Navigation Links
Home Defibrillators Fail to Boost Survival Rates
Date:4/1/2008

But they still may be valuable for heart attack patients, study suggests

TUESDAY, April 1 (HealthDay News) -- Putting external defibrillators in the homes of people after they had a heart attack didn't improve their survival rate, a new study found.

But, the leader of the study still sees plenty of encouraging news in the research and is not necessarily ruling out the use of those heart-shocking devices in the home.

In a 37-month trial, half of 7,001 heart attack survivors had defibrillators put in their homes, while the other half got standard instructions to call for emergency help if a second heart attack occurred. But, the death rate for both groups was just about the same -- 222 of the people given defibrillators and 228 of those not given the devices, said study leader Dr. Gust H. Bardy, director of the Seattle Institute for Cardiac Research.

The findings were to be presented Tuesday at the American College of Cardiology annual meeting, in Chicago, and were published in the April 1 online edition of the New England Journal of Medicine. The results were also expected to be published in April 24, 2008, print issue of the journal.

People in the study weren't considered suitable for implanted defibrillators. The devices they took home were identical to those now found in many public places for use in cardiac emergencies.

"It really amazed me that the survival prospects for this group were so promising," Bardy said. "A 2 percent-a-year death rate for 60-year-old patients, that surprises me."

Most of the deaths in the defibrillator group were due to non-cardiac causes, Bardy noted. "The event rate was so low," he said of cardiac deaths, "and the usage of the defibrillators is less than it should be. It's not that the devices are ineffective. When they were used, they did real well."

The defibrillators, which deliver an electric shock to restart an arrested heartbeat, were used 18 times, and six of those people survived, Bardy said. "Long-term survival of one out of three is not bad," he said.

Partly because of the high cost of external defibrillators, their home use should not be encouraged, said an accompanying editorial in the journal by Dr. David J. Callans, professor of medicine at the University of Pennsylvania. "Future efforts should turn toward education, modification of risk factors and other methods for primary prevention of heart disease," Callans said in a statement.

But Dr. Robert Femia, chairman of emergency medicine at Lenox Hill Hospital in New York City, disagreed with Callans. "Early defibrillation offers the best chance for survival," Femia said. "My point is that there may be a role for a defibrillator as part of a plan developed by your physician on an individual basis."

Such a plan usually is lacking after a heart attack, Bardy said. "One thing that is not standard practice is consciousness-raising," he said. "Most post-myocardial infarct [heart attack] patients don't have a discussion of mortality, don't have a discussion of cardiac arrest, don't have a discussion of what to do if there is a cardiac arrest."

Any discussion with a doctor after a heart attack should include advice about carefully taking any medications that are prescribed, Bardy said, and about other medical measures needed to keep arteries clear.

When such steps are taken, he said, "the patient may or may not choose an external defibrillator. I see no downside for an external defibrillator. Whether or not it will help in the long run, I don't know."

More information

The facts about external defibrillators are available from the U.S. Food and Drug Administration.



SOURCES: Gust H. Bardy, M.D., director, Seattle Institute for Cardiac Research, Seattle, Wash.; Robert Femia, M.D., chairman, emergency Medicine, Lenox Hill Hospital, New York City; April 1, 2008, presentation, American College of Cardiology annual meeting, Chicago; April 1, 2008, New England Journal of Medicine, online


'/>"/>
Copyright©2008 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Several methods for enhancing the functioning of defibrillators in cases of heart attack
2. Defibrillators Not Dangerous While Driving
3. Plaintiffs Obtain $240 Million Amended Settlement In Guidant Defibrillators Products Liability Litigation
4. Women Less Likely to Get Heart Defibrillators
5. Green Tea Boosts Antibiotics for Superbugs
6. Abdominal Fat Boosts Dementia Risk
7. Drug Therapy Boosting Heart-Attack Survival Rates
8. Artery Plaque Boosts Hispanics Odds for Stroke
9. Stopping a receptor called nogo boosts the synapses
10. Frying Tumors Can Boost Lung Cancer Survival
11. Moms-to-Be Who Quit Smoking Boost Chances for Easygoing Child
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:2/28/2017)... , ... February 28, 2017 , ... ... premiere organization in North America for the scientific development, healthcare training and clinical ... Annual Meeting & Scientific Session on September 16-17 in Greenville, SC at the ...
(Date:2/28/2017)... Lake City, Utah (PRWEB) , ... February 28, 2017 , ... ... Month is a time for everyone to reaffirm their commitment to improving cardiovascular health ... cause of death for men and women. Every year, one in four deaths are ...
(Date:2/28/2017)... ... February 28, 2017 , ... Roxanna ... 4:30-5:30 p.m. at the 11th Annual RISE Nashville Summit. RISE Nashville is the ... analytics, and engagement strategies. , The discussion will include best practices for accurate ...
(Date:2/27/2017)... ... ... Robert E. Burke, MD, PhD, had a successful career as a pediatrician and ... have led him down a much different path. , In his book, “Beyond the ... Dr. Burke shares a personal account of the tribulations he encountered on his path ...
(Date:2/27/2017)... ... 2017 , ... Elisa Guajardo Carothers is not your typical author. She went from working as ... Now, she writes about God, when she isn’t swimming as a performing mermaid. , Her ... BS! (Before Satan),” she offers a comedic look at the dysfunctions of God’s family, before ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:2/27/2017)... 27, 2017  A landmark study led ... MBBS, PhD, FRACS, of  Sydney Heart and Lung ... will be published in the February 28, 2017 issue ... College of Cardiology . According to the study, which involved 37,720 ... surgery technique (anOPCABG) reduced postoperative stroke by ...
(Date:2/27/2017)... TAMPA, Fla. , Feb. 27, ... medical device company focused on developing cerebral embolic ... the members of the FDA,s Circulatory System Devices ... acknowledgement of the need for cerebral protection following ... "The statements shared by this FDA panel support ...
(Date:2/27/2017)... -- Now in its seventh year, the Pharmaceutical ... successful at developing and commercialising innovation. ... The Index can be summarised ... two different companies in early phase, which would make the ... of each company,s performance between 2011 and 2016, the 2017 ranking sees ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: