Navigation Links
Fault trumps gruesome evidence when it comes to punishment
Date:8/3/2014

periences significant bodily harm from the fall and he dies from his injuries shortly after impact." And the graphic version reads, "Steve plummets to the rocks below. Nearly every bone in his body is broken upon impact. Steve's screams are muffled by thick, foamy blood flowing from his mouth as he bleeds to death."

After reading each scenario the participants were asked to list how much punishment John deserved on a scale from zero (no punishment) to nine (most severe punishment the subject endorsed).

When the responses were analyzed, the researchers found that the manner in which the harmful consequences of an action are described significantly influences the level of punishment that people consider appropriate: When the harm was described in a graphic or lurid fashion then people set the punishment level higher than when it was described matter-of-factly. However, this higher punishment level only applied when the participants considered the resulting harm to be intentional. When they considered it to be unintentional, the way it was described didn't have any effect.

"What we've shown is that manipulations of gruesome language leads to harsher punishment, but only in cases where the harm was intentional; language had no effect when the harm was caused unintentionally," summarized Michael Treadway, a post-doctoral fellow at Harvard Medical School and lead author of the study.

According to the researchers, the fact that the mere presence of graphic language could cause participants to ratchet up the severity of the punishments suggests that photographs, video and other graphic materials sampled from a crime scene is likely to have an even stronger impact on an individual's desire to punish.

"Although the underlying scientific basis of this effect wasn't known until now, the legal system recognized it a long time ago and made provisions to counteract it," said Treadway. "Judges are permitted to exclude relevant evidence f
'/>"/>

Contact: David Salisbury
david.salisbury@vanderbilt.edu
615-343-6803
Vanderbilt University
Source:Eurekalert  

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Electrical switch during labour could be faulty in overweight women
2. Fat Is Not Your Fault Review
3. How This Program Can Help People Lose Weight Naturally – Vinamy
4. New York No Fault Arbitration Lawyers Munawar & Andrews-Santillo LLP Launches New York No Fault Arbitration Website
5. Class Action Suit Claims Lenovo Sold Faulty Notebook Computers Using Misleading Marketing Tactics; Parker Waichman LLP, Whitfield Bryson & Mason LLP Represent Plaintiffs
6. New Article Finds Fault With Pediatric Organization’s Support for Circumcision, Provoking a Formal Response
7. Faulty development of immature brain cells causes hydrocephalus
8. Scientists discover how iron levels and a faulty gene cause bowel cancer
9. VisionWare and Serco Partner to Enable ‘Digital by Default’ Strategy
10. Misidentified and contaminated cell lines lead to faulty cancer science
11. Drug kills cancer cells by restoring faulty tumor suppressor
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Fault trumps gruesome evidence when it comes to punishment
(Date:4/24/2015)... On February 21st, 2015, Per Wickstrom had the ... contributor Karen Salkin at Durkin Entertainment’s EcoLuxe Lounge, sponsored ... of which Wickstrom is the founder. Making appearances at ... EcoLuxe Lounge is a gathering of some of the ... and services. Among the many roles that she has ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... Anchor Health Administrators (Anchor), specialists in Long-Term Care ... exclusive agreement with LTC Solutions for All LLC (SFA) ... , Anchor has more than 18 years of experience ... and is currently the designated advocate for the American ... member benefit. , “I am very pleased to be ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... (PRWEB) April 24, 2015 With years ... , UGA is now proud to be partnered with ... of 16,000 animals a year. This partnership has brought ... their animals. , After providing an in-house payment ... Medical Teaching Hospital (VMTH) wanted to increase financing options ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... (PRWEB) April 24, 2015 “ Opera ” ... Report, which features the latest and coolest technology products available ... of NewsWatch, conducted the review and shared with viewers how ... Without web browsers, surfing the internet would not be in ... other and the Opera browser is no different. Celebrating their ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... April 24, 2015 Qualis Health, ... organizations, has published a new resource for practicing ... The guide to Quality and Resource Use Reports ... & Medicare Services (CMS) to help practices interpret ... streamline resources, and identify care coordination opportunities to ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Karen Salkin Talks with Per Wickstrom at the 2015 EcoLuxe Lounge and the "Salute to the Oscars" Celebration 2Health News:University of Missouri Veterinary Medical Teaching Hospital Teams with UGA 2Health News:A Web Browser That Connects over 350 Million People was Featured on NewsWatch Television 2Health News:Qualis Health Publishes Guide to Help Physician Practices Assess and Improve Quality 2
... variants in the DNA of 486 people infected with HIV that ... virus and delay the onset of full-blown AIDS. ... for an HIV vaccine that would work by boosting the protective ... bodys own immune system overcome an infection. One of the genes ...
... may have ended 150 years ago but that need not ... ambience in a majestic 17th century garden . ... has made known plans to open up a part of ... for weddings. ,The magnificently laid and maintained gardens, ...
... passed snide remarks about her, claiming that the actress is too ... Ashton Kutcher tied the knot in September 2005, and the actress ... ,Lesley Guynes, who is separated from Moores half-brother commented that the ... she was old. ,I think Demi is getting too ...
... study by researchers has claimed that Chinas desire to ... monkeys in their infancy in the Mount Huangshan Scenic ... ,According to National Geographic, the skyrocketing infant mortality of ... to a restricted range and regularly competing for corn ...
... toughen anti-smoking laws, restricting smoking in public places and ... further approved a Health and Family Welfare Ministry proposal ... Act in the first week of the monsoon session ... told reporters after a Cabinet meeting in New Delhi. ...
... food cravings and keeping them in check may be ... first six-month phase of the study provides new insights ... their role in weight control. ,Cravings are ... Susan Roberts, PhD, director of the USDA HNRCAs Energy ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Experts Identify Vaccine Target for HIV 2Health News:Experts Identify Vaccine Target for HIV 3Health News:Now You can Marry in a Mughal Ambience, If You Wish to 2Health News:Chinese Eco-tourism Causing Infanticide Among Tibetan Monkeys 2Health News:Government to Toughen Its Anti-smoking Laws 2Health News:Weight Management Achieved by Controlling and Not Suppressing Food Cravings 2
(Date:4/24/2015)... , April 24, 2015 ... portfolio of automated, indication-specific planning tools for radiosurgery/SBRT ... focused software applications aimed at enhancing the workflow ... and spine introduced in 2013 - comes full ... (SRS) planning tools. These new Elements enable on-the-fly ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... , April 24, 2015 The ... (part of the National Institutes of Health [NIH])  ... nine research projects for the development of diagnostic ... recent HAI outbreaks at U.S. health facilities , ... research into rapid, multiplexed and effective tests using ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... , April 24, 2015  Lannett Company, Inc. ... amended and increased its five-year revolving credit facility to ... an accordion feature that will allow the company to ... additional $30.0 million, subject to securing additional commitments from ... of the credit facility remains December 18, 2018.   ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Brainlab Introduces New Generation of VMAT* for Brain and Spine at 3rd ESTRO in Barcelona 2Kalorama: NIAID Rewards HAI Innovators with Grants 2Kalorama: NIAID Rewards HAI Innovators with Grants 3Kalorama: NIAID Rewards HAI Innovators with Grants 4Lannett Expands Revolving Credit Facility To $120 Million 2
... 10, 2012 Elsevier, a world-leading provider ... announced it will organize an extra Tetrahedron Symposium in ... speakers in bioorganic and organic medicinal chemistry closer to ... in two locations, one in Europe and one in ...
... The Ministry of Health and Welfare and Korea Health Industry ... Health Authority-Abu Dhabi (HAAD) arrived in South Korea on Dec. ... government arranged for domestic hospitals to sign a pact on ... Chairman Mohammed Sultan Al Hameli and CEO Zaid Daoud Al ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Elsevier Announces Two Tetrahedron Symposia for 2012 2Elsevier Announces Two Tetrahedron Symposia for 2012 3First Patient from Abu Dhabi Arrives in South Korea for Medical Treatment 2
... BP 900 offers three magnifications ... routine practice, the BP 900 ... and progressive functionality. Two optional ... one for digital photography, are ...
... 400 System is an automated multiplexing platform ... SNP detection, pathogen sequence detection and pharmacogenetics ... be applied to an open and flexible ... be reused until all tests sites have ...
... for venous pressure monitoring, blood sampling, ... Turbo-Flo polyurethane PICC line sets offer:, ... Micropuncture Introducer Needle, Biocompatible ... trimmed to patient specific anatomy. Remove ...
Cable connections for 5 different adapters: Storz, ACMI, Pentax, Wolf and Olympus....
Medicine Products: