Navigation Links
Government dietary guidelines, unintended consequences and public policy
Date:1/30/2008

also noting that an increasing prevalence of obesity in the United States has corresponded roughly with an absolute increase in carbohydrate consumption.

Dr. Marantz and colleagues present data that support these trends; however, they are careful to note that this temporal association does not prove causation. Instead, says Dr. Marantz, it raises the possibility of a net harmful effect of seemingly innocuous dietary advice. These dietary recommendations did not necessarily cause harm, but there is a realistic possibility that they may have.

In a commentary published in the same issue of the American Journal of Preventive Medicine, Steven H. Woolf, MD, MPH, from Virginia Commonwealth University and Marion Nestle, PhD, MPH, of New York University, maintain that the guidelines are supported by decades of research. While they agree with Dr. Marantz that people often compensate for low-fat intake by consuming more calories, they disagree that the guidelines were wrong to encourage low-fat diets. The guidelines were not the culprit, said Dr. Woolf, who believes that the government was right to share what was known about the dietary causes of disease.

Woolf and Nestle do not dispute that guidelines can have unintended consequences. However, they write, When the prevailing message fails to achieve its intended aims or achieves the wrong ends, the solution is not to abandon the enterprise but to reshape the message to achieve desired outcomes.

Continuing the dialog, Marantz, Bird and Alderman respond in a further commentary, When trying to mitigate potential harm from past guidelines based on inadequate science, issuing reshaped guidelines with similarly inadequate science merely perpetuates past mistakes. It might sometimes be best to avoid translating flaccid arguments into rigid guidelines. Ultimately, this boils down to a difference in world view, much like the distinction between clinicians guided by the therapeutic imperative and
'/>"/>

Contact: AJPM Editorial Office
eAJPM@ucsd.edu
858-457-7292
Elsevier Health Sciences
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Federal Government Receives Failing Grades on Tobacco Control in Annual American Lung Association Report
2. Bioniche Receives $5 Million of Federal Government Support to Scale-up Vaccine Production in Ontario
3. HealthSouth Announces Final Agreement on Previously Disclosed Settlement with Federal Government
4. Rh-Apo2L Named as One of Chinas High-Tech Transforming Products by Chinese Government
5. NCPA Study: Government, Insurers Keep Medicine in Stone Age
6. Lieutenant Governor Catherine Baker Knoll Accepts Women in Government Presidential Leadership Award
7. UK government has reneged on pledge for flexible working in NHS
8. UK Government (NHS) Selects Ericom to Enable Secure Application Access for its Medical and Administrative Staff
9. PharmAthene and Medarex Announce Additional $0.8 Million U.S. Government Appropriation for Continued Development of Anthrax Therapeutic Valortim(TM)
10. Government restrictions on weight loss surgeries limit access for poor, underinsured patients
11. Leading Oncologists from Across the Country Hold Emergency Meeting on New Government Reimbursement Policy for Medicare Patients with Cancer
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:7/12/2014)... 2014 A recent article released by Seattle's ... of suggestions for those seeking cosmetic surgical procedures in ... approaching and the heat begins to enliven the rainy Pacific ... clothing, realizing that they didn’t work out as much during ... cause a sudden surge of people eager to look their ...
(Date:7/12/2014)... Wright & Schulte LLC, an experienced law firm who ... (case #59776/2014), announces they have launched a new TV ... popular hair dye, Just For Men, has caused some men ... other areas. In addition to detailing symptoms that are allegedly ... advertisements being run by Wright & Schulte LLC will also ...
(Date:7/12/2014)... (PRWEB) July 12, 2014 ... score of 4.1 out of 5. This above-average ... have been underpinning buyer negotiation power over the ... analyst Anna Son, “during the period, surging demand ... costs associated with new product development, have placed ...
(Date:7/12/2014)... July 12, 2014 The largest pure ... is pleased to announce that it will be opening ... new facility will join four Atlanta-based Nova Medical Centers’ ... at 3209 Deans Bridge Road, and will be open ... , “With Nova’s treatment philosophy of rapid return-to-work ...
(Date:7/11/2014)... Recently, MagicQuinceaneraDresses.com, the popular online supplier of special ... Quinceanera dresses . The company’s new items are ... without paying a large amount of money. They are ... , The company’s online shop has become a one ... outfits. In addition to exquisite Quinceanera dresses, it also ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Best Summer Cosmetic Surgeries Revealed in Article By Seattle Plastic Surgeon 2Health News:Just for Men Lawsuit News: TV Campaign Launched by Wright & Schulte LLC to Inform Consumers of the Alleged Association between the Popular Hair Dye and Chemical Burns 2Health News:Just for Men Lawsuit News: TV Campaign Launched by Wright & Schulte LLC to Inform Consumers of the Alleged Association between the Popular Hair Dye and Chemical Burns 3Health News:Just for Men Lawsuit News: TV Campaign Launched by Wright & Schulte LLC to Inform Consumers of the Alleged Association between the Popular Hair Dye and Chemical Burns 4Health News:Floor-Grade Instruments Procurement Category Market Research Report from IBISWorld has Been Updated 2Health News:Floor-Grade Instruments Procurement Category Market Research Report from IBISWorld has Been Updated 3Health News:Floor-Grade Instruments Procurement Category Market Research Report from IBISWorld has Been Updated 4Health News:Nova Medical Centers To Open New Facility in Augusta, Georgia 2Health News:Cheap Quinceanera Dresses Now Available At MagicQuinceaneraDresses.com 2
... PolyScript(R) Labels Enable Fast and Cost-Effective CustomizationSOUTHFIELD, Mich., April ... manufactured specifically to provide equipment with safety warnings or ... to help engineering industries meet the exacting demands made ... (R) and PolyScript ...
... April 1 The following was released today ... Healthcare & Health IT Reporters, Editors, ... WHO: American Health Information Management Association ... Beyond Compliance to Strategic Advantage WHEN: ...
... Derma Sciences, Inc. ... care products, reported that sales for 2008 rose 47.1% year-over-year, ... higher sales of proprietary advanced wound care products led by ... $34.1 million in 2007. The Company,s loss increased consistent with ...
... The Quantum Group, Inc. (NYSE Amex: QGP ... transitioned to Continental Stock Transfer and Trust Company to act ... Quantum President & CEO, commented, "Continental Stock Transfer has been ... well regarded reputation as a comprehensive and customer-centric company that ...
... Alere,s groundbreaking Healthy Kids Program offers tools for ... costs estimated at $14 billion annually- Employers and ... First of its kind personalized solution that provides ... obesity and helps parents and kids become healthierMARIETTA, ...
... Could Save Millions on Expensive Social Services CHICAGO, ... for people who are homeless, have a mental illness, ... and cost of expensive public services such as state ... report released Thursday by the Heartland Alliance Mid-America Institute ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Schreiner ProTech Introduces Intelligent Marking Solutions Achieving Process and Cost Optimizations 2Health News:Derma Sciences Reports Fourth Quarter, Year-End Results for 2008 2Health News:Derma Sciences Reports Fourth Quarter, Year-End Results for 2008 3Health News:Derma Sciences Reports Fourth Quarter, Year-End Results for 2008 4Health News:Derma Sciences Reports Fourth Quarter, Year-End Results for 2008 5Health News:Derma Sciences Reports Fourth Quarter, Year-End Results for 2008 6Health News:Derma Sciences Reports Fourth Quarter, Year-End Results for 2008 7Health News:Derma Sciences Reports Fourth Quarter, Year-End Results for 2008 8Health News:The Quantum Group Announces Transition to Continental Stock Transfer 2Health News:The Quantum Group Announces Transition to Continental Stock Transfer 3Health News:New Online Program Helps Parents Tackle Childhood Obesity 2Health News:New Online Program Helps Parents Tackle Childhood Obesity 3Health News:Study Links Reduced Use of Mental Health Facilities, Nursing Homes and Other Public Services to "Smart Investments" in Supportive Housing 2Health News:Study Links Reduced Use of Mental Health Facilities, Nursing Homes and Other Public Services to "Smart Investments" in Supportive Housing 3Health News:Study Links Reduced Use of Mental Health Facilities, Nursing Homes and Other Public Services to "Smart Investments" in Supportive Housing 4Health News:Study Links Reduced Use of Mental Health Facilities, Nursing Homes and Other Public Services to "Smart Investments" in Supportive Housing 5
(Date:7/11/2014)... , July 11, 2014 Research ... "Global Hypodermic Needles Market 2014-2018" report to their ... A hypodermic needle is a hollow needle commonly ... body or or to extract fluids from it. A ... or to inject substances that cannot be ingested. Hypodermic ...
(Date:7/11/2014)... 2014 Research and Markets ( http://www.researchandmarkets.com/research/tjlw9k/immunoprotein ... "Immunoprotein Diagnostic Testing Market - Forecasts to 2019: ... 6% and is expected to be valued at ... http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20130307/600769 ... been segmented according to immunoprotein types which include ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... , 11. Juli 2014 /PRNewswire/ ... Kameras für die molekulare Bildgebung, einschließlich ... heute die CE-Zulassung für sein Navigator ... kann Dilon das Produkt jetzt europaweit ... den Großteil der europäischen Länder ausgedehnt ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Global Hypodermic Needles Market 2014-2018: Key Vendors are Becton, Dickinson and Co, Covidien, Retractable Technologies and Terumo Corp. 2Global Hypodermic Needles Market 2014-2018: Key Vendors are Becton, Dickinson and Co, Covidien, Retractable Technologies and Terumo Corp. 3Immunoprotein Diagnostic Testing Market - Forecasts to 2019: Expected to grow at the highest CAGR of 6% and is expected to be valued at USD 4,943.0 million 2Dilon erhält CE-Zulassung für sein Navigator-Gamma-Sondensystem 2
... study ... pediatric liver transplant patients, COLUMBIA, Md., Aug. 21 ... the peer-reviewed journal Liver Transplantation, have,further developed our understanding ... pediatric liver-transplant patients,post-transplantation., Working in a cooperative group ...
... 21 Novavax, Inc.,(Nasdaq: NVAX ) today announced ... discuss results from the Phase I/IIa human clinical,trial of ... Eastern Time on August 26, 2008., The call ... Dr. Rahul Singhvi and other members of senior management, ...
Cached Medicine Technology:New Data Support Earlier Suggested Guidance for Levels of Cell-Mediated Immunity in Pediatric Liver Transplant Patients 2New Data Support Earlier Suggested Guidance for Levels of Cell-Mediated Immunity in Pediatric Liver Transplant Patients 3Novavax to Present Phase I/IIa Trial Data Results in an Investor Conference Call on August 26, 2008 2
... national reference laboratory and a worldwide leader ... offers an extensive test menu of highly ... and anatomic pathology. Owned by the University ... than half of the nation's university teaching ...
... ARUP Laboratories is a national reference laboratory ... research and development. ARUP offers an extensive ... medical tests in clinical and anatomic pathology. ... Laboratories' clients include more than half of ...
... a national reference laboratory and a worldwide ... ARUP offers an extensive test menu of ... clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned by the ... more than half of the nation's university ...
... a national reference laboratory and a worldwide ... ARUP offers an extensive test menu of ... clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned by the ... more than half of the nation's university ...
Medicine Products: