Navigation Links
Medicare Faces Challenges Caring for Chronically Ill
Date:2/10/2009

Initiatives to lower costs, improve service seldom work, study finds

TUESDAY, Feb. 10 (HealthDay News) -- Only a fraction of Medicare pilot programs aimed at cutting costs and improving care for people with chronic illness actually did the job, a new study shows.

That doesn't necessarily mean that ideas like these should be abandoned altogether, however.

Based on the findings, "we should not expect these care coordination efforts to pay for themselves or to save money," said Paul Precht, director for policy and communications at the Medicare Rights Center. "But that doesn't mean they're not worth doing, because when they work right, they can deliver better health for people."

And what makes them work right?

"If you target the programs well on people who have the right level of severity of illness and types of illnesses, and you have certain features, then you can have an impact on hospitalization rates. That's the key," said study senior author Randall Brown, vice president and director of health research at Mathematica Policy Research Inc. in Princeton, N.J. Mathematica designed this pilot project.

"The more that providers and particularly the physicians are directly involved and the more the physicians are part of an integrated network that includes the other specialties, the better [a particular program] works," added Precht.

The findings were published in the Feb. 11 issue of the Journal of the American Medical Association.

Most experts agree that exploding costs and the prospect of an empty purse threaten Medicare's future. According to an accompanying editorial, Medicare expenditures will top $400 billion this year, a hefty 13 percent of the total federal budget.

One study found that in 2002, about half of beneficiaries who had been treated for five or more conditions accounted for 75 percent of total spending.

Most of the costs associated with chronic illness come from hospital stays which, in turn, are often due to inadequate care between admissions (lack of counseling on improving lifestyle factors, lack of adherence to medication regimens, etc.).

One proposed solution is to better coordinate care between different physicians and other health care providers.

This complex analysis looked at 15 care-coordination programs involving more than 18,000 fee-for-service Medicare patients with chronic problems such as congestive heart failure, coronary artery disease and diabetes. Each program included between 178 and 2,657 patients. Care was assessed after individuals had been in the program at least seven months. The outcomes were then compared to those of a control group consisting of "usual care."

Only two of the 15 programs showed any significant difference in hospitalization rates, and one of those actually involved an increase of 0.118 admissions per person per year.

In one program, Mercy Medical Center in rural northwestern Iowa achieved 0.168 fewer admissions per person per year, 17 percent less than the control group.

Not one of the programs resulted in net savings, although three programs --- including Mercy and Health Quality Partners (HQP) in Pennsylvania -- did achieve some savings. HQP also had "close to significant effects on hospitalizations," Brown said.

The two success stories, Mercy and HQP, had certain features in common, namely more contact between nurse-coordinators and patients and more contact between coordinators and physicians.

"Both these programs had good relationships with local hospitals and with patients' physicians," Brown said. "The care coordinator knew the physicians, because they were either located in the same facility or the physicians set aside space for the care coordinator to interact with patients when the patients came in for a visit. They bumped into each other a lot."

Overall, however, the picture was not a positive one.

"It is discouraging. I think there's good reason to be skeptical of what these stand-alone disease-management companies can do," Precht said. "The record is mixed, but it's pretty clear, they don't save money."

More information

There's more on specific programs at the Medicare Web site.



SOURCES: Randall Brown, Ph.D., vice president and director, health research, Mathematica Policy Research Inc., Princeton, N.J.; Paul Precht, director, policy and communications, Medicare Rights Center; Feb. 11, 2009, Journal of the American Medical Association


'/>"/>
Copyright©2009 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. CDS Completes Large-Scale Transition of Medicare Data Processing
2. Medicare Drug Plan Doughnut Hole Could Impact Seniors Health
3. Seniors in Medicares doughnut hole decrease use of meds
4. First Coast Service Options Announces Start up of New Medicare Contract
5. Nurses to Congress: Expanding Medicare Could Reverse Job Losses, and Repair Our Broken Healthcare System and Safety Net
6. CMS Selects Thomson Reuters to Help Implement Medicare Medical Home Demonstration Project for Medicare Recipients
7. Burgess to Co-Chair and Serve as Lead Sponsor for WRGs 2009 The Business Of Medicare Advantage Forum
8. PWeR(TM) Platform Available to Increase Provider Reimbursements From Medicare
9. A Newly Approved CMS Medicare Package Expands Reimbursement Coverage for Telehealth Originating Sites Beginning January 1, 2009
10. Actuaries Laud New Presidents Medicare and Social Security Message, Call for Bipartisan Solution
11. American Association for Homecare Criticizes Release of Controversial Medicare Bidding Rule in Final Hours of Bush Administration
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Medicare Faces Challenges Caring for Chronically Ill
(Date:1/20/2017)... ... 20, 2017 , ... Vitamin Well has launched two new ... have been produced in collaboration with Zlatan Ibrahimovic and have been developed to ... a successful launch in Sweden last year, the next generation sports drinks VW+001 ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... ... January 20, 2017 , ... “Code Word: Chocolate Biscuit”: a biographical account following a man ... is the creation of published author, Marlyn Ivey, born in Lynn Haven, Florida and at ... school and at 19 years of age, he joined the Navy and got married right ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... ... 20, 2017 , ... “Christmas in Suffolk”: a story of love, secrets, ... lives in Lafayette, Indiana where she works in a daycare and looks for inspiration ... Published by Christian Faith Publishing, Sara Seymour’s new book is an adventure of love ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... ... January 20, 2017 , ... “The Land of More and ... the issue of world hunger, and shares the simple and achievable answer. “The Land ... and member of the Fairview Missionary Church in Angola, Indiana where he works with ...
(Date:1/19/2017)... ... January 19, 2017 , ... ... On-demand E-learning system for Clinical and Regulatory education for Physicians, Physician Advisors, ... Aerolib`s successful education methodology of Disease Specific Documentation Improvement. , The Aerolib ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/20/2017)... DUBLIN , Jan 20, 2017 ... "Global Hearing Aids Market (by Devices, Implant Types, OTC Amplifiers, ... report to their offering. ... Global Hearing Aids Market Sales Volume, ... of the fast-evolving, high-growth hearing aid industry. The ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... Stock-Callers.com today evaluates the following Drug Manufacturers equities: ... A/S (NYSE: NVO ), Sucampo Pharmaceuticals Inc. (NASDAQ: ... PTX ). These stocks belong to the Healthcare ... finishing near its session lows. As per a NASDAQ report, ... of health care companies in the S&P 500 also were ...
(Date:1/20/2017)... 2017  Palladian Health, a leading provider of ... of an opioid management program which assists physicians ... helps stem the growing tide of dependence on ... chronic non-cancer pain (back pain, neck pain, and ... of evidence regarding long-term effectiveness. The ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: