Navigation Links
How accurate are hospital report cards?
Date:9/8/2009

MAYWOOD, Il. A key statistic that consumer groups and the media often use when compiling hospital report cards and national rankings can be misleading, researchers report in a new study.

The statistic is called the mortality index. A number above 1.0 indicates a hospital had more deaths than expected within a given specialty. Lower than 1.0 means there were fewer than the expected number of deaths.

The study by Loyola University Health System researchers in the Journal of Neurosurgery illustrates how the mortality index can be misleading in at least two major specialties -- neurology and neurosurgery. The index fails to take into account such factors as whether a hospital treats complex cases transferred from other hospitals or whether a hospital treats lower-risk elective cases or higher-risk non-elective cases.

"A hospital with a lower mortality index may not be a better hospital for patient care, but rather a place where the patient mix has been refined or limited," said senior author Dr. Thomas Origitano, chairman of the Department of Neurological Surgery, Loyola University Stritch School of Medicine.

There is no "definitive or reliable source for rating the quality of overall neurosurgical care," Origitano and colleagues wrote in the Journal of Neurosurgery, published by the American Association of Neurological Surgeons.

Researchers examined neurosurgical mortality data from 103 academic medical centers in the University HealthSystem Consortium. Hospitals with the worst mortality index tended to be Level 1 trauma centers with busy emergency rooms and a high percentage of Medicaid patients.

A Level 1 trauma center with a busy ER is more likely to treat severe and complex cases such as head and spinal injuries from car accidents, injuries from falls or gunshot wounds. And the reason a high percentage of Medicaid patients is associated with a high mortality index is likely because Medicaid patients are more likely to have "poor access to medical care, are poorly educated in health and hygiene, are uninsured and present only once their symptoms have become severe," researchers wrote.

The study also found that in hospitals with the lowest mortality index, at least 87 percent of the neurosurgical cases were elective in nature. Elective surgery includes cases such as back surgery or decompression of a pinched nerve. Patients deemed to be at too high a risk do not undergo the surgery.

By contrast, non-elective surgery for such conditions as head injuries and spine infections generally has to be done even when the risks are high.

Researchers cited several other problems with rating systems. For example, report cards typically lump neurology and neurosurgery into one category, neurosciences. "Although both services treat many of the same pathological processes, their performance at any given institution is by no means shared," researchers wrote. "This can be misleading if the neurology aspects of the rating system misrepresent the neurosurgical service or vice versa."

Another common practice is using reputation as one of the main ranking criteria. This practice "is at best subjective," researchers wrote.

Researchers wrote that misleading information in report cards and rakings "may falsely direct patients and their families to hospitals providing a lower level of neurosurgical care, or direct them away from hospitals providing a high level of neurosurgical care."


'/>"/>

Contact: Jim Ritter
jritter@lumc.edu
708-216-2445
Loyola University Health System
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. New research findings pave the way to more accurate interpretation of brain imaging data
2. Utilizing GPS-like Measurement Precision To More Accurately Determine Overall Performance
3. Varian Medical Systems Receives 510(k) Clearance for Fast and Accurate Acuros(TM) Radiotherapy Treatment Planning Capability
4. Mayo Clinic study using structural MRI may help accurately diagnose dementia patients
5. Mayo Clinic Study Using Structural MRI May Help Accurately Diagnose Dementia Patients
6. MRI Accurately Depicts Deep Endometriosis
7. MRI accurately depicts deep endometriosis
8. Glucose challenge test is accurate and economical for diabetes and prediabetes screening
9. New accurate diagnostic test for swine H1N1 influenza using RT-PCR technology
10. MedSolutions: Accurate Diagnosis Is Critical to Reducing Healthcare Costs
11. Craneware Supports Hospitals Compliance and Upfront Collections with Accurate Estimates
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/24/2016)... ... May 24, 2016 , ... Local engineering firm, Timmons ... Medical Center located in Woodbridge, VA. The project includes a brand new ... site. , The new 2 story building houses the Central Sterile department, Sterile ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... ... May 24, 2016 , ... Mental health watchdog Citizens Commission on Human ... renowned professor of psychiatry Thomas Szasz, is continuing its protest against the use of ... exhibit in Atlanta, Georgia. The opening of the exhibit follows CCHR’s recent protest at ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... ... May 24, 2016 , ... Loma Linda University Health (LLUH) has officially broken ... Children’s Hospital. Over 3,000 people looked on as the shovels hit the dirt at ... slidehsow. , During the program, Richard H. Hart, MD, DrPH, president, LLUH, recapped ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... ... May 24, 2016 , ... ... perfect data logger for each job, ensuring the best suited solution to meet ... MadgeTech data loggers at their lab in Istanbul. , Metroloji Okulu specializes in ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... ... May 24, 2016 , ... Growing in popularity, more and ... gluten-free products are available and easily accessible. Whether someone chooses to cut gluten out ... a certain diet, King Kullen Grocery stocks their shelves with many different gluten-free products ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/24/2016)... 2016 Celsion Corporation (NASDAQ: ... provided an update on its ongoing OVATION study, ... GEN-1, the Company,s DNA-based immunotherapy, with the standard ... with advanced ovarian cancer who will undergo neoadjuvant ... an IL-12 DNA plasmid vector formulated as a ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... 24, 2016 Los innovadores ... del mundo, introduce catéteres para la intervención de ... una compañía global especializada en el suministro de ... su cartera incluyendo productos para tratar la enfermedad ... PTA son los dispositivos de primera entrada de ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... 24, 2016 Dutch surgeons have launched a ... the world and treat patients on a global scale. Medical professionals ... Asia and the US have already signed ... and networking in a totally secure environment. Education  ... zone working together with a surgeon at Harvard to treat a ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: