Navigation Links
Medicare: Barrier to hospice increases hospitalization
Date:10/31/2012

PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] A Medicare rule that blocks thousands of nursing home residents from receiving simultaneous reimbursement for hospice and skilled nursing facility (SNF) care at the end of life may result in those residents receiving more aggressive treatment and hospitalization, according a new analysis.

"This study is the first, to the knowledge of the authors, to attempt to understand how treatments and outcomes vary for nursing home residents with advanced dementia who use Medicare SNF care near the end of life and who do or do not enroll in Medicare hospice," wrote researchers, including lead author Susan Miller, research professor of health services policy and practice at Brown University, in the Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

Miller said the outcomes are often unwanted treatments.

"Unfortunately, given the high use of Medicare skilled care near the end of life and policy that prevents simultaneous Medicare reimbursement for skilled nursing and hospice care, aggressive treatments that may not be the preference of families or their loved ones are common," she said.

The federal government will investigate this issue under the Medicare Hospice Concurrent Care demonstration project mandated by the Affordable Care Act.

About half of all nursing home residents dying with advanced dementia have Medicare SNF care in the last 90 days of life, but residents with this care are not allowed to receive simultaneous hospice and SNF Medicare reimbursement for the same terminal illness. The two services have different medical goals.

Because of the rule, previous research has reported, 46 percent of residents with advanced dementia but no SNF use hospice, while only 30 percent of similar residents who do have SNF use hospice (some residents can still end up with both services simultaneously if, for instance, SNF addresses a different condition than their terminal illness).

What Miller and her colleagues found is that whether and when SNF patients have access to hospice makes an important difference in the care they receive at end of life. That matters to many families, because it is not an easy decision, emotionally or financially, to give up SNF in favor of hospice.

"What I've heard from physicians is that families may be advised about hospice, but when the family learns that by choosing hospice and thus giving up SNF they'd have to pay for the entire nursing home stay, they will choose SNF over hospice," she said. "One physician told me a story about a significant other who wanted hospice for their family member. It was cheaper for that person just to quit their job, stay home and care for the person and get hospice rather than to pay for nursing home care because the nursing home cost more than they were making."

To conduct her analysis, Miller and her co-authors studied the Medicare records of 4,344 nursing home residents with SNF care and advanced dementia who died in 2006. Of the sample, 1,086 received hospice care either concurrent with SNF or afterward. The other 3,528 patients were demographically and medically similar, but did not receive hospice care.

One of team's key findings was that residents with hospice either during or after SNF care were far less likely to die in the hospital than people without hospice. Those with concurrent SNF and hospice were 87 percent less likely to die in the hospital. Those with hospice after SNF were 98 percent less likely. In the meantime, the data showed the patients with hospice received less aggressive treatments in many other ways. Fewer received feeding tubes, medications (except hypnotic and antianxiety drugs), IV fluids, and occupational or physical therapy than those with no hospice.

The researchers also measured two key outcomes that were more complicated to interpret: persistent difficulty breathing and persistent pain. Residents with hospice after SNF were 37 percent less likely than those without hospice to experience persistent difficulty breathing, or dyspnea, but residents with concurrent hospice and SNF had no significant difference in their experience of this problem. With persistent pain, those with hospice after SNF were not less likely to experience it than residents with no hospice, but those with concurrent SNF and hospice were 65 percent more likely to experience pain.

Miller said that the pain comparison, in particular, is puzzling because of the subjectivity of measuring pain and the likelihood that people who elect hospice care do so in part because of elevated levels of pain.

Overall, Miller said, the results show that the Medicare rule that reduces access to hospice at end of life significantly affects the treatment nursing home residents receive.

Whether it is worth it, from a cost perspective, to change the policy, is not clear, Miller said. The ACA-mandated demonstration will help answer that. But evidence from prior studies suggests that Medicare does tend to save money when nursing home residents do not have long hospice stays. Miller said she plans future studies to look at costs and alternative ways to bring palliative care to nursing home patients with advanced dementia.


'/>"/>

Contact: David Orenstein
david_orenstein@brown.edu
401-863-1862
Brown University
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Language Barrier Hurts Elderly Asthma Patients
2. Nurse leader resistance perceived as a barrier to high-quality, evidence-based patient care
3. Study identifies barriers to breast health care in Pakistan
4. Nano-devices that cross blood-brain barrier open door to treatment of cerebral palsy
5. Minorities Less Likely to Use Hospice Care: Study
6. ASTRO: Deviating from radiation protocols increases risk of treatment failure and death
7. Split-dose preparation for colonoscopy increases precancerous polyp detection rates
8. Mild increases in thyroid-stimulating hormone not harmful in the elderly
9. OSA increases cardiovascular mortality in the elderly
10. Prenatal diagnosis of congenital heart disease increases maternal stress, depression, and anxiety
11. Smoking after stroke increases death risk by 3-fold
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/24/2017)... ... 2017 , ... An in-depth computational analysis of genetic variants implicated in both ... genes that may explain why susceptibility to one of the disorders could place individuals ... today in the journal npj Schizophrenia. , “There is a wealth of genomic ...
(Date:2/24/2017)... ... February 24, 2017 , ... In the Health Care IT ... top priority because it’s not if you will be attacked, but when.” However, he ... comes to digital health care. , Improvements in auditing and monitoring have taken security ...
(Date:2/24/2017)... ... February 24, 2017 , ... The narrative in “ Signal ... Schanssema ’s true account of his paramedic experiences. Schanssema describes the tragedies he saw, ... his attempts to overcome them. , Schanssema, initially unsure of the career path he ...
(Date:2/24/2017)... , ... February 24, 2017 , ... Yisrayl Hawkins, Pastor ... on Bible Prophecy concerning this present generation. Yisrayl makes an astounding statement when ... generation. He explains that the Bible details the current times so plainly that ...
(Date:2/24/2017)... ... ... The Radiology Business Management Association will select the 2017 Quest ... Better Radiology Marketing Programs conference, held this year from March 5 to 7 ... given out in five categories. They are:, ,     Patient Marketing, a ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/23/2017)... -- LG Innotek hat heute die weltweit erste 70 mw ... 1,5-fache des 45-mW-Moduls der Konkurrenz. UV-C LED ... 280 nm und eignet sich damit für Sterilisationsaufgaben. Es verhindert ... Das Produkt von LG Innotek erzeugt UV-Strahlung im Bereich ... ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... and Markets has announced the addition of the "Menopause Drugs Price ... ... Analysis and Strategies - 2016, provides drug pricing data and benchmarks in ... What are the key drugs marketed for Menopause ... market? What are the unit prices and annual treatment ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... REDWOOD CITY, Calif. , Feb. 23, 2017 ... specialty pharmaceutical company focused on the development and ... moderate-to-severe acute pain, announced that it will release ... close on Thursday, March 2nd, 2017. AcelRx management ... p.m. Eastern Time (1:30 p.m. Pacific Time) on ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: