Navigation Links
Is patient coding making hospitals appear better than they are?
Date:4/25/2010

In this week's BMJ, Nigel Hawkes, freelance journalist and Director of Straight Statistics, a campaign for the better use of statistical data, investigates how the way that patients are allocated diagnostic codes by a hospital can have a big effect on a hospital's performance.

It follows two articles published by the BMJ last week arguing that using death rates to judge hospital performance is a bad idea.

It began, says Hawkes, when Mid Staffordshire Foundation NHS Trust was branded "appalling" by the Care Quality Commission, yet was rated in the top ten for quality of care by health analysts Dr Foster in their 2009 Good Hospital Guide. Further investigations into lower than average death rates from broken hips at Mid Staffordshire was put down to "improved coding procedures."

Could such coding changes be affecting Dr Foster's performance evaluations, flattering hospital-standardised mortality ratios (HMSRs) and making hospitals appear much better than they are, asks Hawkes?

Diagnostic coding is used by hospitals to record the conditions suffered by patients admitted to them for treatment, he explains. If a hospital uses an increasing number of codes year by year, it implies that more patients with more severe conditions are being treated. But if the death rate remains constant while the severity index increases, it appears that the hospital is doing better at keeping people alive.

Research by CHKS, a rival health analytical company, shows that the number of codes has been creeping up over recent years, yet crude death rates in English hospitals show virtually no change over the past five years. There is also a big variation in the average number of diagnostic codes per patient from hospital to hospital.

How has this happened, asks Hawkes? One explanation might be the increasing proportion of patients classified as needing palliative care. CHKS figures show the number of deaths coded Z51.5 (the code used for palliative care) was under 400 a month in 2004, but had reached more than 1,800 a month by June 2009.

Patients coded Z51.5 are assumed to have come into hospital to die, so performance calculations make allowance for that. This means that a few heavy users of the Z51.5 code could have reduced their HSMRs from 110 (above average) to 90 (below average) simply by increasing the frequency of use of the palliative care code.

Although Hawkes cannot prove that any hospital is doing this, he says "there is no question that the situation is open to manipulation by trusts."

Dr Foster Intelligence, the company responsible for the Good Hospital Guide, believes that HSMRs remain a good measure of the quality of care, if used alongside other measures. CHKS, by contrast, believes that while they may be a useful tool within a hospital, they are unsuitable on their own for comparisons between hospitals while such big coding variations exist.

The clash of evidence between the Good Hospital Guide and the Care Quality Commission embarrassed the Department of Health and a review of the use of HSMRs in England is now underway.


'/>"/>

Contact: Emma Dickinson
edickinson@bmjgroup.com
44-207-383-6529
BMJ-British Medical Journal
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Targeted therapy prolongs life in patients with HER2-positive breast cancer
2. Physical Therapist, Money Launderer and Patient Recruiter Plead Guilty in Connection With Multiple Detroit Health Care Fraud Schemes
3. Aspen Dental Opens 44 New Offices, Welcomes 340,000 New Patients in 2009
4. Blood Thinner Combos Risky for Heart Attack Patients
5. Patients with mild gallstone pancreatitis can undergo surgery sooner, shortening hospital stays
6. Brain Scans Suggest Some Vegetative Patients May Be Aware
7. Inflammation marker related to obesity is elevated in patients with pancreatic cancer
8. Penn State Hershey Medical Center to Provide Complimentary AT&T Wi-Fi in Patient Rooms
9. Adding Chemo to Tamoxifen Helps Some Breast Cancer Patients
10. Livonia Optometrist Offers New Technology - and New Hope - to Patients ... Free of Charge
11. HD For More Than Your TV – New Technologies Offer Patients High Definition Vision At Any Age
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:6/24/2016)... ... June 24, 2016 , ... Today, InhaleLabs.com (Inhale) offilially launched ... medication by matching users with high quality water pipes within an ideal price range. ... , Inhale was founded by two brothers, Nick and Mike Hunter, who use medical ...
(Date:6/24/2016)... ... ... Dr. Seema Daulat, a native Texan and University of Texas at Austin magna ... 13, 2016. , Dr. Daulat earned her Doctorate of Medicine (MD) at The University ... Agape Clinic serving Dallas’ underprivileged community. , Following medical school, Dr. Daulat completed both ...
(Date:6/23/2016)... ... , ... An article published June 8 on AOL News describes ... cancer in individuals with unhealthy oral hygiene habits. The article goes on to state ... gum disease, brushed their teeth on a daily basis, wore dentures and if they ...
(Date:6/23/2016)... ... June 23, 2016 , ... The Mechille Wilson Agency, a ... Jasper County and the surrounding region, is initiating a charity drive to assist a ... funds earmarked for a scholarship fund that will be presented to the chosen student ...
(Date:6/23/2016)... McKinney, Texas (PRWEB) , ... June 23, 2016 , ... ... the special operations community. He turned towards the water to find peace and set ... funds for a veterans charity and turned to the internet. He came across the ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:6/23/2016)... -- In a startling report released today, National Safety Council ... comprehensive, proven plan to eliminate prescription opioid overdoses. Prescription ... are tackling the worst drug crisis in recorded U.S. history, assigned ... Kentucky , New Mexico , ... 28 failing states, three – Michigan , ...
(Date:6/23/2016)... June 23, 2016 Research and Markets ... Issue 52" report to their offering. ... treatment creates a favourable commercial environment for MedImmune to enter. ... base that will serve to drive considerable growth for effective ... serve to cap sales considerably, but development is still in ...
(Date:6/23/2016)... and BOGOTA, Colombia , June 23, 2016  Astellas today announced the establishment of Astellas Farma ... as the company,s second affiliate in Latin America . ... ... Astellas Farma Colombia ... ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: