Navigation Links
Go Ahead, Prove the Negative
Date:11/8/2007

WASHINGTON, Nov. 8 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The following was written by Frankie L. Trull, President of the Foundation for Biomedical Research:

Opponents of animal research are seeking to stimulate a debate where none exists, but their illogical arguments have flatlined and cannot be resuscitated.

Some people believe in the power and promise of biomedical research involving the humane use of animal models. Others oppose animal research and its inherent power and promise. To insist that there exists a legitimate debate between these two factions, over empirical proof, is a foolhardy notion.

The biomedical research community recognizes that virtually all medical advances of the last century resulted from animal research. The opposition, founded largely on an emotional response, speculates that animal research was not necessary to arrive at those historical advances.

Laboratory research on dogs and fish gave us insulin to treat diabetes. Opponents say the dogs and fish had nothing to do with the discovery of insulin but cannot prove that insulin would have been developed in their absence. The polio vaccine was developed following research on mice and monkeys. Take the mice and monkeys out of the equation, and where would the polio vaccine be? Clams and rats helped researchers illuminate the power of the MRI, a non-invasive imaging method for medical diagnosis. No clams, no rats: No MRI.

Posing the hypothetical question of whether or not these achievements of the last century could have been possible without animal research is the faulty logic. The fact is that modern society is immunized by vaccines, treated by medications, and saved by organ transplants. Researchers are constantly laboring to deliver effective treatments and cures for cancer, spinal cord injuries and diabetes.

Biomedical research boasts more than two centuries of illuminating discoveries. Development of the smallpox vaccine in 1796 was based on work with cows. This summer, researchers at the University of Wisconsin-Madison have made gains against Lou Gehrig's disease with the aid of some laboratory rats.

Whenever pitting sound science against faulty logic, be forewarned that sound science always wins.

Opponents of 200 years of solid scientific evidence suffer from biomedical research amnesia. The predictive relationship is the essence of the entire scientific argument. To suggest that there is no predictive relationship between animals and humans is to discount any interconnectivity between the species. It is an argument that carries no weight with serious scientists and medical professionals.

What replicates a living system better than -- brace yourself -- a living system? Computer modeling can work as an adjunct to, but not as a replacement for, animal models. People and animals share many of the same physiological systems. Likewise, they also carry many of the same diseases. Is it not natural, then, to find that humans and animals respond similarly to treatments? Finding one exception to predictability neither negates animal research successes nor impugns the very foundations of modern medicine.

Recognizing that predictability can be gleaned from animal models, government regulations and international law both require the research of treatments and cures on suitable animal models before they ever reach humans in clinical trials. Animal research, therefore, is not optional. We all agree cancer is evil. Some might say animal research is evil. But if animal research cures cancer tomorrow, can we live with a necessary evil today?

There is little to debate. The merits of animal research are part of the historical record. Researchers should not have to defend the value of their government-regulated work to militants who would stop at nothing. Their use of harassment, firebombing, arson and other extreme fear tactics not only discredits and weakens their side's stance; it also creates an arduous environment for researchers to continue vital work that turns out to benefit all members of society -- even the critics and protestors themselves.

How far can biomedical research take us? Can we find cures for breast cancer, AIDS, diabetes and spinal cord injuries? If animal research history has predictive value, then the future looks very promising. As for the opposition, if life-changing cures can be delivered without animal research, then they should prove it. If not, then opponents should step aside because there is serious work to accomplish.

This Op-Ed is the first in a series of three that defines the debate over animal research.

Frankie L. Trull is president of the Foundation for Biomedical Research, located in Washington, D.C.


'/>"/>
SOURCE Foundation for Biomedical Research
Copyright©2007 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Vision restoration therapy shown to improve brain activity in brain injured patients
2. Broad-based group of physicians calls for improvement in stroke treatment
3. FDA Approves First Anti-Psychotic for Kids
4. Frequent Prostate Screens Fail to Improve Aggressive Cancer Diagnoses
5. Pill box organizers increase HIV patients adherence and improve viral suppression
6. Nasal Anthrax Vaccine Proves Effective in Animal Study
7. Treating depression may improve recovery of heart rate variability following coronary syndromes
8. FDA Approves New Roche West Nile Virus Blood Screening Test
9. Study Demonstrates Marteks Algal DHA Oil Improves Blood Triglyceride Lipid Levels
10. AWWA, National Association of Water and Sanitation of Mexico, Agree to Share Expertise and Resources for Improved Water Supply
11. Exercise and yoga improves quality of life in women with early-stage breast cancer
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/25/2016)... ... May 25, 2016 , ... New studies published ... injured workers across 15 states. The outcomes examined in these studies include recovery ... care, and satisfaction with medical care. , “The goal of the studies is ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... , ... May 25, 2016 , ... CloudLIMS, joins an ... and Life Sciences Tech Solution Providers list of 2016 by CIOReview. , In a ... and Life Sciences Tech Solution Providers 2016 has been concluded with. The positioning is ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... ... May 25, 2016 , ... The World Molecular Imaging ... Molecular Imaging.” The focus of ADDMI-IG will be geared towards how using molecular ... issues. Through ADDMI-IG WMIS will provide a platform for productive discussions about the ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... ... 2016 , ... DKT International, one of the largest private ... to release their 2015 global impact data. In 2015, DKT served over 30 ... and 3.8 million unsafe abortions across 21 countries worldwide. , “We are ...
(Date:5/25/2016)... ... May 25, 2016 , ... Afrimesure specializes in ... and pharmaceutical, to food and HVAC facilities. Their knowledgeable staff also takes care ... For medical applications, Afrimesure offers a variety of MadgeTech systems available for sterilization ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/24/2016)... 2016 Niederländische Chirurgen haben ... es Ärzten erlaubt, ihre Expertise weltweit zu teilen ... Live Streaming mit einer Instant-Messaging-Funktion und der Möglichkeit, ... in Europa, Afrika, Asien und den ... Plattform registriert. Information und Weiterbildung   ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... , May 24, 2016 ... beide primären Endpunkte und ... Überlegenheit in ‚ausgezeichneter plus guter ... Colons    ,      (Logo: ... gab heute neue positive Daten von der MORA-Studie ...
(Date:5/24/2016)... 24, 2016  Diana Russell suffers from a form ... the inside out.  This disease has put her in ... children and grandchildren to leave her home.  Because of ... cannot haul the wheelchair.  So if there is a ... Diana is left to wait for the bus. ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: