Navigation Links
Ipilimumab in advanced melanoma: added benefit for non-pretreated patients not proven
Date:6/12/2014

In early 2014, the German Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care (IQWiG) assessed the added benefit of ipilimumab in non-pretreated patients with advanced melanoma. The drug manufacturer claimed a noticeable increase in survival time and thus an added benefit versus dacarbazine, the appropriate comparator therapy specified by the Federal Joint Committee (G-BA). However, the indirect comparison conducted by the company was too uncertain, and the postulated effect was biased in favour of ipilimumab. Hence an added benefit was not proven.

In two addenda, the Institute now also examined updated and corrected analyses by the company as well as a possible added benefit versus a second comparator therapy. The result remained unchanged, however: An added benefit of ipilimumab is not proven for non-pretreated patients versus any of the two comparator therapies.

Advantage in pretreated patients

Ipilimumab is a monoclonal antibody used in melanoma if the disease is so advanced that the melanoma can no longer be surgically removed or has formed metastases. In 2012, the manufacturer presented informative data for pretreated patients from a randomized controlled trial. These data indicated a major advantage of ipilimumab in survival time in comparison with "best supportive care". This advantage was associated with major risk of harm, however.

Effects in non-pretreated patients not interpretable

In October 2013, European approval was expanded to patients who have not been treated for their advanced melanoma. In a new dossier, the manufacturer subsequently also claimed an added benefit for this group versus the appropriate comparator therapy dacarbazine specified by the G-BA. IQWiG did not concur with this claim because the treatment effects presented by the manufacturer were not interpretable: The quality of the relevant indirect unadjusted comparison was too low, the results were biased in favour of ipilimumab, and not all relevant confounders were considered in the analysis.

Subsequent assessment in two addenda

In addition, the manufacturer had presented data on the comparison of ipilimumab with vemurafenib in its dossier. IQWiG did not examine these data in its dossier assessment because the G-BA had not specified vemurafenib as an appropriate comparator therapy at first. In March 2014, shortly before completion of the IQWiG dossier assessment, the G-BA commissioned the Institute to also assess the potential added benefit versus vemurafenib. Moreover, the manufacturer submitted corrected and updated data analyses in the commenting procedure on the dossier assessment in April 2014. Following the G-BA's commission, IQWiG now assessed these data in a second addendum.

Indirect comparison not interpretable

As so far there are no studies that directly compare ipilimumab with vemurafenib, the manufacturer used an indirect comparison, in which dacarbazine was used as a so-called common comparator. In this indirect comparison, on the one hand it used data from the BRIM-3 study, a randomized phase 3 study comparing vemurafenib with dacarbazine.

For the second side of the indirect comparison, the manufacturer did not use a direct comparison between ipilimumab and dacarbazine. Instead, it used the unadjusted indirect comparison again, which it had already used for examining the added benefit in comparison with dacarbazine. Hence the indirect comparison between ipilimumab and vemurafenib is also subject to great uncertainties. No conclusions on added benefit can be derived from this.

General weakness of analysis not resolved

In the second addendum, the Institute examined the corrected analyses subsequently submitted by the manufacturer. This correction reduced the exclusion of patients, but, in the outcome "overall survival", the exclusion was still 20 percentage points higher on the ipilimumab side of the indirect comparison than on the dacarbazine side. Originally, the difference was almost 40 percentage points.

What is more important, however, is the fact that the documents subsequently submitted did not address the uncertainty resulting from the methods of the unadjusted indirect comparison. Overall, an added benefit of ipilimumab in non-pretreated patients with advanced melanoma versus dacarbazine or vemurafenib is still not proven.

G-BA decides on the extent of added benefit

The dossier assessment is part of the overall procedure for early benefit assessments supervised by the G-BA. After publication of the manufacturer's dossier and the IQWiG dossier assessment, the G-BA conducted commenting procedures, in which the manufacturer submitted additional information. The G-BA subsequently commissioned IQWiG to assess the data subsequently submitted.

If, in the course of the discussions on a commission of the G-BA, a need for further revision arises, IQWiG presents its report in the form of an addendum. The Institute sent the two addenda on ipilimumab to the commissioning agency on 26 March and on 16 May 2014.

The G-BA then decides on the extent of the added benefit in each case, thus completing the early benefit assessment.


'/>"/>

Contact: Dr. Anna-Sabine Ernst
presse@iqwig.de
49-022-135-6850
Institute for Quality and Efficiency in Health Care
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Marker may predict response to ipilimumab in advanced melanoma
2. Study: Ipilimumab Shows Durable Responses But Low Overall Response Rate In Patients With Unresectable Or Metastatic Mucosal Melanoma
3. Considerable added benefit of ipilimumab in advanced melanoma
4. Advanced breast cancer: Benefits of Trastuzumab (Herceptin) outweigh the risk of harm
5. Early palliative support services help those caring for patients with advanced cancer
6. UIC conducts phase I drug study for advanced pancreatic cancer
7. Long-term results encouraging for combination immunotherapy for advanced melanoma
8. Immune therapy for advanced bladder cancer yields promising results
9. Better sleep predicts longer survival time for women with advanced breast cancer
10. Drinking poses greater risk for advanced liver disease in HIV/hep C patients
11. Palliation is rarely a topic in studies on advanced cancer
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/27/2016)... ... ... Southland Log Homes , designer and manufacturer of America’s Favorite Log ... be found on its website at SouthlandLogHomes.com. , The designs of the wood ... craftsmanship of timber post and beam construction. The result is a barn that ...
(Date:5/27/2016)... ... May 27, 2016 , ... An influential resource amongst nurses and professionals in ... lights on the variety of topics detailing why we appreciate nurses in so many ... career has gone from being in a major recession to one of the hottest ...
(Date:5/27/2016)... ... May 27, 2016 , ... An educational ... by inspiring human-interest stories, courtesy of awareness-driven celebrities and thought leaders. It also ... advocates, associations and industry leaders such as Bioness. , As patients feel ...
(Date:5/27/2016)... ... May 27, 2016 , ... ... bolstered by inspiring human interest stories, courtesy of leaders in the nursing and ... within the industry, from leading advocates and associations—namely Jones & Bartlett Learning. , ...
(Date:5/27/2016)... ... 27, 2016 , ... With a team of certified experts, ... Aside from its GMP accreditation, Validation Center is also a registered authority of ... and staff. , Validation Center is ISO17025 accredited and only offers its clients ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/25/2016)... PUNE, India , May 25, 2016 /PRNewswire/ ... Pipeline Review, H1 2016"market research report that provides ... complete with comparative analysis at various stages, therapeutics ... route of administration (RoA) and molecule type, along ... releases. It also reviews key players involved in ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... Cirujanos holandeses han puesto en marcha una ... compartir sus mejores prácticas por el mundo y tratar ... Europa, África, Asia y Estados ... combina la transmisión en vivo con mensajería instantánea y ... "Imagine un médico de Medicines sans Frontieres ...
(Date:5/24/2016)...   , Study met both ... in , Excellent plus Good ... of the ascending colon   ,      ... announced new positive data from the phase III MORA study for ... litre PEG with ascorbate. The study met both primary endpoints showing ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: