Navigation Links
Fallout From Failed AIDS Vaccine Could Dampen Research

Experts worry infection fears might keep participants from trials

MONDAY, Nov. 12 (HealthDay News) -- An experimental AIDS vaccine used in a recent trial may have placed participants at higher risk of infection with HIV -- although whether or not that was truly the case remains unclear.

What is clear is the concern among experts that the news will keep would-be trial participants away from future AIDS vaccine studies.

"That's always a possibility, and that's the reason why we have to be very transparent and open and honest, and be very energetic to educate people to understand just what went on here," said Dr. Anthony Fauci, an AIDS research pioneer and director of the U.S. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases (NIAID). The institute was a partner in the trial.

"Already we have a lot of people misinterpreting that the vaccine itself actually gave [recipients] HIV infection -- that's impossible," he said. "We have a lot of education to do, and there's always a danger that this could sour people on getting involved in vaccine trials."

Another expert agreed that the collapse of the large, phase II trial of Merck & Co.'s V520 vaccine could send the wrong message.

"It's a blow to the HIV prevention field," said Rowena Johnston, vice president of research at the Foundation for AIDS Research (amfAR) in New York City. "Clearly, we want to be very careful that people aren't thinking that AIDS researchers are going to be putting them at risk."

The V520 vaccine was the first of the so-called "viral vector" HIV vaccines to make it all the way to such a large, phase II trial, after showing much promise in smaller, earlier studies.

The vaccine used a harmless adenovirus -- a type of cold virus -- as a "vector" to deliver a set of three synthetically derived HIV genes. The hope was those genes would help prime the immune system against the virus that causes AIDS.

The virus vector approach is a common one in vaccine research generally, and HIV/AIDS experts had high hopes for the Merck vaccine, which was meant to be tested in more than 3,000 volunteers uninfected with HIV.

Unfortunately, the vaccine failed to deliver. In September, a preliminary analysis of the data showed no statistical difference between those who got the shot and those who got a placebo, in terms of new infections. The trial was halted at that time.

Reporting last Wednesday at a scientific meeting in Seattle, the research team said an updated review of the numbers had since revealed a widening gap in infections that actually favored the placebo.

So far, the researchers said, 49 of 914 men vaccinated have tested positive for HIV, compared to 33 of 922 men who got the placebo shot.

And in a puzzling twist, individuals who had higher levels of preexisting immunity to the adenovirus before vaccination were actually much more prone to developing HIV infection, compared to participants with low levels of immunity, the researchers said.

Among 778 male volunteers with a high level of preexisting adenovirus immunity, 21 of those vaccinated are now HIV-positive, versus nine in the placebo arm of the trial.

In terms of vaccine's effectiveness at slowing progression from HIV infection to AIDS, the trial was also a bust. Among participants infected with HIV, researchers have so far seen no difference in "viral load" -- HIV levels in the blood -- between those who received a shot and those who did not.

The vaccine's failure comes as a disappointment to AIDS researchers, the experts said. However, the notion that the vaccine actually heightened users' risk for infection is still far from certain, they added.

First of all, the numbers of cases of new infection recorded in the trial simply didn't reach statistical significance, Fauci said. However, the trend "is noticeable enough that you have to pay attention to it," he added.

Fauci and Johnston stressed that it's impossible for the vaccine itself to directly infect a person with HIV, because the adenovirus was the only pathogen included in the shot.

However, there is the possibility that vaccination might have spurred changes in the immune systems of individuals whose immune systems were already primed to fight the adenovirus. Theoretically, those immune-system changes could have made HIV infection more likely in these people if they were exposed to the virus.

"HIV replicates much better in [immune] cells that are activated," Fauci explained. For certain trial participants with a high preexisting immunity to the adenovirus, vaccination could have put their immune system on a kind of "high alert" -- activating exactly the type of CD4+ T-cells that HIV is attracted to, he said.

"Those CD4+ T-cells are then going to be very vulnerable targets for HIV when you become exposed to HIV," Fauci theorized.

But he also stressed that this only remains a theory. Research is continuing to see if the vaccine did, in fact, leave participants more vulnerable to contracting HIV.

"What we are trying to do now is to mine the data to see if we can find out any mechanistic or other circumstantial information that could help us decipher that out, and determine whether this is 'really real,'" Fauci said. That research could take up to a year to yield results, he noted.

In the meantime, Fauci and Johnston agreed that vaccine research using viral vectors should continue to go forward, albeit with an added note of caution.

If the trend seen in the study is confirmed, it could mean changes in the way the organizers of vaccine trials recruit participants in the future, they said.

"If it turns out to be biologically significant, then we will have to be very careful when using a viral vector to which people have underlying immunity, because that [could lead] to a significant activation of their immune responses," Fauci said.

Trial organizers would become more selective as they recruit participants, he said, "to make sure that we don't have people who have underlying immunity to the vector in question."

Both experts stressed that trial participants should always do their best to prevent exposure to HIV and not assume that an experimental vaccine gives them added protection.

"The counseling that people in trials get is really very thorough," Johnston said, "and yet I think that as trial participants, many people really do come away with the perception that they are being given a product that might protect them."

Safe behaviors -- especially condom use -- remain the surest way to prevent infection with HIV, whether you are in a trial or not, Johnston said. "To protect yourself, you really need to assume that the vaccine won't work, and then keep on protecting yourself in every way possible."

In the meantime, an estimated 39 million people remain infected with HIV worldwide, and the hope for a safe, effective vaccine delivered by a viral vector remains high, she said.

"The viral vector is really a very good idea -- it's still one of the best ideas that's out there," Johnston said. "I don't think the failure of one candidate from one company should signal the end of this as a concept."

More information

Find out more about the fight against HIV/AIDS at amfAR.

SOURCES: Anthony Fauci, M.D., director, U.S. National Institute of Allergy and Infectious Diseases, Bethesda, Md.; Rowena Johnston, Ph.D., vice president, research, Foundation for AIDS Research, New York City; Nov. 7, 2007, statement, Merck & Co.

Copyright©2007 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. DNA vaccine against multiple sclerosis appears safe, potentially beneficial
2. HPV vaccine does not appear to be effective for treating pre-existing HPV infection
3. Vaccine Stops Alzheimers Brain Tangles
4. Human Papilloma Virus vaccines may decrease chances of oral cancer
5. U.S. Teens Fall Short on Vaccine Coverage
6. Nasal Anthrax Vaccine Proves Effective in Animal Study
7. Hot ice, measuring depression, perfect invisibility and flu vaccine incentives
8. Bioniche Receives $2 Million Government Grant For Market Development Related to its E. coli O157:H7 Cattle Vaccine
9. Iomai Patch-Based Vaccine Cut Rate of Travelers Diarrhea by 75 Percent in Phase 2 Field Study
10. FDA approves expanded label for FluMist (influenza virus vaccine live, intranasal) to include childr
11. MedImmune Licenses Reverse Genetics Technology to GlaxoSmithKline for Use in Influenza Vaccine Development and Production
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Fallout From Failed AIDS Vaccine Could Dampen Research
(Date:10/10/2015)... ... October 10, 2015 , ... Well-known Eastern ... to be recognized by The National Law Journal for inclusion in their second ... firms across the United States who obtained the largest awards for their personal ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... California (PRWEB) , ... October 09, 2015 , ... ... Osteopathic Medicine of the Pacific Associate Dean for Graduate Medical Education J. Michael ... of the Year Award. Finley was selected for his impact on graduate medical ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... With the FCPX LUT Vibrance pack from ... A LUT is a Lookup Table that contains a mathematical formula for modifying an ... table. This pack comes with 60 vibrant CUBE LUT files. , Inspired ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... Smoke alarms can save lives. In fact, ... risk of dying in reported home fires in half. As part of Fire Prevention ... are property installed and maintained. , Half of home fire deaths result from fires ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... , ... Head Over Heels Athletic Arts gymnast, Madelyn Williams, will attend the ... in Huntsville, Texas on October 17-21. , "It's very exciting to be invited ... executive director, said. “It's a stepping stone into the U.S. elite system where Maddie ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
... Neuroscientists at MIT,s Picower Institute of Learning and Memory have ... inexplicably linked to long-term memories. The work is slated to ... "Our finding explains, at least partially, why seemingly irrelevant ... person is remembered as vividly as more significant information such ...
... HealthDay Reporter , THURSDAY, Jan. 13 (HealthDay News) -- This winter ... instead is turning out to be a more typical flu season, ... to get a flu shot, advice that seniors in particular should ... their age group the hardest, the experts added. The H1N1 flu ...
... for Injury Biomechanics ( ) has been awarded ... Research and Materiel Command for phase 2 of an ... military personnel. Specifically, blast induced brain trauma will be ... helmet design and body armor and the resulting reductions ...
... Liverpool-led consortium has received $1.5million from the Bill & ... serious disease and epidemics in sub-Saharan Africa. Streptococcus ... in sub-Sahara Africa. The funding will enable scientists ... associated with invasive pneumococcal disease, why it spreads so ...
... HealthDay Reporter , THURSDAY, Jan. 13 (HealthDay ... by patients and health professionals alike to save money ... and potentially dangerous, a new study suggests. Belgian ... deviated from recommended dosages by 15 percent or more. ...
... HealthDay Reporter , WEDNESDAY, Jan. 12 (HealthDay News) -- ... said Tuesday, breathing on her own and moving both arms ... "She has a 101 percent chance of surviving," Dr. ... told the Associated Press . "She will not die." ...
Cached Medicine News:
(Date:10/9/2015)... 9, 2015 --> ... announced its execution of an Intellectual Property & Subsidiary Assignment and ... Inc. a Delaware Corporation, related party, and a majority ... --> --> These agreements were executed ... whereby the Research and Development components shall now be ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... -- Henry Schein , Inc. (NASDAQ: HSIC ... and services to office-based dental, animal health and medical ... Disaster Relief Hotline is open for dentists, physicians and ... a result of the disastrous flooding in ... Henry Schein customers is 800-999-9729. The Hotline ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... 2015  Hi-Tech Pharmaceuticals ("Hi-Tech"), a leading global ... iForce Nutrition ("iForce"), one of the fastest-growing Sports Nutrition ... , today announced that they have entered into ... to acquire iForce. The transaction will enhance Hi-Tech,s ... through iForce,s strong distribution network. Jared ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
... BROOKFIELD, Wis., March 1, 2012 The Food and ... to treat female urinary incontinence. "InTone ... the millions of women who have incontinence issues," said ... LLC, and inventor of InTone.  "With InTone, we believe ...
... the Pharmacy Technician Certification Board (PTCB) ... from the pharmacy profession on recommended changes to ... of specialty pharmacy technician exams and additional requirements ... period of practical experience, criminal background checks, and ...
Cached Medicine Technology:
CPTMeister is a coding reference based on the Physicians' Current Procedural Terminology (CPT) codes developed by the American Medical Association. It is an iSilo document composed of more than 2,000...
The BluefishRx ICD-9 is a Palm OS code lookup tool which incorporates the ICD-9 code set with the full and short code descriptions. It includes a multi keyword search tool with a dictionary of over 2...
MD Coder v 6.0 is a charge capture for the Palm OS and Pocket PC operating systems. We have integrated the feedback from hospitals and physicians. MD Coder v 6.0 comes in three versions: Physician Ba...
Preferred Health Resourses Practice Management System is called Remedy. The PDA version is Remedy for the Palm. It is a data capture program for your medical billing....
Medicine Products: