Navigation Links
In U.S., No Comeback Seen for Hormone Therapy
Date:8/9/2009

Experts say risks of long-term use still outweigh possible benefits

SUNDAY, Aug. 9 (HealthDay News) -- Hormone replacement therapy once seemed like a wonderful means to help women age gracefully. By dosing menopausal women with estrogen and progesterone as their bodies began to produce decreased amounts of those hormones, doctors believed they could help fend off heart disease, osteoporosis and cancer.

But those beliefs collapsed in 2002, when researchers pulled the plug three years early on the Women's Health Initiative, a large-scale, federally funded study of hormone replacement therapy (HRT). They had found that the therapy produced an increased risk of breast cancer, heart attack, stroke and blood clots. HRT has been pretty much taboo ever since.

Or has it?

Several studies released in the past year have revealed ways in which HRT might still be beneficial. Under certain conditions and with the right timing, they found, some women could be helped by the therapy.

Despite these findings, experts with the American Cancer Society and the American Heart Association say there's scant chance there will be any revision on the position on HRT in the United States anytime in the near future.

"In an effort to decrease hot flashes, it's hard to tell someone to take the breast cancer risk and the heart and stroke risk shown in other studies," said Dr. Vincent Bufalino, a spokesman for the American Heart Association and president and chief executive of Midwest Heart Specialists, in Naperville, Ill. "If you can put up with the menopausal symptoms, you're better off doing that than taking the risks related to hormone replacement therapy."

Research that has shown the more positive side of HRT has included:

  • A report on a Mayo Clinic study that found a lower rate of colorectal cancer among older women taking HRT.
  • A report by American Cancer Society epidemiologists that found that women could use an estrogen-progesterone combination for less than two years with no increased risk of breast cancer. It also found that cancer risk increased dramatically after three or more years of hormone therapy and that increased risk disappeared two years after stopping HRT.
  • A Danish study that found an increased risk of heart attack in women 51 to 54 years old who took hormone replacement therapy, especially those who'd taken it for a long time. But it found no correlation between hormone therapy and elevated heart attack risk in older women.
  • A Canadian study that found women who have a genetic predisposition to breast cancer actually reduced their breast cancer risk after taking HRT.

The American and Danish studies also found that HRT involving just estrogen was far safer than HRT that included a combination of estrogen and progesterone.

Based on research like this, Canadian doctors are revising their guidelines on hormone replacement therapy.

But Bufalino and Susan M. Gapstur, vice president of epidemiology for the American Cancer Society, said that the studies do not provide enough evidence to sway current medical thinking in the United States.

"I would not say the philosophy is changing," Gapstur said. "The critical question becomes, there's this balance between the long-term risk of chronic diseases versus immediate concerns of hot flashes and quality of life around the postmenopausal period."

Short-term use of hormone replacement therapy might be helpful in alleviating menopause symptoms, she said, but more study is needed to fully assess the impact of that therapy -- particularly because the younger women who might benefit most from such therapy appear to be most at risk.

"What we thought we knew about hormone replacement therapy and cardiovascular disease might not be true for older women, but I think there are still a lot of questions about the risks and benefits of hormone replacement therapy for younger women," Gapstur said. "That's where we need to focus our attention."

Bufalino agrees, arguing there's little point in pushing such therapy when there's so much downside and so little benefit.

"There are some small subgroups inside the groups that show some statistical benefit, but I think we would all be cautious at this time based on this report," Bufalino said of the American Cancer Society research. "If you just look at it on the surface, it's not clearly definitive."

And perhaps adding fuel to the fire of doubts, reports emerged Aug. 5 that a pharmaceutical company that makes HRT had paid a medical communications firm to help produce 26 studies supporting its use. Those studies were published in 18 medical journals between 1998 and 2005, according to a report first published by the New York Times.

The drug maker, Wyeth, contends that the studies were scientifically accurate. None of the papers disclosed Wyeth's role in initiating and funding the work.

More information

The U.S. National Institutes of Health has more on hormone therapy.



SOURCES: Vincent Bufalino, M.D., president and CEO, Midwest Heart Specialists, chairman, Midwest Heart Foundation, and medical director, Edward Heart Hospital, Naperville, Ill.; Susan M. Gapstur, Ph.D., M.P.H., vice president, epidemiology, American Cancer Society; April 22, 2009, presentation, American Association for Cancer Research annual meeting, Denver; American Cancer Society, news release, Feb. 2, 2009; Oct. 1, 2008, European Heart Journal, online; Sept. 23, 2008, Journal of the National Cancer Institute


'/>"/>
Copyright©2009 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. Flu Widespread in U.S., but Vaccine Is Poor Match
2. CVS Caremark Corp. to Pay $36.7 Million to U.S., 23 States, & D.C. to Settle Medicaid Prescription Drug Fraud Allegations
3. Walgreens to Pay $35 Million to U.S., 46 States & Puerto Rico to Settle Medicaid Prescription Drug Fraud Allegations
4. As Diabetes Reaches Epidemic Levels in Georgia and U.S., Thousands Drawn to Diabetes University in Atlanta Nov. 8
5. LegalView Reports Record Numbers of Drug Reactions in U.S., Partially Caused by Heparin
6. Abbott Nutrition Announces Voluntary Recall of ZonePerfect(R) Chocolate Peanut Butter Bars, ZonePerfect(R) Peanut Toffee Bars and NutriPals(TM) Peanut Butter Chocolate Bars in U.S., Mexico, New Zealand and Singapore
7. Registered Dietitians Can Do Much to Help Educate Americans and Eliminate Health Disparities in U.S., Says Former Surgeon General
8. TB Still Declining in U.S., But at Slower Rate
9. Using Too Much Salt Is Common in U.S., CDC Says
10. Across the U.S., Stress Varies by Region
11. dLIFETV Premieres Eighth Season With Baseballs Comeback Player Dmitri Young and Leave It To Beavers Jerry Mathers
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
In U.S., No Comeback Seen for Hormone Therapy
(Date:2/20/2017)... ... February 20, 2017 , ... ... to purchase a new ultrasound-enhanced thrombolysis machine, a state-of-the-art device that breaks up ... facilitated by the Pepin Family Foundation. , “We greatly appreciate this gift from ...
(Date:2/19/2017)... ... February 19, 2017 , ... Orbita, ... join forces with Healthwise ® at HIMSS 2017 to showcase ... in evidence-based health education, technology and services, will demonstrate a voice-powered knowedge assistant ...
(Date:2/18/2017)... ... February 17, 2017 , ... Park Cities Pet Sitter President, Joette ... the Pet Life Radio network. The episode, which was posted this week, features ... what factors led to Park Cities Pet Sitter’s being awarded the 2017 National Association ...
(Date:2/17/2017)... , ... February 17, 2017 , ... ... foundational and sustainable systems change designed to further positively impact the health and ... of Trustees has long considered it our duty to seriously consider releasing our ...
(Date:2/17/2017)... ... February 17, 2017 , ... Corrective Action ... Letter, **An FDAnews Webinar**, Feb. 23, 2017 — 1:30 p.m. – 3:00 p.m. ... action (CA) and preventive action (PA)? , The methods share techniques and tools ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/20/2017)... , February 20, 2017 According to a new ... Suspension, Dry powder), Device Type (Metered dose, Dry Powder, Nebulizer)), Canister (Plain, ... by MarketsandMarkets, The market is projected to reach USD 52.37 Billion by ... during the forecast period. Continue Reading ... ...
(Date:2/20/2017)...   Alberty   Drugs , a ... has announced a significant shift in focus by ... to servicing local Veteran Affairs Centers (VA) and other ... increased need to secure cost effective treatments for their ... for their goods & services. "The opportunity ...
(Date:2/20/2017)... , February 20, 2017 Acute, Chronic and ... expected to grow at a CAGR of 7% from 2016-2021 and CAGR ... CAGR of 6% from 2016 to 2027. The market is estimated at ... ... Read on to discover how you can exploit the future business opportunities ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: