Navigation Links
Hospitals face legal dilemma if they test incapacitated patients after needle accidents

Anaesthetists are calling for greater clarity on the legal implications of testing incapacitated patients for blood-borne viruses, after a survey found that this is often done following staff needlestick injuries, in possible breach of UK legislation.

The paper, in the September issue of Anaesthesia, reports on the results of an anonymous survey of intensive care units in England, Wales and Northern Ireland.

It is accompanied by an editorial by Dr Andrew Hartle, chair of the multi-disciplinary working party set up by the Association of Anaesthetists of Great Britain and Ireland (AAGBI) to explore the legal dilemma facing healthcare professionals who carry out such tests.

UK researchers sent the survey to 225 intensive care units in England, Wales and Northern Ireland and 99 responded.

"Our survey showed that 63 per cent of the units who responded had recorded an incident where a member of staff had suffered a needlestick injury while caring for an incapacitated patient in the last 12 months" says the paper's lead author Dr Lorna Burrows.

Analysis of the results showed that:

  • In just over 90 per cent of cases (56 patients) staff did not know whether the incapacitated patient had a blood borne virus (BBV). Staff were already aware of the full BBV positive status of the remaining ten per cent.
  • 36 patients were tested at the time of the injury and ten were found to have a BBV. In six cases this represented the first diagnosis of a BBV. In the other four cases staff knew the patient had at least one BBV, but felt the need to test for others.
  • 22 patients were told they had been tested when they regained consciousness (61 per cent). Three were not told, one patient died before they could be spoken to and it is not known what happened in the other 10 cases.
  • Less than a third of the healthcare workers took post-exposure medication following their injury and less than half took this action even when they knew the patient had a BBV.

"Needlestick injuries are very common in the UK National Health Service and account for 17 per cent of accidents" says Dr Burrows. "The annual incidence is estimated to be as high as 623 per 10,000 staff, but poor reporting could mean that it is even higher.

"Guidance issued by the Department of Health suggests that employers have a responsibility to assess and manage the risks associated with needlestick injuries and protocols are generally managed by occupation health departments. This includes screening for BBVs such as HIV and hepatitis.

"If the patient is conscious, they can be asked questions about their medical history and for permission for blood tests to be carried out. But if the patient is unconscious, they cannot give consent. If staff test a patient's blood without their consent, and this test is solely for the benefit of the healthcare worker who has had the needlestick injury, then it could be argued that this is unlawful under the Human Tissue Act 2004 and the Mental Capacity Act 2005."

This means that UK hospitals - and the healthcare professionals who work for them face the dilemma of how to protect staff after a needlestick injury, while at the same time protecting patients' rights.

The authors state that three possible arguments have been put forward for performing a BBV test on an unconscious patient after a needlestick injury.

  1. It is likely to be in the patient's best interest to establish a diagnosis of HIV infection as this enables treatment to commence as soon as possible. Testing a patient who lacks the capacity to consent is therefore lawful.

  2. The patient would be likely to provide consent, if asked, to avoid the healthcare worker having to suffer the side effects of unnecessary medication or the anxiety of not knowing the patient's BBV status. The problem with this argument is that it cannot be assumed that consent would be forthcoming in fact, this research showed that one patient refused to be tested when they regained capacity.

  3. It has been argued that the healthcare worker has a right to know the BBV status of the patient if they have sustained a needlestick injury. Under Article 2 of the Human Rights Act, the healthcare worker's right to know could be deemed greater than the right of the patient not to know. This has not been formally tested in a court of law, but this argument currently appears to be unlawful.

"Our survey shows that significant numbers of intensive care unit staff in the UK suffer needlestick injuries and it is not unusual that these can come from patients who test positive for BBVs" concludes Dr Burrows.

"It highlights the need for further discussion within the profession and with legislators regarding needlestick injuries and the legality of testing incapacitated patients for blood-borne virus infections."

"Dr Burrows' paper is very important because it highlights, once again, that legislation introduced with the best intentions has had unforeseen consequences and that urgent clarification is required" says Dr Andrew Hartle, Honorary Secretary Elect of the AAGBI and chair of the working party set up to explore this issue. "It is also very well timed, as a survey of working practices is one of the recommendations of the working group."

Dr Hartle's editorial provides a detailed analysis of the legal dilemma facing doctors, the possible implications for staff who test without consent and recommendations for change.

"We are very conscious that testing without consent could leave our members open to criminal law, civil law and professional misconduct proceedings" he says.

"That is why we and our working party colleagues who include the Royal College of Anaesthetists, Intensive Care Society, Royal College of Nursing, ethicists and patient representatives feel that urgent clarification is needed."


Contact: Annette Whibley

Related medicine news :

1. The private sale of drugs in public hospitals
2. Most pandemic plans in Ontario hospitals have not been tested: Queens University study
3. SHARECOR Partners With Quantros, Inc. to Facilitate Core Measures and Regulatory Reporting in Louisiana Hospitals
4. Kaiser Foundation Health Plan and Hospitals Report Fourth Quarter and Fiscal Year 2009 Financial Results
5. Father Channels His Grief into Advocacy, Promotes Simple Actions to Make Hospitals Safer for Children
6. Vestara and EXP Pharmaceutical Services Corp. Announce Partnership Making Available Industry's Only Automated Pharmaceutical Waste Management Solution to over 5,000 U.S. Hospitals
7. Small to Mid-Sized Hospitals Turn to Orion Health to Implement Health IT Solutions for Improved Patient Care and Outcomes
8. Patients Do Better at Hospitals That Follow Stroke Guidelines
9. Evidence-based care and outcomes improve at Get With The Guidelines-Stroke hospitals
10. Global Hospitals and Healthcare Suppliers Focus on Cutting Costs and Improving Quality at 2010 GHX Supply Chain Summit
11. COBRAGuard Partners With THA to Offer Texas Hospitals COBRA Relief
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/10/2015)... , ... October 10, 2015 , ... The sixth annual ... on the growth of cybercrime costs for US companies. The New York Times broke ... 6th. With averages showing increases hovering around 20% among the companies surveyed, it only ...
(Date:10/10/2015)... Arbor, MI (PRWEB) , ... October 10, 2015 , ... ... City, MO. , On the heels of the release of the Institute of ... of tools, and their integration with Cerner solutions that assist healthcare providers and consumers ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... The American ... Dean for Graduate Medical Education J. Michael Finley, DO, as the recipient of ... selected for his impact on graduate medical education opportunities for osteopathic residents, and ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... A new health tool ... Aid, is now available online ( ) – just in time for the ... officially begins in October. However, for many in the U.S., the real start of ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... , ... October 09, 2015 , ... ... a special promotion on Invisalign, the orthodontic system that uses clear, plastic aligners. ... are almost invisible against the teeth, which allow patients to complete treatment in ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
... (HealthDay News) -- Drinking too much alcohol can lead to ... the most common cause of HIV infection and finding ways ... health efforts to prevent HIV/AIDS. Alcohol use has long ... whether unsafe sex associated with alcohol use actually led to ...
... MONDAY, Dec. 12 (HealthDay News) -- Breast cancer survivors ... treatment with radiation and/or chemotherapy, a new study says. ... and treatment-specific ways that these cancer therapies impair cancer ... Moffitt Cancer Center and Research Institute in Tampa, Fla., ...
... , Researchers at the Norwegian University of Life Sciences ... new method for detailed analyses of electrical activity in ... can help doctors and researchers to better interpret ... considerable steps forward in terms of interpreting for example ...
... has found that alcohol consumption directly impacts a person,s intention to ... the stronger becomes your intention to engage in unsafe sex. ... infection, and it is a main risk factor for the global ... prevent unsafe sex, HIV incidence in most high income countries (such ...
... leukemia patients, own infection-fighting cells appears to protect ... with fludarabine-based chemotherapy, according to new research from ... of Pennsylvania. The new process is a step ... from the commonly prescribed drug, which improves progression-free ...
... Researchers at the Stanford University School of Medicine report ... physical force contributes to scarring in mice. "Our ... the mechanical environment can directly increase inflammation, which is ... and associate chair of surgery. Mice genetically engineered ...
Cached Medicine News:
(Date:10/9/2015)... -- --> --> ... of an Intellectual Property & Subsidiary Assignment and an Assignment & Assumption ... Corporation, related party, and a majority holder of 88% ... --> These agreements were executed as part of ... and Development components shall now be separate from the ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... 2015  The Centers for Disease Control and ... Zoonotic Infectious Diseases, Office of Advanced Molecular Detection ... research collaboration to evaluate the performance of Edico ... research collaboration is to evaluate the utility of ... and infectious disease applications. This collaboration will also ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... Texas , Oct. 9, 2015   Lexicon Pharmaceuticals, ... from the TELESTAR Phase 3 clinical study of telotristat etiprate ... Tumor Society annual symposium to be held from October 15-17, ... from interviews with patients who completed the randomized treatment portion ... time in a poster session. --> ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
... Questcor Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (NASDAQ:  QCOR) announced today that executive ... be held August 9-11, 2011 at the InterContinental Boston in ... is scheduled to present an overview of the Company on ... To listen to the audio web cast of the ...
... REDWOOD CITY, Calif., July 28, 2011 Codexis, Inc. ... I. Mizutani, Executive Vice President, Upstream Business, Raizen Energia ... of Directors. Mr. Mizutani serves as the Board representative ... holds approximately 16% of Codexis, outstanding shares of common ...
Cached Medicine Technology:
Optipress II Automated Blood Component Extractor for the standardized separation of whole blood into high purity individual components...
... Distriman is a ... that is designed to ... used with Gilson DistriTip ... polypropylene syringes with level ...
The Eppendorf Maxipettor is a continuously adjustable pipette for precise pipetting of volumes up to 10 ml (in 10 l increments). Even liquids with a high vapor pressure or viscosity can be pipetted w...
... Plus, a handheld manual dispenser, is ideal ... long series pipetting. Its increased volume selection ... research tasks, and its smooth handling reduces ... The nine Combitips allow a wider range ...
Medicine Products: