Navigation Links
Is Grief an Illness? The Debate Heats Up
Date:2/17/2012

By Alan Mozes
HealthDay Reporter

THURSDAY, Feb. 16 (HealthDay News) -- The loss of a loved one can trigger deep emotional turmoil, but is the grief that follows a normal part of being human or is it a form of mental illness in need of diagnosis and treatment?

That's the gist of a major debate now unfolding in the world of psychiatry, as the American Psychiatric Association (APA) prepares to issue the fifth edition of its seminal reference guide to mental disease, the Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders (DSM).

The issue: For the first time, the manual -- a touchstone for mental health professionals across the United States -- may not exclude the concept of "bereavement" from the constellation of behaviors and experiences that it deems worthy of consideration when clinicians set out to diagnose a major depressive disorder.

What does this mean? That feelings or outbursts accompanying the passing of a family member or close friend -- such as crying, insomnia, fatigue, confusion and profound sadness -- may now be viewed as a treatable illness rather than as a normal reaction to life's most shattering moments.

Needless to say, not everyone agrees with this shift in thinking.

"To me, grief is a normal condition, not to be tagged with a diagnostic code and to be treated," stressed Dr. T. Byram Karasu, chairman of psychiatry and behavioral sciences at Albert Einstein College of Medicine and psychiatrist-in-chief at Montefiore Medical Center in New York City. "Everyone loses someone in their lives at some point. So, this would be classifying everyone at some point. No one would be immune to this."

"And that does not make sense, because grief is a normal and very healthy behavior," said Karasu, who also chairs the APA's National Task Force on the treatment of depression. "One has to feel joy as well as pain and depression, otherwise life is not worth living. And one shou
'/>"/>

Copyright©2010 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. Father Channels His Grief into Advocacy, Promotes Simple Actions to Make Hospitals Safer for Children
2. New Website and Self-Help Book Validate Women Experiencing Grief After an Abortion
3. Mother Talks of the Anger, Confusion and Grief of a SIDS Death
4. When a Parent Dies Suddenly, Childs Grief May Persist
5. Grief Is a Real Heartbreaker, Study Finds
6. Universal Health Care Debate Coincides with Release of My eMHR, the Nation's First Free Electronic Personal Health Records System
7. Study Revives Debate on Prostate Drug
8. BU Study Contributes to Online Health Education Debate
9. The Reality of Sex Addiction Stirs Debate
10. Rhetoric, framing efforts have little influence in same-sex marriage debate
11. Critique 029: What should we advise about alcohol consumption? A debate amongst scientists
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Is Grief an Illness? The Debate Heats Up
(Date:11/26/2014)... the well-known wedding dress manufacturer for the global market, ... for ladies worldwide. Meanwhile, these graceful items are offered ... very popular in the world and clients can buy ... , Sweetdressy.com believes that a company can attract clients ... best services. The spirit of the company is making ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... Norwalk Hospital is pleased to announce ... the American Nurses Credentialing Center (ANCC). , The ... work environments where nurses can flourish. The designation ... Hospital and identifies it as one of the ... organizations’ commitment to nurses and their contributions toward ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... -- When you,re planning your holiday get-away, don,t ... sports -- such as skiing or hiking, a ... may fail to take altitude into account when ... risk of developing fatigue and other symptoms related ... Dr. Melissa Tabor, an assistant professor of sports ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... Reinberg HealthDay Reporter WEDNESDAY, ... smoking cigarettes than ever, health officials said. In fact, ... percent in 2005 to 18 percent in 2013. That means ... 42.1 million, despite the increasing population, according to the U.S. ... still have a long way to go, and if we ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... The family foundation of Best Buy founder, Richard ... Foundation (Meso Foundation), half of which will be specifically ... Program . The focus area of the Richard M. ... organizations that can generate transformational results in education, human ... and chairman emeritus of Best Buy Co., Inc., the ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Cheap Prom Dresses For Ladies Introduced At SweetDressy.com 2Health News:Norwalk Hospital Announces American Nurses Credentialing Center PATHWAY TO EXCELLENCE® DESIGNATION 2Health News:Norwalk Hospital Announces American Nurses Credentialing Center PATHWAY TO EXCELLENCE® DESIGNATION 3Health News:Don't Let High Altitude Ruin Your Holiday Trip 2Health News:U.S. Adult Smoking Rate Drops to New Low: CDC 2Health News:U.S. Adult Smoking Rate Drops to New Low: CDC 3Health News:Best Buy Founder’s Family Foundation Donates $100,000 to Organization Fighting Deadly Cancer 2Health News:Best Buy Founder’s Family Foundation Donates $100,000 to Organization Fighting Deadly Cancer 3
... Vereen Issues a Call-to-Action for People with Diabetes to ... Diabetes Today, BRIDGEWATER, N.J., Sept. 24 Tony,Award-winning ... a world leader in diabetes care, to launch Take ... to educate,people living with diabetes about their condition. Since ...
... Age 55 and Over to Know the Signs,of ... Suspected, WASHINGTON, D.C., Sept. 24 Despite ... detection, there are,striking differences between intentions and actual ... adults age 55 and over titled, "Alzheimer,s,Disease: Current ...
... Launch of the Disposable flexfit (TM) Breaks down Longstanding Barriers to ... ... N.J., Sept. 24 Songbird Hearing, Inc.,today introduces a unique option ... that 55 million Americans currently,experience some degree of hearing loss, while ...
... Hospital Assets,Patient Care to Remain Uninterrupted At HPA Hospitals, ... America,("HPA" or "the Company") announced today that it and ... Chapter 11,of the U.S. Bankruptcy Code. The filings do ... the HPA system, which continue to operate as usual.,The ...
... The 2008 Compensation Data survey results found that 67.3 percent ... and their family. , ... Kansas ... increases, employers and employees continue to see high health insurance ...
... Drug Administration,s (FDA,s) plan to list those drugs whose safety is ... drug companies, physicians, and patients. , ... Horsham, PA ... the Food and Drug Administration,s (FDA,s) plan to list those drugs ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Ben Vereen, Tony Award-Winning Actor, Strives to Raise Awareness of Diabetes and Treatment 2Health News:Ben Vereen, Tony Award-Winning Actor, Strives to Raise Awareness of Diabetes and Treatment 3Health News:New Alzheimer's Disease Survey Reveals Disparities Between Beliefs and Behavior in Pursuing Diagnosis 2Health News:New Alzheimer's Disease Survey Reveals Disparities Between Beliefs and Behavior in Pursuing Diagnosis 3Health News:New Alzheimer's Disease Survey Reveals Disparities Between Beliefs and Behavior in Pursuing Diagnosis 4Health News:New Alzheimer's Disease Survey Reveals Disparities Between Beliefs and Behavior in Pursuing Diagnosis 5Health News:Songbird Hearing Provides Revolutionary Alternative for Those Dealing With Hearing Loss 2Health News:Songbird Hearing Provides Revolutionary Alternative for Those Dealing With Hearing Loss 3Health News:Corporate Parent Hospital Partners of America Files Voluntary Chapter 11 Petition; Filings do not Include any Hospital Facilities 2Health News:Health Insurance Premium Costs High for Employers and Employees 2Health News:DIA/FDA/PhRMA Drug Safety Conference: Planning the Lifecycle of Safety Evaluation 2
(Date:11/26/2014)... YORK and LONDON , ... of market intelligence, MarketResearch.com is pleased to announce the ... and Consultancy focusing on the active pharmaceutical ingredient (API) ... visit: http://www.marketresearch.com/land/publisher.asp?vendorid=4023&progid=86891 . In IQ4I,s ... – Forecast to 2020 , IQ4I ...
(Date:11/26/2014)...  Medtronic,s roughly $43 billion acquisition and ... in the media for its US Federal tax ... player in one of the fastest growing device ... research firm said  the two companies compete in ... of solutions spanning inpatient to home care, and ...
(Date:11/26/2014)... 25, 2014  Breckenridge Pharmaceutical, Inc. announced today ... agreement with Pii (Pharmaceutics International, Inc.) ( ... and Pii expect to develop and commercialize several ... Pii will develop, manufacture and supply the products, ... under its own label.  The drugs, comprised of ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:MarketResearch.com: Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient Market to Reach $175 Billion by 2020 Says IQ4I Report 2MarketResearch.com: Active Pharmaceutical Ingredient Market to Reach $175 Billion by 2020 Says IQ4I Report 3Medtronic - Covidien: Beyond Taxes, Deal Will Create Patient Monitoring Power, according to Kalorama Information 2Medtronic - Covidien: Beyond Taxes, Deal Will Create Patient Monitoring Power, according to Kalorama Information 3Breckenridge Pharmaceutical signs Multi-Product Generic Agreement with Pharmaceutics International, Inc. 2
... Dendreon Corporation (Nasdaq: DNDN ) announced ... approved the remainder of its New Jersey manufacturing facility, ... PROVENGE® (sipuleucel-T) to help meet the needs of patients ... refractory) prostate cancer.   Last April, upon ...
... drug used to treat erectile dysfunction and pulmonary ... and young adults with congenital heart disease to ... exercise performance during stress testing in patients with ... Children,s Hospital of Philadelphia. This study ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Dendreon Expands Launch of PROVENGE 2Dendreon Expands Launch of PROVENGE 3Dendreon Expands Launch of PROVENGE 4Dendreon Expands Launch of PROVENGE 5Exercise Performance in Children and Young Adults with Single Ventricle Heart Disease Improves with Use of Drug for Erectile Dysfunction 2Exercise Performance in Children and Young Adults with Single Ventricle Heart Disease Improves with Use of Drug for Erectile Dysfunction 3