Navigation Links
Is a society with smokers profitable?
Date:7/16/2009

The latest rise in the indirect taxation on tobacco and alcohol took place in June. The most popular brand of cigarettes went up in price from 3.10 euros to 3.30 euros per packet. Are these taxes a form of dissuasion or a way of compensating the rest of society for the harm generated by those who smoke? A study by the Polytechnic University of Cartagena has looked into the most significant questions concerning the tobacco economy.

The research, carried out by ngel Lpez and Arntzazu Viudes, reviews the main economic arguments for the analysis of the policies to control tobacco addiction and describes the market failures from different paradigms.

As Lpez declared to SINC, "we have not attempted to verify a specific hypothesis but rather carried out an appraisal of the studies on tobacco consumption from the economic point of view, including both the traditional vision and the more recent progress". It can be seen from this review, for example, that smoking is a personal choice which can generate net losses of welfare for other members of society and for the family of the smoker but, above all, for the person in question. "Upon this basis there exists an economic justification for corrective interventions by the State", the researchers explained.

The article, which has recently been published in the Revista Espaola de Salud Pblica (Spanish Magazine of Public Health), also discusses two of the most significant preventive measures nowadays: the ban on smoking in bars and restaurants and the taxes on payment in tobacco.

The economists put forward the following argument: "the measures depend on the mechanisms which generate losses of welfare. The taxes have traditionally been justified as corrections for the costs imposed on the rest of society, due either to a supposed imbalance between taxes and payments from the public sector or to the harm caused by secondhand tobacco".

The advantages of raising taxes

The question which then arises is whether the taxes are sufficient for the costs generated by tobacco. For Lpez, "if we bear in mind all the significant costs, the evidence available indicates that this is not so".

In their work, and according to the evidence collated, the financial externalities are partly compensated for by the level of taxation applied in many industrialized countries. Nevertheless, the most solid justification for increases in taxes lies "in the existence of failures in the sovereignty of the consumer, both when starting to smoke and when attempting to give it up and sticking to such a decision. These failures generate a demand for self-control mechanisms, and the high price is one of the most effective mechanisms", the economist explained.

Under no circumstances can it be said that a society with smokers is per se economically ineffective. According to Lpez, it depends on whether the smokers are fully aware of the harm they cause to themselves and smoke because they want to (not because they cannot overcome the addiction) and whether they compensate the rest of society for the external costs they generate. "It is quite difficult for these premises to be fulfilled", the researchers asserted.

The taxes on tobacco, the study says, can also be justified by the existence of externalities arising from the social use of tobacco and by the possible inappropriateness of regarding the costs imposed by secondhand tobacco affecting the rest of the family as private costs. The restrictions on consumption in closed public places is another powerful self-control mechanism and represents "a second solution to the problem of the externalities arising from secondhand tobacco".

According to Lpez, "both taxes and the restrictions on consumption are measures which impose losses of welfare on the people who smoke with full sovereignty, in other words, those who value the pleasure of smoking more than the present and future costs of the habit. Nevertheless, in view of the estimates of the private costs and the evidence that most smokers want to stop give up, the hypothesis that taxes and restrictions on consumption increase net welfare gains plausibility. In any case, the researchers argue that "measures of prevention and control which increase the options of individuals without interfering in the decisions of those who wish to smoke with full sovereignty are desirable".

The policies in the study which are regarded as being inspired in the principles of liberal paternalism "may produce positive results in the future, although there is still much to be done as regards their potential implementation and evaluation", the experts concluded.


'/>"/>

Contact: SINC
info@plataformasinc.es
34-914-251-820
FECYT - Spanish Foundation for Science and Technology
Source:Eurekalert  

Related medicine news :

1. The American Society of Hematology Announces New Honorific Award
2. MedicAlert Foundation and Autism Society Launch New Program to Safeguard Individuals and Families Living With Autism
3. New Policy Statement from Society for Adolescent Medicine Urges Inclusion of Adolescent and Young Adult Health Issues in All Health Care Reform Legislation
4. American Society of Hematology awards grants to encourage novel medical training programs
5. St. Jude Virologist Honored by the Royal Society
6. Six Researchers to Receive Prestigious Awards from the American Society of Hematology
7. Portola Pharmaceuticals Announces Several Scientific Presentations at International Society on Thrombosis and Haemostasis XII Congress
8. American Chemical Society praises nomination of Collins as NIH Director
9. LA BioMed President and CEO will be named president of the American Judicature Society
10. Vertical Sleeve Gastrectomy Expert, Dr. Paul Cirangle, Speaks at Annual American Society for Metabolic & Bariatric Surgery Meeting
11. Health Physics Society 54th Annual Meeting
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Is a society with smokers profitable?
(Date:9/21/2017)... ... 2017 , ... 38-Year-Old Plastic Surgeon Gill at Aesthetic Surgery Center is Saluted ... announce that Plastic Surgeon Kiranjeet Gill has been awarded as one of the 15th ... award that was started in 2003 to salute young achievers in Southwest Florida who ...
(Date:9/21/2017)... Falls Church, VA (PRWEB) , ... September 21, ... ... **An FDAnews Webinar**, Sept. 26, 2017 — 1:30 p.m. – 3:00 p.m. ET, ... exacting business. It’s easy to get things wrong, run afoul of The Quality ...
(Date:9/21/2017)... IL (PRWEB) , ... September 21, 2017 , ... SABRE ... to run from September 11 to the end of November. , The Chicago, Illinois, ... to their community and teach them about the ease of taking their personal safety ...
(Date:9/21/2017)... ... September 21, 2017 , ... ... with Infinity Behavioral Health Services for professionals in the addiction treatment industry entitled: ... Audit . , Insurance companies and state and federal governments are increasingly ...
(Date:9/21/2017)... , ... September 21, 2017 , ... ... FDAnews Management Report**, http://www.fdanews.com/products/54818-promotional-communication      , In the competitive world of drug ... get while staying in compliance with FDA rules. , The FDA has issued ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:9/19/2017)... venture-backed medical device company developing a non-invasive, robotically assisted, platform therapy that uses pulsed sound ... ... Jim Bertolina, PhD ... Tom Tefft ... device executive Josh Stopek , PhD, who has led R&D and business development teams ...
(Date:9/19/2017)... 2017   ZirMed Inc ., a recognized leader in ... it has been ranked #1 by its users for the ... 2017 User Survey. ZirMed was recognized as the top-ranked end-to-end ... medical centers over 200 beds and holds one of the ... survey history. ...
(Date:9/18/2017)... Mich. , Sept. 18, 2017  PMD Healthcare ... Specialty Pharmacy of Kalamazoo, Mich. , ... hub service that expedites and streamlines patient and provider ... PD 2.0, and wellness management services.  ... device used to measure lung function for a variety ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: