Navigation Links
Minimally Invasive Surgery Not Better for Sciatica
Date:7/7/2009

Faster recovery, less pain with conventional operation

TUESDAY, July 7 (HealthDay News) -- Minimally invasive surgery for the excruciating back pain that can be caused by sciatica didn't work as well as the conventional procedure in a Dutch study.

"The expected treatment benefit of a faster rate of recovery from sciatica after tubular diskectomy could not be reproduced by this double-blind study," according to a report in the July 8 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Orthopedic surgeons at the Medical Center Haaglanden studied 328 people who underwent surgery for sciatic pain, and found that "the overall differences in pain intensity and recovery rates favored the conventional microdiskectomy."

Surgery is done to remove the portion of a disk that has ruptured and causes pain by pressing on the sciatic nerve. The older method, microdiskectomy, is done through a larger incision than that used for transmuscular tubular diskectomy, the minimally invasive technique that was introduced in 1997 and has gained wide popularity. But only a few studies comparing results of the two techniques have been reported.

"The reason why it [minimally invasive surgery] did not work could be because our conventional technique uses a small incision as well," said study author Dr. Mark P. Arts.

Minimally invasive surgery might still be recommended in some cases, Arts noted. "We are still working on our subgroup analysis, but possibly the tubular diskectomy is indicated in obese patients in whom a large incision and exposure is inevitable," he said.

But more patients probably will prefer the conventional approach, Arts said. "We will discuss the results of our study with our patients and their prejudiced opinion of small being better will probably change into, 'Do what's best for me,'" he said.

The results of the Dutch study were no surprise to Dr. Todd J. Albert, director of the department of orthopedic surgery at the Rothman Institute of Thomas Jefferson University in Philadelphia.

"We have people in our unit who did a similar study and found very similar results," Albert said. That study has been submitted to a medical journal for publication, he noted.

Any minimally invasive surgical technique is bound to be popular "because the public wants a less invasive procedure if it accomplishes the same thing," Albert said. "Sometimes it pans out and sometimes it doesn't. With knee surgery it has, but minimally invasive hip surgery, which was a big rage a few years ago, is not necessarily better."

In his practice, Albert said, surgery for sciatic pain is done with a procedure halfway between the conventional and minimally invasive methods. "Maybe my incision is a half a centimeter longer than for microdiskectomy," he said. "We find the window where the disk is pressing on the nerve and push it out. It is much more like the open-surgery approach."

In practical terms, the real question about surgery for sciatica is not which technique should be used but whether surgery should be done, said Dr. Michael Y. Wang, an associate professor of neurological surgery and rehabilitation medicine at the University of Miami Miller School of Medicine.

"In general, the answer is, when you have a neurological deficit or intractable pain or a problem threatening loss in terms of neurological function," Wang said. The most common reason is to ease pain, he said.

The differences shown in the Dutch study are not great enough to say that one procedure is clearly preferable over the other, Wang noted. "I use the conventional technique even though I'm a minimally invasive surgeon," he said. "For sciatica, the minimally invasive method is too complicated and involved."

The Dutch results are not directly transferable to the United States for several reasons, Wang said. For example, those who had surgery in the study stayed an average of 3.3 days in the hospital. Such a long stay is virtually unheard of in the United States, where hospital discharge is almost always done a day or two after surgery, Wang said.

More information

Sciatica and its treatment are described by the U.S. National Library of Medicine.



SOURCES: Mark P. Arts, M.D., neurosurgeon, Medical Center Haaglanden, the Hague, Netherlands; Todd J. Albert, M.D., director, department of orthopedic surgery, Rothman Institute of Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia; Michael Y. Yang, M.D., associate professor, neurological surgery and rehabilitation medicine, University of Miami Miller School of Medicine; July 8, 2009, Journal of the American Medical Association


'/>"/>
Copyright©2009 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. Minimally Invasive Heart Surgery Research Wins N.I.H. Award
2. Novadaq launches PINPOINT: Companys first minimally invasive imaging system
3. Published Results Using AtriCure Minimally Invasive Products
4. Awake the Movie Highlights the Need for Goldilocks Anesthesia, Says Dr. Barry L. Friedberg, Developer of Bispectral Index (BIS) Monitored Propofol Ketamine Sedation, Now Trademarked as Minimally Invasive Anesthesia (MIA)(R)
5. Z-shaped incision enhances minimally-invasive surgery
6. Z-shaped incision enhances minimally invasive surgery
7. Minimally Invasive Surgery Fixes Aneurysms
8. Northwestern Memorials Heart Center Pioneers Minimally Invasive Surgery That Corrects Irregular Heart Beat
9. Minimally invasive fibroid treatment fares well in multicenter trial
10. Women Can Now Learn About Minimally Invasive Gynecologic Treatments at AAGL.org
11. Robot-assisted minimally-invasive CABG surgery
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Minimally Invasive Surgery Not Better for Sciatica
(Date:1/23/2017)... NY (PRWEB) , ... January 23, 2017 , ... ... today that John J. Nelson, a senior accountant at the Firm, will participate in ... Make-A-Wish® Hudson Valley. Over 200 runners will race up 1,576 steps, a vertical distance ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... ... 23, 2017 , ... Wooden and plastic balance boards have been around since at least the ... Board is the first and only balance board to use a patent-pending design featuring ... at the same time as well as skill-level adjustable for all ages and abilities. ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... ... January 23, 2017 , ... ... Crystallization in Process Chemistry by Applying Simple PAT Tools . , ... to isolate and purify the desired product. Chemists now spend more time ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... , ... January 23, 2017 ... ... Foundation (OREF), in partnership with the American Society of Anesthesiologists® (ASA®), the ... (APSF), the American Academy of Orthopaedic Surgeons (AAOS) and the Cigna Foundation, ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... ... ... “Life Under Blankets”: an entrancing story about one woman's travels through the wilderness ... of published author, Kimberly Mitchell, who earned her bachelor’s degree in English education at ... master’s degree in education in the field of curriculum and instruction. Kimberly’s passion for ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/23/2017)... Consolidated Stability Storage is Leading to CROs ... Outsourcing Market This research service on the global ... and technologies, and provides a snapshot of the key ... and forecasts are provided from 2016 to 2020. ... CAGR of 9.4% till 2020, driven by an explosion ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... -- MouthWatch LLC announced today that its flagship product, the ... intraoral camera on DentalCompare,s list of Top Dental Products ... product was the CollaPlug Absorbable Collagen Wound Dressing . ... popular because it is by far the most economical option ... it doesn,t sacrifice quality imaging." ...
(Date:1/23/2017)... , Jan. 23, 2017 7D Surgical ... clearance from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration ... Canada enabling the North American commercial launch of ... for spine surgery, the 7D Surgical System.  ... 3D optical technologies and machine vision algorithms to ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: