Navigation Links
Infant Heart Transplant Controversy Continues
Date:8/13/2008

3 new reports raise question of how long a heart must stop beating before death is certain,,,,

WEDNESDAY, Aug. 13 (HealthDay News) -- Three new reports challenge current guidelines on how long after cardiac death doctors must wait before taking a heart from an infant organ donor.

There's no question that organ donation saves lives, and there's also no question that there aren't enough donor organs to save everyone on the transplant list. However, deciding who is a suitable organ donor, particularly when the potential donor is an infant, is not so clear-cut.

Most people are familiar with the concept of organ donation after brain death, but organ donation is also permissible after cardiac death. Cardiac death occurs after life support is withdrawn, and the heart stops on its own. Because the heart can sometimes restart, the Institute of Medicine recommended in 1997 that 5 minutes should elapse between the time the heart stops and the organ retrieval begins. More recently, however, it's been suggested that cardiac death becomes irreversible after just one minute.

Now, in the Aug. 14 issue of the New England Journal of Medicine, surgeons from Denver Children's Hospital report on three cases in infant heart donors where surgeons reduced the time between when the heart stopped and when organ retrieval began. In one case, the time was shortened to three minutes, and in the other two to just 75 seconds.

The reason doctors might want to shorten this interval is to reduce the time that transplantable organs are deprived of oxygen, which likely increases the success of transplants. Doing so might also help increase the number of available organs for donations, which is important because as many as one in four babies awaiting a heart transplant dies while on the waiting list, according to the study.

"Donors who died from cardiocirculatory causes offer an opportunity to reduce waiting time and waiting-list mortality among children whose survival depends on a heart transplant," wrote the Denver doctors.

In two of the four accompanying perspective pieces in the same issue of the journal, two experts with normally divergent viewpoints on this issue, agreed on one thing: Under the current definition of cardiac death, cardiac function must be irreversible, and by definition, if cardiac function is irreversible, how can such a heart then be placed in another person where it starts beating again? Clearly, the loss of cardiac function was not irreversible, according to Dr. Robert Truog, director of clinical ethics from Harvard Medical School, and Robert Veatch, a professor of medical ethics from Georgetown University.

"I don't know how you can ever have a patient that meets the criteria for irreversible loss of function, and then reverse that function in someone else," said Veatch. Using other organs after cardiac death is possible, he said, but if surgeons are declaring someone dead because their heart has stopped, then under the current law, that heart shouldn't able to be used in someone else, no matter how long surgeons wait.

Truog also thinks the debate over how many seconds to wait before declaring cardiac death misses the point. "If death means irreversible loss of cardiac function and that heart beats in someone else's chest, it's not irreversible, is it?"

He said the debate over whether transplant surgeons are hastening death is similar to the debate over whether or not withdrawing mechanical ventilation was killing a patient or not from 30 years ago. Today, he said, many deaths occur in intensive care units when mechanical ventilation is withdrawn.

If a patient, or in the case of an infant or a child, the patient's surrogate, provides consent for organ donation prior to cardiac death, Truog said in his perspective, "With such consent, there is no harm or wrong done in retrieving vital organs before death, providing that anesthesia is administered. With proper safeguards, no patient will die from vital organ donation who would not otherwise die as a result of the withdrawal of life support."

Veatch takes a more conservative stance on organ procurement, and said he believes that most local organ procurement organizations wouldn't support the Denver procurements, no matter how successful the transplants may have been.

Veatch said, ideally, people would have a choice when they decide to become organ donors, and that choice would include organ donation after whole brain death, organ donation if you've suffered a permanent loss of consciousness, and cardiac death. Currently, organs are only harvested after whole brain death or cardiac death, according to Veatch, and he added that only New Jersey offers organ donors a choice with these options. But, he said he believes that many people, if offered the choice, would choose to have their organs donated if it was determined that they were in a persistive vegetative state.

Truog said the debate isn't likely to end soon, and sometimes, more than medical personnel get involved in these highly controversial decisions. In one case in California, prosecutors brought three felony charges against a transplant surgeon that they believed hastened the death of a disabled and brain-damaged organ donor. A judge has already dismissed two of the charges, and the doctor's lawyers have recently asked the judge to dismiss the remaining charge, asserting that the physician's actions were consistent with the usual standard of care.

More information

Read more about organ donation at the American Heart Association.



SOURCES: Robert Truog, M.D., professor, medical ethics and pediatric anesthesia, director, clinical ethics, Harvard Medical School, executive director, Institute for Professionalism and Ethical Practice, and senior associate, critical care medicine, Children's Hospital Boston; Robert Veatch, Ph.D., professor, medical ethics, Kennedy Institute of Ethics, Georgetown University, Washington, D.C.; Aug. 14, 2008, New England Journal of Medicine


'/>"/>
Copyright©2008 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. Preterm Birth Contributes to Growing Number of Infant Deaths
2. Preterm birth contributes to growing number of infant deaths
3. Suckling Infant Triggers Trust Hormone in Moms
4. Non-parental care of infants tied to unfavorable feeding practices
5. Vaccinated infants well-protected against severe pneumococcal infection in Norway
6. Child Care May Lead to Unwanted Weight Gain in Infants
7. Stillbirths, infant deaths lead to anxiety, guilt and stress among obstetricians
8. The Second International Conference on Signs of Autism in Infants: Changing Outcomes through Early Identification and Intervention, October 11 and 12, 2008. Save the Date!
9. Cats Can Trigger Eczema in Some Infants
10. RF Technologies(R) Introduces Enhanced Clinical Support Service, Step-by-Step, a Comprehensive Program Designed to Ensure Infant Security
11. Trust for Americas Health Releases Report on Connection between Womens Health and Stalled Infant Mortality Rates
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Infant Heart Transplant Controversy Continues
(Date:8/18/2017)... CA & CARMEL, IN (PRWEB) , ... August 18, 2017 , ... ... on its 36th annual list, the most prestigious ranking of the nation's fastest-growing private ... been included in the exclusive Inc. 5000 ranking . This year’s ranking reflects ...
(Date:8/18/2017)... ... August 18, 2017 , ... “Three Narrow Roads”: a vivid and ... of published author, Rev. Dr. Burnett King Sr., is currently the pastor-teacher-visionary at Simply ... the Faith Track Club, Inc., a track-and-field program geared towards youth. , King shares, ...
(Date:8/18/2017)... ... August 18, 2017 , ... “Kingdom Mandate for Kingdom Builders”: ... “Kingdom Mandate for Kingdom Builders” is the creation of published author, John F. ... Eastern Europe as a missionary in 1983. He spent three decades training pastors ...
(Date:8/17/2017)... ... August 17, 2017 , ... Riccobene Associates ... location in Goldsboro, NC to its family of practices. Residents of Goldsboro will ... starting August 15, 2017. , Riccobene Associates Family Dentistry, founded by Dr. ...
(Date:8/17/2017)... MA (PRWEB) , ... August 17, 2017 , ... ... will come together on September 19, 2017 for Anti-Infectives Rx. This off-the-record networking ... B. Martin Conference Center at Harvard Medical School. , Industry leaders and decision ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:8/7/2017)... 7, 2017 Zimmer Biomet Holdings, Inc. (NYSE and ... that its Board of Directors has approved the payment of ... of 2017. The cash ... about October 27, 2017 to stockholders of record as of ... of dividends are subject to approval of the Board of ...
(Date:8/4/2017)... -- Agragen, LLC, a Cincinnati -based ... and aquacultural feed sectors, announces a significant step ... AGR131.  This drug is designed to trap and ... patients suffering from inflammatory conditions such as rheumatoid ... Biological pharmaceuticals currently used ...
(Date:8/2/2017)... , Aug. 2, 2017 CaryRx, a next-generation full-service ... delivery service for patients in the Washington D.C. ... retail pharmacy by providing delivery of medications through the convenience ... future delivery or delivered within one hour to any location ... excited to bring this invaluable service to Washington ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: