Navigation Links
Human guinea pigs wary of high-paying medical trials
Date:12/4/2009

  • More than 15 million Americans are recruited annually to participate in clinical trials according to the Alliance for Human Research Protection (AHRP), and most will be compensated for their participation.

  • Research institutions view payments to volunteers as compensation for time and expenses; not as compensation for potential risks related to participating in the experiments.

  • A new study finds that volunteers have a very different view of clinical trial compensation. High-paying research studies raise a red flag for human guinea pigs and signal high levels of risk.

The findings from a study published this month by the journal Social Science and Medicine have implications for informed consent in human subjects research and the debate over research participation incentives.

Cynthia Cryder, assistant professor of Marketing at the Olin Business School, Washington University in St. Louis, is the lead author of the study, "Informative Inducement: Study Payment as a Signal of Risk"*. Her co-authors are Alex John London and George Loewenstein at Carnegie Mellon University and Kevin G. Volpp at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine and the Wharton School.

"At a big-picture level, what stands out from these results is that research participants do not just consider participation payments as an incentive to be traded off for their time." Cryder explains. "They actually infer information about the study itself from the participation payment."

Cryder and colleagues conducted three experiments to measure people's interest in participating in potentially risky research studies, their perception of the risk associated with those studies and how payment amounts affected their interest and perceptions.

Experiments for the study were conducted with an online nationwide sample or a sample from a northeastern U.S. city in 2007-2008.

The study finds that while high pay is a real incentive for people to participate in clinical trials, it also increases the "perceived risk" of the trial and the time potential volunteers spend researching and viewing information about risks related to the trial.

"Specifically in our experiments," Cryder explains, "they [participants] judge studies that offer high payments to be riskier than identical studies that offer low payments."

George Loewenstein, the Herbert A. Simon Professor of Economics and Psychology at Carnegie Mellon and co-author of the study, says these findings contradict some of the common guidelines used for establishing participation incentives:

"Most organizations that do research prohibit participation payments that substantially exceed compensation for time and expenses. The fear is that people will be overly tempted by high payments to take excessive risks. Our research challenges this common practice. It suggests that people assume that studies that don't pay much aren't risky."

The study concludes that there is a "mismatch" between current research guidelines for setting compensation levels and the assumptions participants make about the levels of pay and risk. Loewenstein explains:

"Contrary to the assumption that high payments are excessively tempting, our research suggests that they alert subjects to potential risk and make them more vigilant about protecting themselves. An added bonus of high payments is that it is ethically sensible for people to be adequately compensated when they do, in fact, incur risks."

The authors of the study believe their findings should contribute to the debate over research participation incentives and informed consent. The way potential human subjects interpret payment, risk and information about clinical trials as documented in the Cryder et al paper sheds new light on the role of the human subjects in research.


'/>"/>

Contact: Melody Walker
melody_walker@wustl.edu
314-935-5202
Washington University in St. Louis
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Humana Launches Dancetown on Tues., Dec. 8 in Kissimmee
2. The WFH receives the largest humanitarian aid donation in its history - Donation represents more than 40 million international units to the WFH
3. The therapeutic benefits of the human-animal bond
4. Bono and Wyclef Jean Receive RFK Center for Justice & Human Rights Ripple of Hope Award
5. Coal Pollution Damages Human Health at Every Stage of Coal Life Cycle, Reports Physicians for Social Responsibility
6. Human Pheromone Sciences Announces Third Quarter Results
7. Physicians for Human Rights Offers Training in Crime Scene Documentation
8. NIAID announces new human immunology research awards to help fight emerging infectious diseases
9. Not What the Doctor Ordered: Rapid Environmental Change Threatens the Foundations of Human Health
10. Precuneus region of human and monkey brain is divided into 4 distinct regions
11. NovaBays Aganocides Show Penetration and Efficacy in a Pre-Clinical Infected Human Nail Model of Onychomycosis
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:10/15/2019)... , ... October 15, 2019 , ... ... FDA’s Most Recent IFU Guidance , **An FDAnews Webinar**, Tuesday, October 29, 2019, ... for Use (IFU) guidance have on new drug applications and biologics license applications? ...
(Date:10/11/2019)... ... ... Inland Detox, Inc. has just moved to a new location in the ... Temecula Valley and it’s the perfect place for long-term residential alcohol and substance ... well as double occupancy rooms, a 2nd home where all treatment takes place, a ...
(Date:10/10/2019)... , ... October 10, 2019 , ... ... Annual Conference, Nutrition 21 was excited to hear the significant results of an ... blood flow impact of Nitrosigine®. The clinical study poster entitled “The Acute Effects ...
(Date:10/8/2019)... ... , ... Dr. Amir HagShenas of Silicon Valley Smile Solutions uses effective treatments ... common and treatable condition. Dr. HagShenas’ goal is to treat gum disease ... including tender and bleeding gums, and to prevent gum disease from progressing. , Those ...
(Date:10/8/2019)... ... , ... Over the past three decades, Buffalo Wings & Rings has elevated ... by providing a higher-quality product and experience than the competition. Now, the club-level sports ... A MUG FOR THE CAUSE" campaign in support of Breast Cancer Awareness Month. ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:10/8/2019)... ... October 08, 2019 , ... Dr. Ryan McNally, ND, ... 2019 Academy of Integrative Health and Medicine conference. Their presentation titled Advances in Integrative ... and how they can be used to promote brain health, and reduce the debilitating ...
(Date:10/8/2019)... ... October 08, 2019 , ... Respected dentist, Dr. Kenneth ... to enhance his skill and knowledge of dental implant diagnosis, placement and maintenance. ... four-part series of classes that combines in-depth lectures with hands-on workshops. Halfway through ...
(Date:10/8/2019)... ... October 08, 2019 , ... Fresno resident Regina Tanner has been selected by ... donor honoree. Regina will walk alongside the float, Light in the Darkness, during the ... and attorney, became a living organ donor in the fall of 2016 when her ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: