Navigation Links
Health-care worker hand hygiene rates increase three-fold when auditors visible
Date:7/8/2014

Hand hygiene rates were found to be three times higher when auditors were visible to healthcare workers than when there were no auditors present, according to a study in a major Canadian acute care hospital.

The study, titled, "Quantification of the Hawthorne effect in hand hygiene compliance monitoring using an electronic monitoring system: a retrospective cohort study," published today on-line in the BMJ Quality & Safety Journal, by first author Dr. Jocelyn Srigley, who did the study as part of her Master's thesis while a Clinical Fellow in Infection Prevention and Control at University Health Network and University of Toronto and senior author Dr. Michael Gardam, Director, Infection Prevention and Control, University Health Network and Women's College Hospital. Link: http://qualitysafety.bmj.com/cgi/rapidpdf/bmjqs-2014-003080?ijkey=JPbRe7gYzAFsm1Z&keytype=ref

The study examined the Hawthorne effect, also known as observation bias the tendency of people to change their behavior when they are aware of an observer using an electronic monitoring hand hygiene system in real-time, eliminating many of the biases inherent to human observation. Ultrasound "tags" on soap dispensers transmitted a signal to a nearby receiver each time the levers were pushed, and a time-stamped hand hygiene wash was recorded in a central data base.

Two inpatient units in University Health Network were electronically monitored, with 60 healthcare workers volunteering to be part of a study of the electronic monitoring system. Staff were aware that data would be used in a variety of studies, but were "blind" to the questions asked in the studies. Auditors did not announce their presence during audits but wore white lab coats. Auditors were also blinded to the questions asked in the research. Hand hygiene dispenses were electronically measured while the auditors were visible, and were compared to the same locations prior to the arrival of the auditors at one, two and three weeks before the audit, as well as to a different area of the unit not visible to the auditor. Auditors typically did not go into patient rooms, so separate hand washing rates were determined for dispensers inside patient rooms and those in hallways. Twelve audits were included between November 2012 and March 2013.

The study found that there was an approximately three-fold increase in the rate of hallway hand washes per hour amongst healthcare staff when an auditor was visible (3.75 per hour), compared to a location where the auditor was not visible (1.48 per hour) and to the previous weeks (1.07 per hour). Hand washing rates with the auditor present were compared to separate groups at different time periods and locations to ensure that the differences found were not due to hand hygiene patterns that could be attributable to time of day or location. In each instance, the hand washing rates were significantly higher when the auditors were present, with the increase occurring after the auditors' arrival, suggesting that the arrival of the auditor triggered the increase in hand hygiene.

"The difference in hand hygiene rates, when an auditor is present compared to those times when one is not, is huge in this study, and we showed this effect to be very consistent," says Dr. Gardam, who is also an Associate Professor of Medicine at the University of Toronto.

"The magnitude of what we found calls into question the accuracy of directly observed hand hygiene rates and the usefulness of measuring and reporting them," says Dr. Gardam. "That said, human auditing of hand hygiene has been helpful to draw attention to this important preventative measurewe just can't stop focusing on it because our posted rates are not nearly as high as we think they are."

Dr. Srigley says that although the researchers were "surprised at the tripling effect" of having an auditor present, there may still be some value in doing audits as there could be opportunities for in-the-moment education with health care staff. Dr. Srigley is the Associate Medical Director of Infection Prevention and Control at Hamilton Health Sciences, composed of seven hospitals in the Hamilton area.

Dr. Gardam suggests that a "front-line staff ownership" approach which engages rather than "nags" staff is a good option. This approach was first brought to University Health Network about six years by Dr. Gardam, in which front-line staff have developed their own reminders to influence staff to wash their hands, including: pancake breakfasts, public unit reporting, pledges, posters, and holding each other accountable.

"We need to change how we look at these complex problems," says Dr. Gardam, "We need to help people change by engaging them and having them come up with local solutions."


'/>"/>

Contact: Alex Radkewycz
Alexandra.Radkewycz@uhn.ca
416-340-2895
University Health Network
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Health-care law gender gap
2. Courts Verdict on Health-Care Reform Holds Surprises, Legal Experts Say
3. Is Courts Health-Care Ruling a Wise Decision? It Depends...
4. Supreme Court Ruling Sets Stage for Full Rollout of Health-Care Reform Law
5. Health-care costs hit the elderly hard, diminish financial wellbeing
6. Health-care costs at end of life exceed total assets for 25 percent of Medicare population
7. Partisanship Guides Americans Attitudes on Health-Care Reform Law: Poll
8. Health-care practitioners must cooperate to reduce medication mismanagement, MU expert says
9. Decontamination of unused medical supplies reduces health-care costs
10. Columbia nursing study finds women less at risk than men for health-care-associated infections
11. Homeless people much more frequent users of emergency department and other health-care services
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... In 1987, McDaniel & ... years in business this year, and they’re marking the milestone by undertaking a ... their patients. , It stands to reason that, given the central importance ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... ... has received a three-year grant totaling $975,000, renewing its funding from the Health ... Human Services. , This funding marks, the fourth time the HRSA administration has ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... SGNA Standards ... after every reprocessing cycle, both between patient procedures and before storage, is a ... is as important to the prevention of disease transmission and nosocomial infection as ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... Connexion Point, a technology-enabled ... list for the fourth consecutive year. With 197% revenue growth over the ... the nation’s fastest growing companies. , Previous honors include ranking 86th on ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... TX (PRWEB) , ... August 16, 2017 , ... ... the United States, named Dr. Douglas J. Harrison, as the new Medical Director of ... be the new facility Medical Director of our Sienna Plantation location,” said Dr. Michael ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:7/31/2017)... Tenn. , July 31, 2017 Three Tru-D SmartUVC ... Yongsan, South Korea . Tru-D, short for "Total Room ... and operating rooms after an environmental services (ES) professional cleans the area ... ... "Although the ...
(Date:7/27/2017)... EXTON, Pa., July 27, 2017  West Pharmaceutical Services, ... financial results for the second-quarter 2017 and updated financial ... Second-Quarter 2017 Highlights Reported ... 2.5% over the prior-year quarter. Net sales at constant ... 2017 reported-diluted EPS was $0.51, compared to $0.60 in ...
(Date:7/25/2017)... BARCELONA, Spain and CAMBRIDGE, Massachusetts ... SOM Biotech, specializing in repurposing drugs to treat rare nervous ... Therapeutics Inc. to clinically develop and market the drug SOM0226 ... reached, the drug achieved very promising results in a Phase ... A new office in the United ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: