Navigation Links
Limited resources, unlimited needs: Americans should ration health care, says MSU ethicist
Date:3/10/2009

EAST LANSING, Mich. As health care costs soar past $2.5 trillion and more than 47 million people remain uninsured, Americans must be willing to give up certain medical options to ensure health care reform is successful, argues a Michigan State University medical ethicist.

Thousands of uninsured Americans die each year because of their lack of insurance, yet millions of dollars are spent annually on medical procedures that save very few lives or yield only a few extra weeks or months to live. According to MSU's Leonard Fleck, whose book "Just Caring" was recently published by Oxford University Press, a discussion on rationing health care is needed to tackle the paradox that represents health care in America.

"When it comes to health care in America, we have limited resources for unlimited health care needs," said Fleck, a philosophy professor and faculty member in MSU's Center for Ethics and Humanities in the Life Sciences. "We want everything contemporary medical technology can offer that will improve the length or quality of our lives as we age. But as presently healthy taxpayers, we want costs controlled."

Since America's real shortage when it comes to delivering health care is a fiscal one, a collective discussion needs to be launched to come up with socially acceptable guidelines, states Fleck's book. Otherwise, the gap between those who can and can't afford care will grow.

"This is the 'just caring' problem: Why should anyone else pay attention to my demands for justice in meeting my health needs when I refuse to pay attention to their demands for justice in meeting their health needs?

"No one has a moral right to impose rationing decisions on others if they are unwilling to impose those same rationing decisions on themselves in the same medical circumstances."

Fleck cites several examples of the health care paradox in America:

Cancer treatment: Many lower-cost cancer treatments can su
'/>"/>

Contact: Jason Cody
codyja@msu.edu
517-432-0924
Michigan State University
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Press Statement Issued by Ranbaxy Laboratories Limited
2. Ansell Limited Launching a New Global Website
3. Mercury Computer Systems Announces the Sale of Visage Imaging to Pro Medicus Limited
4. Virgin Mobile USA Launches Limited Edition Pink Flare Handset to Benefit Susan G. Komen for the Cure(R)
5. TransMedia Group Retained by Renowned Plastic Surgeon Dr. Jeffrey Lagrasso to Share Beauty Trends, Warnings and Medical Perspective Previously Limited to the Rich and Famous
6. Crystal Research Associates, LLC Issues Executive Informational Overview(R) (EIO(R)) on Unilife Medical Solutions Limited
7. North Shore-LIJ Health System Exposure With Madoff Securities Limited to $5.7M
8. School Soda Ban Has Limited Effect
9. Limited Value Found for First-Generation Heart Pumps
10. Mobile Imaging Innovator, Mobile Diagnostic Centers LP, Appoints New CEO : Mobile Imaging Development's Limited Partnership, Mobile Diagnostic Centers LP. Has Appointed Patrick McNamara as CEO
11. Ocean Nutrition Canada Limited Secures Their Position as the Largest Omega-3 EPA/DHA Ingredient Supplier in the World
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/18/2014)... September 19, 2014 A jacket is ... A jacket typically has sleeves, and fastens in the ... generally lighter, tighter-fitting, and less insulating than a coat, ... serve as protective clothing. Today, Fecbek, a well-known clothing ... of trendy men’s jackets; all these items are offered ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... -- Rising temperatures in the Atlantic Ocean may be ... that are becoming warmer, an expansion that could pose ... A study of 40 species along the reefs off ... invasive and poisonous lionfish, according to researchers from the ... of North Carolina-Wilmington, who published their findings in the ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... Steven Reinberg HealthDay Reporter , THURSDAY, ... Ebola outbreak in West Africa is starting to spread faster than ... new cases of the deadly viral infection were reported in just ... more than 5,300, with roughly half of those reported in the ... of deaths now tops 2,600. WHO has estimated that as ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... Chicago, IL (PRWEB) September 18, 2014 ... this fall. , Only 100 spots are still ... Business and Operations of ASCs on October 23-25, 2014 ... for Becker's Hospital Review Chief Information Officer Strategy Roundtable ... , Only 25 spots remain for Becker's Hospital Review ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... One of the most capable and ... ShandsCair Flight Program’s new EC155 B1, will ... at the Air Medical Transport Conference (AMTC), Sept. 22-24, ... into service ShandsCair EC155 and the Vanderbilt University ... AMTC highlight Airbus Helicopters broad, industry leading line-up of ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Cool Jackets Are For Sale At Fecbek.com 2Health News:Rising Atlantic Ocean Temperatures Could Pose Threat to Reefs 2Health News:New Ebola Cases Top 700 in Just One Week, Officials Report 2Health News:New Ebola Cases Top 700 in Just One Week, Officials Report 3Health News:Limited Spots Remain at Becker's Upcoming ASC and Hospital Conferences 2Health News:Airbus Helicopters Inc. Features Industry-leading Models at AMTC 2Health News:Airbus Helicopters Inc. Features Industry-leading Models at AMTC 3Health News:Airbus Helicopters Inc. Features Industry-leading Models at AMTC 4
... Enables PHNS and Healthcare Organizations to Audit, Enforce ... ... Regulations, BATON ROUGE, La., Nov. 16 TraceSecurity, a leading,provider ... its web-based Compliance Manager available to,hundreds of healthcare organizations across the ...
... to Improved HIV Management in Developing World, UPPSALA, ... has signed an agreement with a consortium of American ... of operational,funding, and has committed to raising additional funding ... Cavidi,s newly adopted three-year,business plan. Cavidi is the producer ...
... Agreement Ends Dispute Regarding Fee Disclosures for Separate ... ULLICO Inc. announced an,agreement resolving a Department of ... the Employee Retirement Income Security,Act of 1974 (ERISA). ... began as an inquiry,into ULLICO,s pension plan, ultimately ...
... Human Sexuality, Discussion on the Major Trends in Human Sexual Behavior, Sexual Desire, ... Sexual Dysfunction Issues, NEW YORK, Nov. 16 , WHAT: Are medicine and ... lead to better sex lives? What role does sex play in the ... and other compelling issues on human sexuality ...
... 16 HealthPartners,is the top-performing health plan in the ... newly released business report. The report, sponsored by the,National ... request for,information tool. The tool is used by purchasers ... Health Care Action Group, a coalition of,private and public ...
... November 15 - December 31, TULSA, Okla., Nov. ... today that it will offer three Medicare Part D,prescription ... eligible for Medicare. Medicare beneficiaries in Oklahoma can sign,up ... during the 2008,annual open enrollment period, which begins November ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:TraceSecurity Announces Partnership with PHNS Expanding Compliance Services to Hundreds of Healthcare Systems 2Health News:TraceSecurity Announces Partnership with PHNS Expanding Compliance Services to Hundreds of Healthcare Systems 3Health News:New Investors Fund Expansion of Cavidi AB 2Health News:ULLICO Inc. and U.S. Department of Labor Agree to Resolve 5 Year Old ERISA Investigation 2Health News:ULLICO Inc. and U.S. Department of Labor Agree to Resolve 5 Year Old ERISA Investigation 3Health News:Charlie Rose Science Series 2Health News:HealthPartners is National Benchmark in Six Out of Seven Areas in National Business Coalition on Health Report 2Health News:Blue Cross and Blue Shield of Oklahoma Announces Flexible, Affordable Blue MedicareRx(SM) Medicare Prescription Drug Plans 2
(Date:9/18/2014)... Sept. 18, 2014   Fruit Street Health ... initial seed round of funding. The ... by a series of individual investors, the majority of ... in the initial round are; Houston Cardiology Consultants ... Urologist Stacy Childs, Rapha Family Medicine Practice Owner ...
(Date:9/18/2014)... 2014  Decision Resources Group finds that Regeneron,s Eylea, ... agent for wet AMD, is equally likely to be ... Lucentis, which is the standard of care for wet ... directors do not identify a clear clinical or economic ... Lucentis to be listed on tier 1 or 2 ...
(Date:9/18/2014)...  A $3 million grant from The Glenn Foundation ... to establish a national center of excellence in biogerontology ... Research at U-M will focus on exploiting and expanding ... of aging and postpone diseases in animal models. Researchers ... develop medications that may help people live longer, healthier ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Fruit Street Health Secures First Round Of Seed Funding Led By Group Of Medical Industry And Technology Leaders 2Fruit Street Health Secures First Round Of Seed Funding Led By Group Of Medical Industry And Technology Leaders 3Regeneron's Eylea and Genentech's Lucentis Are Equally Likely to be Covered on Commercial and Medicare Advantage Plans for Wet AMD 2Regeneron's Eylea and Genentech's Lucentis Are Equally Likely to be Covered on Commercial and Medicare Advantage Plans for Wet AMD 3$3 M grant funds Paul F. Glenn Center for Aging Research at the University of Michigan 2$3 M grant funds Paul F. Glenn Center for Aging Research at the University of Michigan 3
... Laboratories is a national reference laboratory and ... and development. ARUP offers an extensive test ... tests in clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned ... clients include more than half of the ...
... ARUP Laboratories is a national reference laboratory ... research and development. ARUP offers an extensive ... medical tests in clinical and anatomic pathology. ... Laboratories' clients include more than half of ...
... ARUP Laboratories is a national reference ... laboratory research and development. ARUP offers an ... unique medical tests in clinical and anatomic ... ARUP Laboratories' clients include more than half ...
... reference laboratory and a worldwide leader in ... an extensive test menu of highly complex ... anatomic pathology. Owned by the University of ... half of the nation's university teaching hospitals ...
Medicine Products: