Navigation Links
Informed consent: False positives not a worry in lung cancer study
Date:7/24/2014

PROVIDENCE, R.I. [Brown University] The U.S. Preventive Services Task Force recently recommended computerized tomography (CT) lung screening for people at high risk for cancer, but a potential problem with CT is that many patients will have positive results on the screening test, only to be deemed cancer-free on further testing. Many policymakers have expressed concern that this high false-positive rate will cause patients to become needlessly upset. A new study of National Lung Screening Trial participant responses to false positive diagnoses, however, finds that those who received false positive screening results did not report increased anxiety or lower quality of life compared with participants who received negative screen results.

"Most people anticipated that participants who were told that they had a positive screen result would experience increased anxiety and reduced quality of life. However, we did not find this to be the case," said Ilana Gareen, assistant professor (research) of epidemiology in the Brown University School of Public Health and lead author of the study published in the journal Cancer.

The NLST's central finding, announced in 2010, was that screening with helical CT scans reduced lung cancer deaths by 20 percent compared to screening with chest X-rays. The huge trial spanned more than a decade, enrolling more than 53,000 smokers at 33 sites.

In the new study, Gareen and co-authors, including Brown faculty and staff members Fenghei Duan, Constantine Gatsonis, Erin Greco, and Bradley Snyder, followed up with a subset of participants at 16 sites to assess the psychological effects of the CT and X-ray screenings compared in the trial.

"In the context of our study, with the consent process that we used, we found no increased anxiety or decreased quality of life at one or six months after screening for participants having a false positive," Gareen said. "What we expected was that there would be increased anxiety and decreased quality of life at one month and that these symptoms would subside by six months, which is why we measured at both time points, but we didn't find any changes at either time point."

The unexpected similarity between the participants with a negative and a false positive screen result is not because getting a false positive diagnosis is at all pleasant, Gareen said, but presumably because study participants understood that there was a high likelihood of a false positive screen result.

"We think that the staff at each of the NLST sites did a very good job of providing informed consent to our participants," she said. "In advance of any screening, participants were advised that 20 to 50 percent of those screened would receive false positive results, and that the participants might require additional work-up to confirm that they were cancer free."

Reassuring results

To make its assessments, Gareen's team surveyed 2,812 NLST participants for the study. Patients responded well, with 2,317 returning the survey at one month after screening and 1,990 returning the survey at six months. The survey included two standardized questionnaires: the 36-question Short Form SF-36, which elicits self-reports of general physical and mental health quality, and the 20-question Spielberger State Trait Anxiety Inventory.

Maryann Duggan and her staff from the Outcomes and Economics Assessment Unit at Brown administered the questionnaires by mail with telephone follow-up as required.

In the study analysis, the researchers divided people into groups based on their ultimate accurate diagnoses: 1,024 participants were "false positive," 63 were "true positive," 1,381 were "true negative" and 344 had a "significant incidental finding," meaning they didn't have cancer but instead had another possible problem of medical importance.

The results were clear after statistical adjustment for factors that could have had a confounding influence. Whether participants received X-rays or the helical CT scans, the questionnaire scores of those with false positive diagnoses remained similar to those who were given true negative diagnoses.

Meanwhile, the scores of the true positive participants who were diagnosed with lung cancer markedly worsened over time as their battle with the disease took a physical and psychological toll.

Because participants received the questionnaires at one and six months, it is possible that study participants receiving a false positive screen result experienced anxiety and reduced quality of life for a short time after receiving their screen result, Gareen said. But by one month after their screening, there was no evidence of a difference between the screen result groups.

Gareen said the results should encourage physicians to recommend appropriate screenings, despite their high false positive rates, so long as patients are properly informed of the likelihood of a positive screen result and its implications. The data provide evidence that the NLST consent process provided a good model for advising those undergoing screening, she said.


'/>"/>

Contact: David Orenstein
david_orenstein@brown.edu
401-863-1862
Brown University
Source:Eurekalert  

Related medicine news :

1. Many Young Adults Misinformed About Hookahs Harms
2. Vita Classic Premium Sliced Smoked Atlantic Salmon Recalled: AttorneyOne Monitor and Keep Consumers Informed
3. Baby Boomer Community Could Stand to Lose Millions, If Not Well Informed on Medigap Plans and Healthcare
4. Oriya Organics Superfood Protein Medley Recalled: AttorneyOne Monitor and Keep Consumers Informed
5. Hospira Lactated Ringer’s and 5% Dextrose Injection Recalled: AttorneyOne Monitor and Keep Consumers Informed
6. Veterans who identify as LGB could benefit from informed mental health services
7. Diet Doc Hormone Diets & Weight Loss Plans Launches Monthly Diet Newsletter Geared Toward Keeping Patients Informed with Interesting Health News, Diet Tips & Recipe Ideas
8. Smarter social services - Applications for informed care delivery
9. Kapelle Media Launches Email Campaign to Keep the Business Community Informed of Marketing Trends
10. Dr. Lembo Keeps Clients Informed with New Facebook Page
11. The Big Mistake Could Cost 10,000 Baby-Boomers a Day Millions in Out of Pocket Expenses, if They are Not Well Informed on Medigap Plans
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Informed consent: False positives not a worry in lung cancer study
(Date:8/20/2017)... Centennial, CO (PRWEB) , ... August 20, 2017 , ... ... in the same household? If so, you may be interested in participating in ... The purpose of this research is to understand more about the relational aspects of ...
(Date:8/19/2017)... ... August 18, 2017 , ... Paragon ... transparent, verifiable database to help the cannabis industry move towards greater legitimacy. By ... deliver a faster technology with lower fees. Paragon will build a fully verifiable ...
(Date:8/19/2017)... Toronto, ON (PRWEB) , ... August 19, 2017 , ... ... of the of NaturallyCurly.com® The Curl Leaders, Editors’ Choice 2017 Award for the second ... must-have accessory for hair stylists and curlies alike was voted Best Moisturizer for Type ...
(Date:8/19/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... August 19, 2017 , ... ... NJ, is a diverse community of over 1,000 passionate employees, caregivers, volunteers, thought ... After Parker at Stonegate changed ownership, it was time to refresh the carpeting ...
(Date:8/18/2017)... , ... August 19, 2017 , ... ... Authority of Thailand presided over the Amazing Thailand Health and Wellness Tourism Showcase ... , Mr. Noppadon Pakprot, Deputy Governor for Tourism Products and Business at TAT ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:7/28/2017)... Holdings, Inc. ("Hill-Rom") (NYSE: HRC), today announced financial results ... and updated its financial outlook for fiscal 2017. ... third quarter, Hill-Rom reported earnings of $0.09 per diluted ... prior-year period. These results reflect after-tax special items, including ... to the non-cash write-down of assets associated with the ...
(Date:7/27/2017)... 27, 2017  Zimmer Biomet Holdings, Inc. (NYSE and ... June 30, 2017.  The Company reported second quarter net ... the prior year period, and an increase of 2.1% ... points of contribution from the LDR Holding Corporation acquisition, ... quarter of 2016, or 0.3% on a constant currency ...
(Date:7/26/2017)... 2017 E.I. Medical Imaging (EIMI) has partnered ... custom design the worlds first ultrasound system to be used ... native habitat. In preparation for a piece produced by ... Week, Dr. Guttridge approached EIMI with the idea of an ... hammerhead sharks underwater. ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: