Navigation Links
Largest study of fertility patients shows concerns about embryo disposition
Date:12/3/2008

DURHAM, NC -- Fertility patients who are done having children feel responsible for the stored, frozen embryos left over from their treatment, yet more than half are against implanting the embryos in anyone else, according to a new study by researchers at Duke University Medical Center.

"This really turns our moral presumptions on their heads," says Anne Drapkin Lyerly, MD, an obstetrician/gynecologist and bioethicist at Duke, and lead investigator of the findings that appear online in Fertility & Sterility.

"Parents care very much about what happens to their embryos, but that doesn't mean they want them to become children. Our study shows that many feel they have to do what they can to prevent their embryo from becoming a child."

The survey of more than 1,000 fertility patients is the largest and only multi-site study to shed important light on the state of the nation's 500,000 frozen embryos currently in storage. It reveals previously unexplored concerns that patients have about their embryos, and it comes at a time when several states and even the federal government are attempting to enact legislation that would either assert an embryo is a person, allow abandoned embryos to be adopted by another couple, or allow unused embryos to become "wards of the state."

What to do with those unused embryos has also become a sticking point for providers, since they are held responsible for safe storage or disposition of apparently abandoned embryos.

Fresh embryos are used in more than 80% of fertility treatment cycles, but most patients also choose to freeze some embryos that were created but not implanted, to use as a possible backup. This means that extra embryos often remain after treatment is completed. Previous studies have found that when childbearing is complete, as many as 70 percent of patients put off for five years -- or more -- the decision of what to do with those frozen embryos, even while they continue to pay annual storage fees. In Lyerly's study, 20 percent of the patients who had completed childbearing indicated they were likely to freeze their embryos "forever."

The lack of acceptable options fuels patients' reluctance to make a decision. "Either the options they prefer aren't available or they are unacceptable," explains Lyerly.

In the survey, the researchers presented four embryo disposition options: thawing and discarding; reproductive donation; indefinite freezing; and donation for research. The majority were unlikely to choose any of these options except for one: research donation.

In a previous paper published in Science, Lyerly reported that 60 percent would be likely to donate unused embryos for stem cell research, an option not readily available. But even if federal policies on funding stem cell research change, Lyerly says that doesn't solve patients' conundrum.

"For many of these patients, the need to make a decision about disposing these embryos is not discussed up front. Understandably, fertility patients have hard times thinking about destroying their embryos when they are emotionally and financially invested in trying to make a baby," she says.

The conundrum arises when reproductive goals change without a renewed discussion about what to do with the embryos that have been stored. "Many centers don't make available all the options for disposition," Lyerly says. "Even in places where embryo research is not conducted, it's possible that embryos can be transferred to another center, yet this might not be discussed."

Two methods that were considered somewhat acceptable by about 20 percent of the fertility patients were placement of embryos in a woman's body at an infertile time, and the idea of a ritual disposal ceremony. Yet, Lyerly says these alternatives are rarely offered to patients even though "these may be the answers to many patients' desires as they allow the embryos to pass in a way that seems most respectful to them."

By bringing fertility patients' concerns to the forefront, Lyerly hopes the next step will be the development of clinical guidelines and ongoing informed consent processes for patients at various stages of fertility treatment. She also hopes it will encourage more detailed disclosure about the available disposition options and facilitate broad availability of disposition decisions that are morally acceptable to the majority of fertility patients.


'/>"/>

Contact: Debbe Geiger
Debbe.Geiger@duke.edu
919-660-9461
Duke University Medical Center
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Courion Helps Reduce Costs at Nations Largest Operator of Senior Living Communities
2. Antibiotics Largest Cause of Drug-Induced Liver Damage
3. Kindred Healthcare, Nations Largest Post-Acute Healthcare Provider, Selects Allscripts Referral Management
4. Medical Technology to be Highlighted at World's Largest Simulation Exhibition
5. November 23 Marks Tenth Anniversary of the Largest Civil Settlement in U.S. History
6. Military, Industry Leaders to Speak at World's Largest Simulation Event
7. World's Largest Modeling and Simulation Exhibition Sells Out for '08
8. Golden Meditech Increases Stakes in Cordlife, Largest Cord Blood Bank Operator in Southeast Asia
9. Jackson Healthcare Named 5th Largest Healthcare Staffing Company
10. Ocean Nutrition Canada Limited Secures Their Position as the Largest Omega-3 EPA/DHA Ingredient Supplier in the World
11. World-Renowned Physicians Converge on Methodist Dallas Medical Center for Largest Live Demonstration of Its Kind in Texas
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/24/2017)... ... February 24, 2017 , ... Yisrayl Hawkins, Pastor and Overseer ... Prophecy concerning this present generation. Yisrayl makes an astounding statement when he says ... He explains that the Bible details the current times so plainly that anyone should ...
(Date:2/24/2017)... ... February 24, 2017 , ... Rosica Communications, ... thought leadership , media relations, social media, content marketing and SEO, is ... powered through Act-On, an intuitive marketing automation platform. , Rosica will now offer ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... February 23, 2017 , ... ... Department of Justice jointly issued a letter to withdraw previous guidance ... with their gender identity. The guidance issued in May 2016 by the Obama ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... ... ... The American Cleft Palate-Craniofacial Association (ACPA) is pleased to announce KLS Martin ... supporter of the event. , "We are pleased that KLS Martin is joining us ... ACPA President. "KLS Martin has a long track record of support of the American ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... ... February 23, 2017 , ... EBSCO ... the National Institute for Health and Care Excellence (NICE) framework. The ... National Health Service (NHS) to search, order and purchase medical and healthcare-related content ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/23/2017)... , Feb. 23, 2017 Visiomed, the ... services since 1997, is changing the landscape of ... providing patients with pro-active, custom-made solutions. Recognizing the ... instant and affordable healthcare without walls, Visiomed has ... devices developed with healthcare professionals that is empowering ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... 23, 2017 ITL Limited, ( ASX: ITD ), an ... the half year ended 31 December 2016 compared with the previous ... can be viewed here . Highlights ... up 104%) Earnings per share of 2.2 cents ... $17.5m (Dec 2015: $15.7m; up 11%) Profit before ...
(Date:2/23/2017)... Research and Markets has announced the addition of the ... their offering. ... The latest research Fibromyalgia Drugs Price Analysis and Strategies - 2016, ... The research answers the following questions: ... clinical attributes? How are they positioned in the Global Fibromyalgia market? ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: