Navigation Links
Media reports may paint overly optimistic view of cancer
Date:3/16/2010

Newspaper and magazine reports about cancer appear more likely to discuss aggressive treatment and survival than death, treatment failure or adverse events, and almost none mention end-of-life palliative or hospice care, according to a report in the March 22 issue of Archives of Internal Medicine, one of the JAMA/Archives journals.

The report is one of three in the issue being released early to coincide with a JAMA media briefing on cancer in Washington, D.C. The March issues of Archives of Pediatrics & Adolescent Medicine, Archives of Neurology, Archives of Ophthalmology, Archives of Dermatology, Archives of Surgery, Archives of Facial Plastic Surgery and Archives of OtolaryngologyHead & Neck Surgery have also published articles on this topic.

It is estimated that one in two men and one in three women will be diagnosed with cancer in their lifetime, according to background information in the article. Of these, approximately half will die of cancer or related complications; more than half a million Americans are expected to die of cancer every year. "These figures have given cancer a prominent place in news reporting," the authors write.

Jessica Fishman, Ph.D., and colleagues at the University of Pennsylvania, Philadelphia, conducted a content analysis of cancer news reporting between 2005 and 2007 in eight large U.S. newspapers and five national magazines. Of 2,228 cancer-related articles that appeared, a random sample of 436 was selected (312 from newspapers and 124 from magazines). Trained coders determined the proportion of articles devoted to various cancer-related topics.

The articles were most likely to focus on breast cancer (35.1 percent) or prostate cancer (14.9 percent), and 87 (20 percent) discussed cancer in general. A total of 140 (32.1 percent) focused on individuals surviving or being cured of cancer, whereas 33 (7.6 percent) focused on one or more patients who were dying or had died of cancer. Ten articles (2.3 percent) focused on both survival and death.

"It is surprising that few articles discuss death and dying considering that half of all patients diagnosed as having cancer will not survive," the authors write. "The findings are also surprising given that scientists, media critics and the lay public repeatedly criticize the news for focusing on death."

In addition, few articles (57, or 13.1 percent) reported that aggressive cancer treatments can fail to extend life or cure the disease, or that some cancers are incurable. Less than one-third of the articles (131, or 30 percent) mentioned adverse events associated with cancer treatments, such as nausea, pain or hair loss.

Most articles (249, or 57.1 percent) discussed aggressive treatments exclusively, but almost none (two, or 0.5 percent) discussed end-of-life care only and only 11 (2.5 percent) discussed both. "For many patients with cancer, it is important to know about palliative and hospice care because this information can help them make decisions that realistically reflect their prognosis and the risks and potential benefits of treatment," the authors write.

After adjusting for article length, there were no differences between magazine and newspaper articles in regards to any of these factors, the authors note.

"How often should the news media discuss treatment failure, adverse events, end-of-life care and death and dying? Although there is no quantifiable answer, the same educational goals that ideally drive news coverage of cancer treatment and survival should also compel news organizations to address these topics," the authors conclude. "The media routinely report about aggressive treatment and survival presumably because cancer news coverage is relevant to a large portion of the population, and, for the same reason, similar attention should be devoted to the alternatives."


'/>"/>

Contact: Joe Diorio
jdiorio@asc.upenn.edu
215-746-1798
JAMA and Archives Journals
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. AUDIO from Medialink and Radica: Staying Sharp with Games for Your Brain
2. AUDIO from Medialink and Kelloggs: Whats in Your Water?
3. AUDIO from Medialink and Commit Lozenge: Wanna Quit Smoking With Therapeutic Nicotine? Just Follow the Directions
4. AUDIO from Medialink and Pfizer: Number of Uninsured Americans Grows to 47 Million
5. Justice Department to Hold Media Event to Demonstrate New Database for Matching Unidentified Remains and Missing Persons Information
6. Weiner Public News First Media Team at National Press Club 5K
7. VIDEO from Medialink and General Motors: On and Off the Track
8. HealthMedia Revolution Explodes in Second Quarter
9. AUDIO from Medialink and Pfizer: Prescription for Safer Drugs Discussed in Washington
10. AUDIO from Medialink and Allergan: Women Not Sure Who to Trust on Anti-Aging Skin Care
11. AUDIO from Medialink and Pfizer: A New Prescription for Safer Drugs
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/25/2016)... ... , ... One Florida-based plastic surgeon’s enthusiasm is proving to be contagious among ... May 13th on Vanity Fair. In fact, as the article explains, more than a ... more than 800,000 Snapchat fans. Commenting on this trend, Dr. Michael Salzhauer, also known ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... , ... May 25, 2016 , ... The Bank of ... Biomedical Technology Program to help provide veterans a pathway to employment and successful careers ... a $20,000 check to Nick Hallack, President and CEO of Medisend, parent organization and ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... ... May 25, 2016 , ... New studies ... of injured workers across 15 states. The outcomes examined in these studies include ... medical care, and satisfaction with medical care. , “The goal of the studies ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... , ... May 25, 2016 , ... Today Omega Institute, ... of 11 innovative workshops and training opportunities in the growing field of ... needs of individuals who are dealing with specific health issues—including injuries, illnesses, and temporary ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... ... May 25, 2016 , ... ... and products in the developing world, is pleased to release their 2015 global ... 5 million unwanted pregnancies, almost 14,000 maternal deaths and 3.8 million unsafe abortions ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/25/2016)... , May 25, 2016 Digital Health ... to it by the US Patent and Trademark ... technology includes proprietary processes for electronic opt-­in and ... and wellness programs, HIPAA compliance and otherwise. ... "Our technology allows for ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... May 24, 2016 Niederländische ... gebracht, die es Ärzten erlaubt, ihre Expertise weltweit ... MDLinking kombiniert Live Streaming mit einer Instant-Messaging-Funktion und ... kommunizieren. Mediziner in Europa, Afrika, Asien und den ... für die Plattform registriert. Information und ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... -- Diana Russell suffers from a form of rheumatoid arthritis ... This disease has put her in a wheelchair, and ... to leave her home.  Because of the size and ... wheelchair.  So if there is a family function, the ... to wait for the bus. Photo - ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: