Navigation Links
Mayo Clinic Proceedings provides forum for debate about capital punishment
Date:1/2/2008

ROCHESTER, Minn. -- In a commentary and two editorials published in the September 2007 issue of Mayo Clinic Proceedings, three anesthesiologists and a medical ethicist discussed whether doctors should participate in capital punishment executions. Since that issue was published, discussions about physician involvement in capital punishment have made their way into the state and federal court systems. And the North Carolina Medical Board has published a statement threatening to discipline physicians who actively participate in executions.

On Jan. 7, 2008, the U. S. Supreme Court will begin hearing arguments as to whether execution by lethal injection, as currently conducted, constitutes a form of cruel and unusual punishment. These new developments, as well as the earlier Proceedings articles, prompted a number of readers to write Proceedings editors and offer additional perspectives on this provocative topic. This lively discussion among physicians, ethicists and others appears in the January 2008 issue of the Mayo Clinic Proceedings and is highlighted below.

Lee Black and Mark Levine, M.D., from the American Medical Association Council on Ethical and Judicial Affairs, author a commentary entitled Ethical Prohibition Against Physician Participation in Capital Punishment. This article asserts that physicians must not participate in executions, as this action is contrary to the core concept of ethics of the medical profession.

Although it is easy to view the provision of comfort, appropriate in some venues, as a duty of physicians, it is simply not ethical to participate in an action that has as its sole purpose the death of an individual, says Black and Dr. Levine.

Participation in prisoner executions might cause patients to have difficulty believing that their physicians are always acting in their best interests, explain Black and Dr. Levine. And merely possessing a special set of skills that would allow physicians to ensure a proper and painless execution does not imply license to use these skills in any manner, they add.

Black and Dr. Levine remind readers that although they welcome discussion about this issue, Physicians are healers, not executioners.

In a second commentary, Mark Heath, M.D., an anesthesiologist from Columbia-Presbyterian Medical Center, offers details about how lethal injections are administered, the effects of the medications used, problems encountered in using this method of execution, and what bearing this information has on the debate over whether execution is, in fact, a medical procedure. Dr. Heath acknowledges that his views on this issue have been influenced by his experiences serving as an expert witness in court, where he testified on behalf of condemned prisoners acting to change execution procedures.

Dr. Heath describes how administration of general anesthesia is necessary to render the prisoner insensitive to pain before staff administer the heart-arresting drug potassium chloride. He explains that this combination of drugs is necessary because injection of concentrated potassium alone would be extremely painful.

For execution by potassium to be humane, the human central nervous system must be placed in a state such that the prisoner is insensitive to the extreme pain that would necessarily be experienced if he or she were conscious, writes Dr. Heath.

Dr. Heath also points out that prisoners currently involved in litigation on this issue want the Department of Corrections to either discontinue the use of these two drugs or provide properly qualified and equipped practitioners at the bedside to ensure that adequate anesthetic depth is established and maintained.

Describing a botched execution that took place in Florida, Dr. Heath says it was unfortunate that this procedure was administered by personnel who did not understand the responsibilities they were assuming and acknowledges that he is opposed to the death penalty and to physician participation in executions.

Following these two commentaries, the journal includes six letters to the editor from a variety of sources, as well as replies from the writers who first discussed this topic in the September 2007 Proceedings issue.

Mayo Clinic anesthesiologist William Lanier, M.D., Mayo Clinic Proceedings editor-in-chief, and anesthesiologist Keith Berge, M.D., also from Mayo, note in their reply that Proceedings welcomes the opportunity to provide a forum for debating this important and timely issue.

We physicians and other citizens now have the option of ignoring physician involvement in capital punishment executions or of facing the issue head-on, reconciling our own beliefs and speaking to the present and future of the medical profession, conclude Drs. Lanier and Berge.


'/>"/>

Contact: John Murphy
newsbureau@mayo.edu
507-284-5005
Mayo Clinic
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Anemia and tropical diseases; Is pharmacogenomics ready for the clinic?
2. Radiologists encouraged to look beyond cancer for clinically unseen diseases
3. Clinical depression linked to abnormal emotional brain circuits
4. Preclinical study suggests organ-transplant drug may aid in lupus fight
5. Mayo Clinic researchers discover new diagnostic test for detecting infection in prosthetic joints
6. AASM encourages those student-athletes at risk for developing osa to visit a sleep clinic
7. Thailand: Partners Open Free AIDS Treatment Clinic in Renowned AIDS Temple in Lop Buri
8. MinuteClinic Becomes Participating Provider with Assurant Health
9. Therap Services Continues to Hire Experienced Developmental Disability Industry Clinicians for its Customer Support Team
10. Acupuncturists Relocation Tightens Relationship With Fertility Clinic
11. Cardiovascular Technologies to be Highlighted at 5th Annual Cleveland Clinic Medical Innovation Summit, Oct. 1-3
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/28/2016)... ... , ... SuperCloset is proud to officially launch our “Helping Veterans Grow ... and obstacles veterans’ need to overcome in order to face their life changes upon ... veteran(s) with a donated SuperCloset product based on the needs and ability of helping ...
(Date:5/28/2016)... AL (PRWEB) , ... May 28, 2016 , ... May ... US Open Martial Arts Fighting Challenge with theme event of “K Warriors” on June ... Mobile, AL 36608. , The event is sponsored and hosted by Shaolin Institute ...
(Date:5/28/2016)... ... ... a part of the city where’s it’s easy to spot the neon lights of chains ... to attract diners with a taste for real food. , On May 13, the ... Grill, an urban casual restaurant focusing on dishes made by hand with wholesome, organic ingredients ...
(Date:5/27/2016)... SC (PRWEB) , ... May 27, 2016 , ... ... a line of classic American timber frame barn kits, which can be found on ... are inspired by historic American barn plans, and they highlight the craftsmanship of timber ...
(Date:5/27/2016)... ... May 27, 2016 , ... W.S. Badger Co. Inc ., ... it has been recognized as one of the best small businesses for new dads ... one of nine small businesses providing progressive benefits to new parents on the organization’s ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/26/2016)... Since its commercial introduction in ... life science tool for conducting genetic studies in a ... in its new report that the industry sits on ... by a range of new applications in the clinical ... http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20140723/694805 ) , Since the Human ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... , May 25, 2016 ... Market by Type (3D, 2D, 4D), by Therapeutic Area ... by End User (Medical Device Manufacturers, Hospitals/ Clinics) - ... the global Medical Animation Market for the forecast period ... reach USD 301.3 Million by 2021 from USD 117.3 ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... and GERMANTOWN, Maryland , May 25, ... QGEN ; Frankfurt Prime Standard: QIA) today announced that the ... Therawis Diagnostics GmbH to develop and commercialize predictive assays in ... PITX2 as a marker to predict effectiveness of anthracycline treatment ... "We are pleased to partner with Therawis, which developed ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: