Navigation Links
Implantable Defibrillators May Not Help Women With Heart Failure

Analysis of previous research found little benefit for female patients

MONDAY, Sept. 14 (HealthDay News) -- Widely used implantable cardioverter-defibrillators may not actually help women with advanced heart failure.

A new analysis turns up no evidence that the devices, used to detect and then correct abnormal heart rhythms, actually lowered the risk of death among female patients, despite the fact that this is routine therapy for all patients with heart failure.

"We do not know of the benefits of defibrillators when used as primary prevention," said Dr. Christian Machado, senior author of a paper appearing in the Sept. 14 issue of the Archives of Internal Medicine. "We just do not know how much women benefit from this therapy."

Yet, according to an accompanying editorial, 30 percent of people getting implantable cardioverter-defibrillators, also called ICDs, are women.

In fact, there are even guidelines supporting the practice, said Machado, who is director of electrophysiology at Providence Hospital Heart Institute, in Southfield, Mich.

ICDs are intended to prevent sudden cardiac death in heart failure patients, who have a high risk for such an event. And while clinical trials do support the practice, those trials tend to be biased towards men.

Here, a search of medical literature databases turned up only five relevant randomized clinical trials between 1950 and 2008. The trials involved a total of 934 women and 3,810 men, a clear indication that women are underrepresented in this type of study even though women make up almost half of the 5.3 million Americans who have heart failure.

None of the studies on their own showed any survival advantage for women of having a defibrillator implanted, nor did the combined data show any benefit.

But there was a reduction in death rates for men in each trial, as well as when the results were pooled together.

"We need to find a way to study more women in order to be able to identify what subgroups truly benefit from this therapy," Machado said.

But that could be difficult. Given that current guidelines recommend the use of ICDs, it would be unethical to propose a trial that randomized some women to go without one, Machado explained.

And this data is certainly not likely to change cardiac care procedures. "I don't think this is going to change anyone's practice," said Dr. Seth Keller, associate director of cardiac electrophysiology at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City. "Practice guidelines are pretty well-established in terms of ICDs. But this does raise a lot of questions."

"If it is true that women don't benefit from primary prevention with ICDs, then why not?" he added.

Machado speculated that reasons for women deriving different or less benefit from ICDs could range from different anatomy to hormonal factors to how women's bodies use calcium.

"I'm sure there's more than one factor leading to such a less dramatic benefit in women from this therapy," he said.

In fact, the devices might even cause harm. The editorial referenced one analysis that found that women have a 70 percent greater risk of problems after receiving an ICD than men.

"Let's question the dogma," Machado said. "Let's figure out how to change our recommendations."

But one expert urged caution.

Dr. Wojciech Zareba, director of the Heart Research Follow-Up Program at the University of Rochester Medical Center, felt that this meta-analysis, along with most papers in this form, was fraught with methodological problems that weakened the validity of the findings.

"I believe that we don't have evidence at this moment which would preclude using ICDs in women," Zareba said. "This is unfortunately only stirring the water and doesn't provide any useful clues."

More information

The American Heart Association has more on women and heart disease.

SOURCES: Christian Machado, M.D., director, electrophysiology, Providence Hospital Heart Institute, Southfield, Mich.; Seth Keller, M.D., associate director, cardiac electrophysiology, Lenox Hill Hospital, New York City; Wojciech Zareba, M.D., director, Heart Research Follow-up Program, University of Rochester Medical Center, Rochester, N.Y.; Sept. 14, 2009, Archives of Internal Medicine

Copyright©2009 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. Implantable device designed to detect, stop seizures under study at MCG
2. GrantAdler Shipping Novel Implantable Vascular Access Port
3. URGENT Thoratec Corporation Worldwide Recall of Implantable Ventricular Assist Device
4. EaglePicher Technologies Introduces First Implantable Medical Cell Designed Specifically for Monitoring Applications
5. Implantable medical devices may expose patients to security, privacy risks; solutions suggested
6. Northwestern Memorial trials implantable device to manage congestive heart failure symptoms
7. Texcel Introduces Innovative Programmable, Implantable Stimulation System for R&D of Specialty Stimulation Therapies
8. Long-Term Results of VisionCares Implantable Telescope for End-Stage Macular Degeneration Published in the American Journal of Ophthalmology
9. MP3 headphones interfere with implantable defibrillators, pacemakers
10. Implantable monitor may help in managing diastolic heart failure
11. Access MediQuip and WellPoint Finalize First National Contract for Implantable Medical Devices
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Implantable Defibrillators May Not Help Women With Heart Failure
(Date:10/10/2015)... ... 2015 , ... Story Chaser is a one-of-a-kind app that makes ... and inspiring stories and as words drop down and users tap the corresponding word. ... and can be interacted with, making it a more engaging game. Users can use ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... ... Doctors on Liens has teamed up with a renowned medical practice, ... to personal injury victims. When personal injury victims suffer major, complex injuries, they ... of conditions ailing them. With the addition of this new group of doctors ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... ... A new health tool that helps identify if a sore throat is ... – just in time for the cold and flu season, which the Center for ... the U.S., the real start of cold/flu season is the start of the school ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... 2015 , ... Head Over Heels Athletic Arts gymnast, Madelyn Williams, will attend ... Ranch in Huntsville, Texas on October 17-21. , "It's very exciting to be ... and executive director, said. “It's a stepping stone into the U.S. elite system where ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... Orleans, LA (PRWEB) , ... October 09, 2015 ... ... with offices serving New Orleans and the surrounding communities, is initiating a combined ... and medical care for unwanted animals in southern Louisiana. , Animal Rescue ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
... from exposure to medications, chemicals and other agentsSAN DIEGO, ... taking cold medication or using certain cleaning products can ... A new Web site ( ) ... latest information about the potential risks of exposure to ...
... restore sight, experts suggest , , THURSDAY, March 5 (HealthDay ... in two forms of childhood blindness has been identified ... of the link between the retinal gene SPATA7 and ... because it pinpoints a new retinal metabolic disease pathway ...
... 100 property and casualty insurers closed 2008 with net ... while the top 100 life insurers suffered unprecedented unrealized ... 2008 Top 100 Performance Monitor revealed a 67.7 percent ... industry,s top property and casualty insurers, from $48.8 billion ...
... Americas, Europe and Asia to Realize New Executive ... Tokyo Stock Exchange), a leading medical diagnostics ... announced executive leadership changes at Sysmex Corporate and ... Effective April 1, 2009, Kazuya Obe will ...
... stroke and heart disease are potential complications of type ... Americans. Now research from Tel Aviv University has found ... a risk factor accelerating cognitive decline and dementia. ... TAU,s Sackler School of Medicine, found that people with ...
... 2009 Many doctors don,t offer emergency contraception ... during emergency department visits because of misinformation about ... by The Children,s Hospital of Philadelphia. , ... reduce unintended pregnancy, the study,s authors said. ...
Cached Medicine News:
(Date:10/8/2015)...  The National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute ... Broad Institute of MIT and Harvard to provide ... well as data to support smaller pilots in ... for Precision Medicine (TOPMed) program and serves ... which will use whole genome sequencing to drive ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... 2015 ... "Natural Language Processing Market for Health ... (Rule-Based, Statistical, & Hybrid NLP Solutions), Region ... Africa, Latin America) - Global Forecast to ... --> ) has announced the ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... Oct. 08 2015 ... "Global API Market Outlook 2020" report ... has announced the addition of the "Global ... offering. --> Research and Markets ( ... "Global API Market Outlook 2020" report ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
... Aug. 31, 2011 BioDelivery Sciences International, Inc. (Nasdaq: ... three upcoming investor conferences.  Dr. Mark A. Sirgo, President ... where he will focus on BDSI,s product pipeline, particularly ... which data from the pivotal Phase 3 efficacy study ...
... 2011 Elbit Imaging Ltd. (NASDAQ: EMITF) ... placed an Investor Relations Presentation relating to its Sources and ... "Investor Relations - Company Presentations -Analysis of Sources and Uses." ... Imaging Ltd. operates in the following principal fields of business: ...
Cached Medicine Technology:
Symbia T6, a True Point SPECT·CT system, combines a dual-detector variable angle gamma camera with a six slice CT scanner for advanced oncology, neurology, and cardiology applications....
... ACOM.PC turns every standard PC into ... internists, and cardiologists can use their ... access to image data thanks to ... 3 format and the compatible storage ...
... Soarian Cardiovascular Enterprise is a comprehensive ... care continuum from admission to follow-up. ... image acquisition, and diagnostic tools from ... provide a single, longitudinal clinical repository ...
... accurate lesion assessment plays a ... the appropriate stent size and ... (IC3D), a highly precise three-dimensional ... now able to quickly quantify ...
Medicine Products: