Navigation Links
Hard to make us personally or financially responsible for our health

Free and equal access to medical treatment has been a staple of the Danish welfare state, but more and more Danes express the view that people treated for lifestyle diseases like smoker's lungs or obesity should pay for their own treatment as these patients are thought to be responsible for their own medical conditions. The logic behind this view is, however, dubious, says PhD Martin Marchman Andersen from the University of Copenhagen. In a new thesis, he shows how difficult it is to defend the claim that people are responsible for their health and that it is very unclear what they should be held cost-responsible for.

"It is a tempting idea that we could cut health expenses by letting patients suffering from so-called lifestyle diseases pay for their own treatment. But this requires that we as a society can justify the claim that these people actually are responsible for their own conditions particularly in a welfare state where we have free and equal access to medical treatment. It is not, however, a claim that is easy to justify if we accept that we are products of genetics and social circumstances," says PhD Martin Marchman Andersen from the University of Copenhagen.

Free will vs. genetics and social legacy

A 2011 survey from the University of Copenhagen showed that almost 50 percent of the Danes believe that obese people should pay for their own obesity operations if they are shown to be responsible for their conditions. And according to Martin Marchman Andersen, these ideas are gaining ground as the Scandinavian welfare states struggle in the wake of the financial crisis and as we learn more and more about the causes of lifestyle diseases.

"The main argument of why we should be held responsible for our own health is the belief that we have free will; free will is the idea that we are the causes of our own actions and that our behaviour is not triggered by external factors. So if we say that a young man takes up smoking of his own free will, we also say that there is no previous cause. But it is very difficult to imagine that there is no previous cause at all, for instance that everybody the young man knows is a smoker and that he therefore would be an anomaly if he did not take up smoking," Martin Marchman Andersen points out and adds:

"The point is that the causal relationships within biology, sociology, and psychology we usually employ when we want to understand human behaviour must apply to lifestyle diseases too. It is not very likely that a young man who takes up smoking is immune to his genetic make-up or his social circumstances in such a way that we can justify the claim that he is responsible for smoking."

This does not mean that patients can never be held responsible, but we need other arguments than the ones we have used so far. And Martin Marchman Andersen underlines that even if we as a society decided that some patients in certain circumstances are to be held responsible for their own health, it would not automatically follow that we could just write out hospital bills to smokers in treatment for smoker's lungs.

Are smokers an economic burden?

Marchman Andersen's research shows that if smokers are to be held financially responsible for their health problems, the condition must be that they are proven to be an economic burden for society even when the complex impact calculations have been made.

"Economists have tried to calculate whether smokers cost society more than non-smokers, but they have not been able to reach a conclusive answer. And all the studies suffer from the same problem; they compare the costs of smokers with the costs of non-smokers, and that is too simplistic a model," says Martin Marchman Andersen and expands the point:

"We know from numerous studies in social inequality within health that lower social groups have a higher probability of contracting a number of diseases - even if they are non-smokers. Merely comparing the costs of smokers with the costs of non-smokers may lead to the conclusion that smokers cost more than non-smokers for reasons that have nothing to do with smoking."

If we want to know whether a smoker is an economic burden, Martin Marchman Andersen concludes, we should compare the costs of the smoker with the counterfactual costs if he had never been a smoker. Only in cases where the former costs exceed the latter costs, we can say the smoker is an economic burden. The smoker's financial responsibility is, in other words, the difference between the two types of costs.


Contact: Martin Marchman Andersen
University of Copenhagen

Related medicine news :

1. Mesothelioma Victims Center Now Urges All Victims of Mesothelioma Cancer to Call Them for the Names of the Best Mesothelioma Law Firms-Don't Get Financially Shortchanged
2. Helper T cells, not killer T cells, might be responsible for clearing hepatitis A infection
3. University of Hawaii cancer researchers discover gene defect responsible for cancer syndrome
4. miR-205 can be responsible for breast cancer
5. Vaccination responsible for dramatic fall in Salmonella infections
6. Drug targets hard-to-reach leukemia stem cells responsible for relapses
7. North American Seminars Introduces Responsible CME, a Program That Combined Live Physical Therapy Continuing Education with Online Continuing Education Courses
8. RundleFit Seeks Promotional Partnership with Socially Responsible, Healthy Lifestyle Brands For Their Six-Week Jump Start/Positive Incentive Program
9. You Survived Cancer: Now Pay Attention to Your Overall Health
10. NIH awards $20 million over 5 years to train next generation of global health researchers
11. Weill Cornell Medical College establishes Center for Healthcare Informatics and Policy
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... 13, 2015 , ... Symposium Chairman, Dr. Rod J. Rohrich is pleased to ... be held March 2nd and 3rd, 2016. The annual meeting, along with the ... physicians from around the world. , Key topics at this year's event will include ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... 13, 2015 , ... Relay (, a technology company that ... significant contract that will provide its award-winning private messaging solution to Independence Blue ... success of its Relay program, IBX Wire™, which now has over 550,000 members ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... 13, 2015 , ... NavaFit Inc. today announced the launch of its NavaFit ... participate in local fitness & sporting events, and stay motivated. Users can ... costs drive us to get more serious about fitness and wellness, individuals are constantly ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... October 13, 2015 , ... Protein is ... the body, including muscle, bone, and blood. But how much protein does the average ... than it might seem, according to the October 2015 issue of Harvard Men's ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... 2015 , ... Scientists in Seattle and Vancouver compared the diagnostic value of ... mesothelioma. Surviving Mesothelioma has just posted an article on the new research. Click ... and the University of British Columbia found that certain genetic alterations were seen just ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:10/13/2015)... EDISON, N.J. , Oct. 13, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... or the "Company"), a biopharmaceutical company focused on ... today announced the closing of its previously announced ... common stock and warrants to purchase up to ... a fixed combined price to the public of ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... 2015  Human Longevity, Inc. (HLI), the genomics-based, technology-driven ... today the launch of the company,s first Health Nucleus, ... potential to transform healthcare. The inaugural Health Nucleus is ... at HLI,s headquarters facility. More Health Nucleus facilities are ... International cities. --> ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... 2015  Measurement in accountable care programs is ... incentives, but gaps in measurement can result in ... systems. A new, peer-reviewed study published in ... explores measurement gaps for high-priority conditions and ... --> --> "These gaps ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: