unternehmensdienstleistungen, die ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Dompé Offers a New "Window" on the World of Scientific Research, with the http://www.dompetrials.com Website, Dedicated to Clinical Trials 2Dompé Offers a New "Window" on the World of Scientific Research, with the http://www.dompetrials.com Website, Dedicated to Clinical Trials 3RXi Pharmaceuticals Announces Sustained Effect of RXI-109 at Three Months Post Scar Revision Surgery and the Completion of Enrollment for its Phase 2a Trial RXI-109-1301 2RXi Pharmaceuticals Announces Sustained Effect of RXI-109 at Three Months Post Scar Revision Surgery and the Completion of Enrollment for its Phase 2a Trial RXI-109-1301 3RXi Pharmaceuticals Announces Sustained Effect of RXI-109 at Three Months Post Scar Revision Surgery and the Completion of Enrollment for its Phase 2a Trial RXI-109-1301 4RXi Pharmaceuticals Announces Sustained Effect of RXI-109 at Three Months Post Scar Revision Surgery and the Completion of Enrollment for its Phase 2a Trial RXI-109-1301 5Symposium über Aegates Ecosystem-Partner-Programm für sichere Medikamente vom 19. - 20. Februar 2015 in Amsterdam 2
... analyzer is an affordable system offering ... reliability and consistency of state-of-the-art instrument-based ... way to obtain dependable urine chemistry ... economy of motion and superior efficiency ...
... device consists of a non-compliant balloon with ... longitudinally on its outer surface. When the ... atherotomes score the plaque, creating initiation sites ... as Atherotomy, allows dilatation of the target ...
... intravascular catheters provide a simple, efficient ... pressures in the heart or cardiovascular ... are ideal for high fidelity pressure ... from 2 to 7 French and ...
... intravascular catheters provide a simple, efficient ... pressures in the heart or cardiovascular ... are ideal for high fidelity pressure ... from 2 to 7 French and ...
Medicine Products: