Navigation Links
Health Insurance Reform DAILY MYTHBUSTER: 'Constitutionality of Health Insurance Reform'

WASHINGTON, Sept. 16 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Reform opponents continue to spread myths about components of America's Affordable Health Choices Act, including the nonsensical claim that the federal government has no constitutionally valid role in reforming our health care system -- apparently ignoring the validity of Medicare and other popular federal health reforms.

MYTH: "Health insurance reform could be unconstitutional... or violate the 10th amendment."

FACT: As with Medicare and Medicaid, the federal government has the Constitutional power to reform our health care system.

The 10th amendment to the U.S. Constitution states that the powers not delegated to the federal government by the Constitution, nor prohibited by it to the states, are reserved to the states... or to the people. But the Constitution gives Congress broad power to regulate activities that have an effect on interstate commerce. Congress has used this authority to regulate many aspects of American life, from labor relations to education to health care to agricultural production. Since virtually every aspect of the heath care system has an effect on interstate commerce, the power of Congress to regulate health care is essentially unlimited.

The 10th amendment does not authorize states to constrict Congress' power under the commerce clause. As the Supreme Court has held, Congress can bar racial discrimination in Ollie's Barbeque in Alabama (Katzenbach v. McClung) or the growing and sale of medical marijuana in California (Gonzales v. Raich), even in the face of state laws permitting such behavior.

The 10th amendment does place one significant limit on Congress and the federal government: Congress cannot "commandeer" state officials to administer programs. It must get the consent of state officials who are asked, e.g., to run health programs for the poor or to help build highways. Typically, Congress obtains that consent by providing financial support to the states. A state is free to refuse the support and refuse to assist the federal government in administering the program, but Congress can authorize the federal government to administer the program on its own. Thus, Congress cannot force a state to administer a health insurance exchange, but it can authorize the federal government to administer such an exchange in any state that declines to do so.

One of the myth's most highly visible proponents has now "backed away from earlier statements" here in an interview with ABC News' George Stephanopoulos:

STEPHANOPOULOS: So just to be clear, are you suggesting that any parts of the plan as the President has laid it out are unconstitutional?

Gov. PAWLENTY (R-Minnesota): Well, I wouldn't go so far as to say it's a legal issue. I was raising it as much as a practical matter, that there are some things that the federal government shouldn't do, doesn't do well, and should leave to the states."

On the shared responsibility requirement in the House health insurance reform bill, which operates like auto insurance in most states, individuals must either purchase coverage (and non-exempt employers must purchase coverage for their workers) -- or pay a modest penalty for not doing so. The bill uses the tax code to provide a strong incentive for Americans to have insurance coverage and not pass their emergency health costs onto other Americans -- but it allows them a way to pay their way out of that obligation. There is no constitutional problem with these provisions.


SOURCE Office of the Speaker of the House
Copyright©2009 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Insured Kids With Uninsured Parents Miss Needed Health Care
2. Soda Tax Wins Health Experts Support
3. Bay Medical Fights Healthcare-Associated Infections by Improving Hand Hygiene 300%
4. Nielsen Announces First-Ever CLIO Healthcare Awards Mixer on November 13th at Skyline Studios NYC
5. September 2009 Mayo Clinic Womens HealthSource Highlights Ovarian Cancer, Salt and Breaking a Sweat
6. AFSCME President McEntee: "Finance Committee Health Care Bill is Deeply Flawed"
7. Pelosi Statement on Senator Baucus Health Insurance Reform Proposal
8. Health Insurer Regence Applauds Chairman Baucus for Moving Health Reform Process Forward With a Bill Today
9. Townhall Comes to Washington: FRC Action to Host Congressional Forum on Health Care
10. YMCA Promotes Small Steps to a Healthier Lifestyle During America On the Move Week With the YMCA, Sept. 20-27, 2009
11. Riverside County Community Agencies Participate in Senior Sensitivity Training Provided by SCAN Health Plan
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... A novel class ... could be effective in fighting methicillin-resistant Staphylococcus aureus (MRSA), one of the major ... showed that small molecule analogs that target the functions of SecA, a central ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... , ... Using a combination of two blood sugar tests rather than a ... a new study by researchers at the School of Public Health at Georgia State ... of Blood Glucose Tests ,” published in Frontiers in Public Health, the researchers noted ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... International telepathology ... UPMC and KingMed Diagnostics researchers. Their review of more than ... with UPMC pathologists resulted in significantly altered treatment plans for more than half ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... The Foundation for Breast and ... prevention—is joining forces with the award-winning creator and writer of Downton Abbey Julian ... 2015 at the Union League of Philadelphia. , The benefit, titled “An ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... California-based i2i ... years, announced today that Michigan-based Family Health Center (FHC) has selected i2iTracks as ... years, FHC was awarded the largest Affordable Care Act grant for Federally Qualified ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/30/2015)... Nov. 30, 2015 Booth #4303 – The Imaging ... will exhibit a broader array of products in a new ... of North America in ... meeting will feature X-ray components "At the Heart of Imaging." ... of products from Varian,s Claymount brand, and computer-aided diagnostic software ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... EAST HANOVER, N.J. , Nov. 30, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... and portfolio at the 57 th American Society ... across leukemias, lymphomas and myelomas as well as supportive ... populations, in addition to personalized cell therapies. The ASH ... Orlando, Florida . Novartis Oncology ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... LONDON and BOSTON , ... to research and develop potential new medicines directed at ... multiple therapeutic areas. --> PFE ) to ... to 10 G protein-coupled receptor (GPCR) targets across multiple ... clinical-stage GPCR structure-guided drug discovery and development company and ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: