Navigation Links
FDA Panel Weighs New Restrictions on Tanning Beds

Experts say devices' UV rays help spur skin cancer, but industry says it's not so clear

THURSDAY, March 25 (HealthDay News) -- Recent calls for the U.S. Food and Drug Administration to clamp down on tanning bed use will heat up again Thursday as an agency panel debates new restrictions on the devices, which some health experts say contribute to cancer.

"We are hoping the FDA will reclassify tanning beds," said Dr. Allan Halpern, vice president of the Skin Cancer Foundation.

Currently, tanning beds are classified as class I medical devices, "which means these cancer-causing machines are in the same category as tongue depressors and elastic bandages and subject to few regulations and little oversight," the foundation noted in a news release.

On Thursday, the General and Plastic Surgery Devices Panel -- part of the FDA's Medical Devices Advisory Committee -- will look over the latest data on the risks of ultraviolet (UV) ray exposure from tanning beds. According to the agency, there is a growing body of evidence that shows an association between skin cancer and the use of tanning lamps.

For its part, the Skin Cancer Foundation would like to see the classification of tanning beds changed to a class II device. For one thing, that could prevent the devices from containing mirrors, which amplify the power of UV exposure.

In addition, the foundation wants tanning beds to be manufactured and labeled in such a way that the public is better educated about their danger. They also want manufacturers to keep a registry monitoring the use of their products.

"UV light is a known cause of cancer," Halpern said. "That's recognized by the U.S. government, by the World Health Organization (WHO). And what tanning beds do is deliver UV light."

On the other side of the debate, John Overstreet, executive director of the Indoor Tanning Association, said the industry is already well-regulated.

"We think the FDA does a pretty good job of regulating the industry. They have regulated the industry for 20-plus years," Overstreet said. "There is a lot of misinformation about the industry," he added.

Overstreet said his association will be testifying at the committee meeting. "We'll address this whole myth about this relationship between melanoma skin cancer and indoor tanning, which is speculative at best," he said.

But last summer, a report from the WHO's International Agency for Research on Cancer moved tanning beds to its highest cancer risk category -- "carcinogenic to humans." Previously, the agency had classified sunlamps and tanning beds as "probably" carcinogenic, so the move put the devices a notch higher in terms of risk.

"The use of tanning beds can be deleterious to your health and we hope to encourage governments to formulate restrictions and regulations for the use of tanning beds," report coauthor Beatrice Secretan, from the Cancer Monograph Working Group at the International Agency for Research on Cancer in Lyon, France, said at the time.

Halpern noted that the use of tanning beds by young girls and women is growing -- as is their incidence of skin cancer. "There is one calculation that as many as a quarter of the melanomas in young women can be attributed directly to tanning bed use," he said.

Another expert agreed.

Dr. Jeffrey C. Salomon, an assistant clinical professor of plastic surgery at Yale University School of Medicine, said: "I never recommend tanning bed usage to my patients. To me, it would be like recommending smoking to a patient.

"UV radiation damages the DNA in the skin and while it may take years for that DNA damage to manifest itself as a skin cancer, it is still a preventable risk, similar to smoking," he added. "And like smoking, we have an obligation as a society to protect our youngest citizens from a known cancer risk by any legal means."

Some people -- including Halpern -- would like to see tanning beds banned completely. "At a minimum we would like to see them banned for people under the age of 18," he said.

But Indoor Tanning Association spokesman Overstreet begged to differ, citing studies that he said show that exposure to UV radiation may actually protect people from developing melanoma.

There are risks from exposure to UV radiation, he said, "but there are also benefits involved with being exposed to UV light. There's no doubt about that," he added.

"Without UV light you cannot live," Overstreet said. "How much you need varies from person-to-person, from skin type to skin type -- like anything else in life, pursue it with moderation."

A bill introduced in Congress on Jan. 26, the Tanning Bed Cancer Control Act, also aims to put new restrictions on tanning bed use.

"Tanning beds are the cigarettes of our time: cancer-causing and poorly regulated," Rep. Carolyn Maloney (D-NY), one of the chief sponsors of the bill, said in a statement.

Currently, the FDA and the U.S. Federal Trade Commission (FTC) each regulate tanning beds and sunlamps. The FDA regulates labeling of the devices and the FTC regulates advertising claims about the devices.

The FDA currently requires tanning salons to direct all customers to wear protective eye goggles and advises consumers to limit their exposure to tanning devices, and avoid them if you have certain medical conditions such as lupus or diabetes, or are susceptible to cold sores.

In addition, the FDA requires labels on these devices that warn of skin aging, skin cancer and eye injury. In 2007, the FDA began a review of these warnings and is considering strengthening its warnings about the risk of skin cancer and eye damage, according to the agency.

More information

There's more on skin cancer at the American Cancer Society.

SOURCES: Allan Halpern, M.D., vice president, The Skin Cancer Foundation, New York City; Jeffrey C. Salomon, M.D., assistant clinical professor, plastic surgery at Yale University School of Medicine, New Haven, Conn; John Overstreet, executive director, Indoor Tanning Association, Washington, D.C.

Copyright©2010 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Panel: FCCs Broadband Plan Will Boost Efforts to Expand Health IT
2. Panel: Properly designed pay-for-performance models can support medical professionalism
3. Panel Finds Many Women Can Avoid Repeat C-Sections
4. Panel questions VBAC bans, advocates expanded delivery options for women
5. All Global Launches Physician Panels in Russia and Poland
6. Avoiding Dairy Due to Lactose Intolerance is Unnecessary in Most Cases and May Pose Diet and Health Risks, Concludes National Institutes of Health Consensus Development Conference Panel
7. Panel asks dairy avoiders: Are you getting enough?
8. NFL Brain Injury Panel Raises Awareness of Potential Long-Term Consequences from Traumatic Brain Injuries
9. Panel calls for reducing colorectal cancer deaths by striking down barriers to screening
10. Federal Panel Urges Obesity Screening for Kids Ages 6 and Up
11. Panel Intelligence Returns to MedPanel Name
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/9/2015)... CA (PRWEB) , ... October 09, 2015 , ... Head ... Center for the elite developmental camp at the Karolyi Ranch in Huntsville, Texas on ... Katreece Stone, Head Over Heels girls team head coach and executive director, said. “It's ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... Confidence Plus Insurance ... a community improvement initiative that involves working with a series of local charities ... of Confidence Plus Insurance is the Gleason Park Electric Violin Ensemble (GPEVE). , ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... Nedlands, WA, Australia (PRWEB) , ... October 09, ... ... be featured in an upcoming episode of Innovations with Ed Begley Jr., airing ... In this segment, Innovations will educate audiences on MMJ Phytotech Limited (MMJ) – ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... Deadly, record-smashing rainfall has ... Foundation (CCCF) in Columbia, South Carolina. In response, the Foundation has established a ... – both short and long term. 100% of monies donated will go directly ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... , ... October 09, 2015 , ... ... medical staffing franchise, was recognized by Cabarrus County Active Living and Parks for ... home care company’s dedication to consistently going above and beyond the ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
... , , WASHINGTON, July ... for a health reform bill that requires no cost-sharing by ... The preventive services proposal was among eight "core consumer protections" ... He listed the eight protections during a Thursday town hall ...
... percent, chances of serious complications 4.3 percent, , WEDNESDAY, ... surgery to combat significant obesity, a new study suggests ... what has previously been reported. , The study, which ... gastric banding (lap-band surgery), found that the risk of ...
... , ROCKVILLE, Md., ... expect to feel better when taking an antidepressant, which rheumatoid arthritis drugs work ... now can get this and other treatment information through new Spanish-language consumer guides ... AHRQ also released consumer ...
... , ARLINGTON, Va., July 29 ... home medical equipment and services (durable medical equipment) and about ... Association for Homecare has developed a "Myth vs. Reality" list ... The American Association for Homecare urges members of the ...
... study finds no better nutrient value than in conventionally produced ... that beckons from the organic aisles of grocery stores may ... rest of supermarket shelves. , According to a British review ... conventionally produced foods have about the same nutrient content, suggesting ...
... , CHICAGO, July 29 Through its ... and Casualty Company has increased its support to the Alzheimer,s Association ... Bankers, annual Forget Me Not Days(R) event increased its donations ... Alzheimer,s Association. In addition, Bankers - the national life and ...
Cached Medicine News:
(Date:10/9/2015)... , Oct. 9, 2015 Henry Schein ... provider of health care products and services to office-based ... customers that the Henry Schein Disaster Relief Hotline is ... logistical or financial issues as a result of the ... The toll-free number for all Henry Schein ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... Calif. , Oct. 9, 2015  Impax Laboratories, ... Company will release its third quarter 2015 financial results ... of the U.S. financial markets. The Company will host ... community at 8:30 a.m., Eastern Time on November 9, ... . --> The financial results and ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... 2015 Eli Lilly and Company (NYSE: LLY ... approximately 50 new jobs to its research and development presence ... York, New York . --> ... will include a translational immuno-oncology hub and a Lilly "portal," ... access to cutting-edge drug discovery capabilities, including chemistry and lead ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
...   Ocular Therapeutix, Inc. announced today that it ... Drug Administration to conduct a pivotal clinical trial with ... use over clear corneal incisions. The ... efficacy of the device, relative to sutured closure, for ...
... South Korea, Feb. 6, 2012 /PRNewswire-Asia/ -- As the whole ... in Korea has shown a great improvement. Cancer is still ... half of Korean cancer patients have, in recent times, managed ... world class cancer treatments are available in Korea. ...
Cached Medicine Technology:
Force 1C has a streamlined, compact design perfect for the requirements of outpatient surgery - as well as the power and performance features needed for a full range of general inpatient surgical pro...
... Isolated ESU on the market with 10,000V PTP ... that allows the surgeon to adjust power settings ... pencil. Excalibur Plus PC Patented Controlled Output Voltage ... cutting through various impedance tissues with minimal thermal ...
Diamond phaco knife keratome shaped blade straight. 3.2 mm wide....
Sabre 180, 230V, 50Hz is a powerful niche generator....
Medicine Products: