Navigation Links
Is American Medicine Too Test Happy?
Date:12/29/2011

By Dennis Thompson
HealthDay Reporter

THURSDAY, Dec. 29 (HealthDay News) -- If you've had a medical procedure lately, you probably first had blood tests, an imaging test like an MRI or ultrasound, perhaps an electrocardiogram and possibly more.

"Is all this really necessary?" you might have wondered.

That's a question that doctors themselves are now raising as a growing body of evidence suggests that overuse of diagnostic testing may be harming patients' health and driving up health-care costs.

"There is clear overuse or misuse of certain kinds of tests for certain patients," said Dr. Steven E. Weinberger, executive vice president and chief executive officer of the American College of Physicians.

So should doctors exercise more restraint, or should patients take a more active and skeptical role in their care?

Weinberger believes the answer lies somewhere in the middle. "There needs to be an honest conversation in both directions, with a clear understanding about what is and isn't necessary," he said.

Experts agree that excessive testing is costing the U.S. health-care system billions through waste. Weinberger said that some estimates have suggested the cost could run as high as $200 billion to $250 billion a year, an amount equal to about 10 percent of the total amount spent on the nation's health care.

But the true cost is borne by patients who face increased health risks associated with diagnostic testing, he said. Dr. Anthony Shih, executive vice president for programs of the Commonwealth Fund, a private health policy research foundation, agreed.

"Although most patients are aware that procedures carry some risks, they are less aware that tests carry risks," Shih said.

Diagnostic testing, in fact, carries three main risks, Weinberger and Shih said:

  • Risks directly related to the test itself, such as the radiation exposure caused by imaging tests.
  • The risk for a false positive, which can lead to a string of other unnecessary follow-up tests and procedures, each with their own sets of potential health hazards.
  • The risk that a condition will be identified that never would have been clinically significant but now will probably be treated.

A routine electrocardiogram, for example, might identify some nonspecific condition that leads to a cardiac catheterization, an invasive medical procedure that carries its own set of health risks, Weinberger said.

"Unnecessary testing is not necessarily benign," he said. "It can lead to situations that can pose health risks to patients."

Clearly, patients should become more active in asking whether tests are necessary. But as most anyone who's been a patient can attest, asking such questions can be daunting for anyone, but especially for a sick person who needs treatment.

Weinberger said he has personal experience when it comes to the difficulty of challenging tests as a patient. He recently had arthroscopic surgery for a knee injury, but before the procedure he had to undergo a battery of diagnostics that included lab tests, a chest X-ray and an electrocardiogram -- all unnecessary, as far as he could tell. And yet, he had the tests without questioning them.

"My experience shows you how hard it is," Weinberger said. "If there's anyone who was in a position to question these tests, it's someone like me." But, he admitted, "you don't want to antagonize the person who's going to provide your care. Sometimes the easiest road is to just go along."

His organization, the American College of Physicians, has started tackling the issue through what it calls its High-Value, Cost-Conscious Care Initiative, which aims to reduce unnecessary testing by educating physicians and patients alike on the benefits, harms and costs of tests linked to specific ailments.

"We're basically trying to develop a list of those types of things that are overused and explore the evidence behind why they are overused," Weinberger said.

Shih said that people who are facing diagnostic tests should use such resources to educate themselves and then feel free to question their doctor about the tests that have been ordered.

"The patient should always ask what the test is looking for, what the potential harms are for the test, and what the next steps are if the test finds something," he said. "As the tests get more invasive and more complex, I would be more careful about asking for the reasoning behind each test."

Ultimately, however, both patients and doctors need to keep in mind that the necessity of tests is a very specific and personal matter, Shih added.

"It's important to recognize that for any given patient, even with the exact same condition, the decision may not be the same," he said. "It depends on the values and preferences of each patient."

"Some patients want to be absolutely sure, while other patients may be more comfortable with uncertainty," Shih explained. "There is no hard-and-fast rule for which tests might be appropriate for each situation."

More information

The U.S. Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality has more on communicating with your doctor.

SOURCES: Steven E. Weinberger, M.D., executive vice president and chief executive officer, American College of Physicians, Philadelphia; Anthony Shih, M.D., M.P.H., executive vice president for programs, Commonwealth Fund, New York City


'/>"/>
Copyright©2010 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. American Council on Exercise (ACE) Study Reveals Kettlebells Provide Powerful Workout in Short Amount of Time
2. Satellite Healthcares Sheila Doss Elected Western Chapters Coordinator-Elect of the American Nephrology Nurses Association
3. Luth Researchs IndicatorEDG(TM) Study Finds Americans Hopes of Achieving Their Dreams Are Fading
4. Highmark Foundation Awards $120,000 to the American Heart Association
5. American Heart Association Rapid Access Journal Report: Study Finds Racial Gaps Continue in Heart Disease Awareness, Low Knowledge of Heart Attack Warning Signs Among Women
6. New American Heart Association Survey Finds Heart Disease and Stroke Patients Face Significant Barriers in Obtaining Quality, Affordable Care
7. American Heart Association Comment on Hospitalization of President Bill Clinton
8. Majority of Americans Approve of President Obamas Handling of Afghanistan and National Security But Disapprove of Handling of Economic Issues, Per Franklin & Marshall College Poll With Hearst Television
9. American Red Cross Issues One-Month Progress Report for Haiti Earthquake
10. 57 Million Americans Sickened by H1N1 Flu: CDC
11. Concentra, American Showa to Open Associates Health Center in Blanchester, Ohio
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:1/18/2017)... ... January 18, 2017 , ... At Hallmark Nameplate, their ... that they have achieved certification to ISO 13485. This certification is another way they ... to date products and services that they need. , The ISO 13485 Certification is ...
(Date:1/18/2017)... ... January 18, 2017 , ... The Hear the ... project with the donation of cochlear implants. In February 2017, the first three ... a fair chance of leading an independent life. This engagement builds on the ...
(Date:1/17/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... January 17, 2017 , ... January is National Stalking Awareness Month ... choose to lurk in the corners and commit the crime of stalking, a very real ... and addiction, an often overlooked factor in stalking and other crimes. , “Stalking: know it. ...
(Date:1/17/2017)... ... , ... For breast cancer clinicians and researchers who were unable to attend ... intimate review and analysis of its highlights, a novel half-day, complimentary meeting—the 14th Annual ... on February 4, 2017 in Chicago. Chaired by Kathy S. Albain, MD, FACP, FASCO ...
(Date:1/17/2017)... ... January 17, 2017 , ... Kevin Harrington (one of the original Sharks from ... campaigns regarding the topic of Beauty and Personal Care. , Everyone ... better way to commit to these changes than beginning with personal care and beauty ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:1/18/2017)... SAN DIEGO , Jan. 18, 2017 /PRNewswire/ ... manufacturing solutions for cell and advanced therapies , ... the French biopharmaceutical company developing "tumor starvation" treatments ... unmet medical needs. Under the agreement, Invetech will ... products based on Erytech,s proprietary ERYCAPS technology platform, ...
(Date:1/18/2017)... January 18, 2017 After the recent ... the use of cannabis both for medical and recreational purposes ... Americans open to the use of cannabis, but the focus ... to Arcview Market Research, the North American legal cannabis market ... the previous year. The research projects sales will grow at ...
(Date:1/17/2017)... 2017 North America Insulin Delivery Market Outlook ... America Insulin Delivery Market Outlook to 2022", provides key ... The report provides value, in millions of US dollars, ... segments - Insulin Pens, Insulin Pumps, Insulin Syringes and ... company shares and distribution shares data for each of ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: