Navigation Links
Limited resources, unlimited needs: Americans should ration health care, says MSU ethicist
Date:3/10/2009

EAST LANSING, Mich. As health care costs soar past $2.5 trillion and more than 47 million people remain uninsured, Americans must be willing to give up certain medical options to ensure health care reform is successful, argues a Michigan State University medical ethicist.

Thousands of uninsured Americans die each year because of their lack of insurance, yet millions of dollars are spent annually on medical procedures that save very few lives or yield only a few extra weeks or months to live. According to MSU's Leonard Fleck, whose book "Just Caring" was recently published by Oxford University Press, a discussion on rationing health care is needed to tackle the paradox that represents health care in America.

"When it comes to health care in America, we have limited resources for unlimited health care needs," said Fleck, a philosophy professor and faculty member in MSU's Center for Ethics and Humanities in the Life Sciences. "We want everything contemporary medical technology can offer that will improve the length or quality of our lives as we age. But as presently healthy taxpayers, we want costs controlled."

Since America's real shortage when it comes to delivering health care is a fiscal one, a collective discussion needs to be launched to come up with socially acceptable guidelines, states Fleck's book. Otherwise, the gap between those who can and can't afford care will grow.

"This is the 'just caring' problem: Why should anyone else pay attention to my demands for justice in meeting my health needs when I refuse to pay attention to their demands for justice in meeting their health needs?

"No one has a moral right to impose rationing decisions on others if they are unwilling to impose those same rationing decisions on themselves in the same medical circumstances."

Fleck cites several examples of the health care paradox in America:

Cancer treatment: Many lower-cost cancer treatments can su
'/>"/>

Contact: Jason Cody
codyja@msu.edu
517-432-0924
Michigan State University
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Press Statement Issued by Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited
2. Ansell Limited Launching a New Global Website
3. Mercury Computer Systems Announces the Sale of Visage Imaging to Pro Medicus Limited
4. Virgin Mobile USA Launches Limited Edition Pink Flare Handset to Benefit Susan G. Komen for the Cure(R)
5. TransMedia Group Retained by Renowned Plastic Surgeon Dr. Jeffrey Lagrasso to Share Beauty Trends, Warnings and Medical Perspective Previously Limited to the Rich and Famous
6. Crystal Research Associates, LLC Issues Executive Informational Overview(R) (EIO(R)) on Unilife Medical Solutions Limited
7. North Shore-LIJ Health System Exposure With Madoff Securities Limited to $5.7M
8. School Soda Ban Has Limited Effect
9. Limited Value Found for First-Generation Heart Pumps
10. Mobile Imaging Innovator, Mobile Diagnostic Centers LP, Appoints New CEO : Mobile Imaging Development's Limited Partnership, Mobile Diagnostic Centers LP. Has Appointed Patrick McNamara as CEO
11. Ocean Nutrition Canada Limited Secures Their Position as the Largest Omega-3 EPA/DHA Ingredient Supplier in the World
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:11/26/2014)... The Maryland Economic Development Association (MEDA) ... MEDA Awards, which, sponsored by Miles and Stockbridge ... MEDA Awards recognize the individuals, programs and projects ... encourage our members to nominate the individuals, programs ... impact in the state of Maryland,” said Pam ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... Francisco, California (PRWEB) November 26, 2014 ... (ADR) and stringent drug safety regulations are expected ... the forecast period. Growing prevalence of acute and ... in demand for new drug development. Moreover, growing ... reporting about the same has become the need ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... Pass, OR (PRWEB) November 26, 2014 ... related fresh water shortages, is moving forward with a ... into drinking water.* Radio host Sharon Kleyne supports the ... of “Total Water Management” (TWM). According to Kleyne, by ... to constantly import new water could be greatly reduced. ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... WOODLAND HILLS, CA (PRWEB) November 26, 2014 ... implants costing thousands of dollars, the prosthodontists at the Anacapa ... that paying for dental procedures can be daunting for some. ... to pay for the procedures they offer. , “No dentist ... functioning and beautiful set of teeth,” said Dr. Mamaly Reshad, ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... Schaumburg, IL (PRWEB) November 26, 2014 ... of communication management solutions, has been award the ... Telephony Magazine. , This award comes as a ... its capabilities within the Lync ecosystem. Specifically, ISI ... for all modes of Lync communication, including voice, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Maryland Economic Development Association Seeking Submissions for 2015 Awards 2Health News:Pharmacovigilance Market To 2020 - Global Industry Growth, Size, Share, Trends, Analysis And Forecast To 2020 Research Report By Grand View Research, Inc. 2Health News:Pharmacovigilance Market To 2020 - Global Industry Growth, Size, Share, Trends, Analysis And Forecast To 2020 Research Report By Grand View Research, Inc. 3Health News:Global fresh water advocate supports San Diego wastewater recycling plan 2Health News:Global fresh water advocate supports San Diego wastewater recycling plan 3Health News:Anacapa Dental Art Institute Doctors Offers 6 Tips on How to Pay for Cosmetic, Restorative and Implant Dentistry 2Health News:Anacapa Dental Art Institute Doctors Offers 6 Tips on How to Pay for Cosmetic, Restorative and Implant Dentistry 3Health News:Anacapa Dental Art Institute Doctors Offers 6 Tips on How to Pay for Cosmetic, Restorative and Implant Dentistry 4Health News:Anacapa Dental Art Institute Doctors Offers 6 Tips on How to Pay for Cosmetic, Restorative and Implant Dentistry 5Health News:ISI Telemanagement Solutions, Inc. has been Awarded the 2014 Microsoft Lync Pioneer Award 2
... ... near some of the best hospitals and clinics in the world. , ... Monsey, NY (PRWEB) May 4, 2010 -- The new All Time ... , ,"We were physically bound by how many people we were able to hire. We literally ...
... ... device from ASL Pharmacy® offers hope for chronic sinusitis patients. The NasoNeb™ ... and other antibiotics, anti-fungals, mucolytics and corticosteroids. , ... Camarillo, CA (PRWEB) May 4, 2010 -- Chronic ...
... quest to understand why people who suffer from depression in later ... term. A study led by Toronto,s Baycrest has found ... such as when they see happy, sad or neutral faces. ... of Geriatric Psychiatry and is likely the first published data ...
... Biotech ... metropolitan areas—without the high costs. , ... Hagerstown, MD (PRWEB) May 3, 2010 -- It may seem unusual ... County Economic Development Commission will be representing what has become a fast-growing hotspot for ...
... Study found the more cigarettes a woman smoked, the ... -- A woman who smokes while pregnant increases her ... young adulthood, a new Finnish study suggests. , While ... unborn children at risk for long-term health problems such ...
... In an effort ... will be moving into a bigger office location on April 26. , ... Cincinnati, OH (PRWEB) May 4, 2010 -- The continued success of ... away from their existing location on Pine Road in Kenwood. The office now occupies a shared ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:All Time Medical Has Just Moved To Their New, State-Of-The Art Office Situated In The Heart Of The Business District Of Monsey, N.Y 2Health News:New Nasal Drug Delivery Device for Chronic Sinusitis Patients Now Available from ASL Pharmacy 2Health News:New Nasal Drug Delivery Device for Chronic Sinusitis Patients Now Available from ASL Pharmacy 3Health News:New Nasal Drug Delivery Device for Chronic Sinusitis Patients Now Available from ASL Pharmacy 4Health News:Why is late-life depression harder to treat? 2Health News:Western Maryland to be Featured at BIO International Convention 2Health News:Western Maryland to be Featured at BIO International Convention 3Health News:Western Maryland to be Featured at BIO International Convention 4Health News:Smoking While Pregnant May Raise Psychiatric Risks in Kids 2Health News:Smoking While Pregnant May Raise Psychiatric Risks in Kids 3Health News:UniqueU Medical Weight Loss Success Requires an Expansion and Move to a Larger Location 2
(Date:11/26/2014)... November 26, 2014 A hernia is ... organ protrudes through the wall of a weak muscle area. ... birth are some of the causes of hernias. There are ... and incisional. An inguinal hernia is when part of the ... is found in the area of the umbilicus. A hiatal ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... and NEW YORK and ... As the leading distributor of market intelligence, MarketResearch.com is ... report by IQ4I Research and Consultancy focusing on the ... more about IQ4I Research visit: http://www.marketresearch.com/land/publisher.asp?vendorid=4023&progid=86891 . ... Pharmaceutical Ingredients Global Market – Forecast to 2020 ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... , Nov. 25, 2014  Medtronic,s roughly ... has been widely discussed in the media for ... creating a stronger leading player in one of ... Information.  The healthcare market research firm said  the ... feature a diverse set of solutions spanning inpatient ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Global Hernia Repair Devices Market Size, Share, Trends and Forecast 2014 to 2018 - Big Market Research 2Global Hernia Repair Devices Market Size, Share, Trends and Forecast 2014 to 2018 - Big Market Research 3Global Hernia Repair Devices Market Size, Share, Trends and Forecast 2014 to 2018 - Big Market Research 4MarketResearch.com: Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient Market to Reach $175 Billion by 2020 Says IQ4I Report 2MarketResearch.com: Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient Market to Reach $175 Billion by 2020 Says IQ4I Report 3Medtronic - Covidien: Beyond Taxes, Deal Will Create Patient Monitoring Power, according to Kalorama Information 2Medtronic - Covidien: Beyond Taxes, Deal Will Create Patient Monitoring Power, according to Kalorama Information 3
... 23, 2011 Reportlinker.com announces that a new market ... Global Pain Management Industry ... the worldwide markets for Pain Management in US$ Million ... Management Devices, and Pain Management Services. The report provides ...
... (NYSE: CVD ) today announced that it will ... February 24, 2011 at 10:00 a.m. ET.  Investors may access ...  In order to register and download any necessary software, please ... in Princeton, New Jersey, is one of the world,s largest ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Reportlinker Adds Global Pain Management Industry 2Covance to Present at the 2nd Annual Morningstar/NYSSA Healthcare Conference 2
Total T3 EIA Thyroid Function 025-BC-1005...
... anti-TG test kit is a solid phase ... It is designed for the quantitative measurement ... in serum or plasma. The microplate is ... controls and patient samples are pipetted into ...
Free Estriol (E3) RIA Reproductive Hormones 024-IDC-2000...
... 17a Hydroxyprogesterone (17aOHP) is produced by ... Even,though 17aOHP has relatively little progestational ... interest because it is the,immediate precursor ... produced by 21-hydroxylation of 17aOHP,measurement of ...
Medicine Products: