Navigation Links
Extreme negative anti-smoking ads can backfire, MU experts find
Date:8/22/2011

COLUMBIA, Mo. Health communicators have long searched for the most effective ways to convince smokers to quit. Now, University of Missouri researchers have found that using a combination of disturbing images and threatening messages to prevent smoking is not effective and could potentially cause an unexpected reaction.

In a study recently published in the Journal of Media Psychology, Glenn Leshner, Paul Bolls and Kevin Wise, co-directors of the Psychological Research on Information and Media Effects (PRIME) Lab at the University of Missouri School of Journalism, found that showing viewers a combination of threatening and disgusting television public service announcements (PSAs) caused viewers to experience the beginnings of strong defensive reactions. The researchers found that when viewers saw the PSAs with both threatening and disgusting material, they tended to withdraw mental resources from processing the messages while simultaneously reducing the intensity of their emotional responses. Leshner says that these types of images could possibly have a "boomerang effect," meaning the defensive reactions could be so strong that they cause viewers to stop processing the messages in the PSAs.

In their study, the researchers showed 49 participants anti-smoking television PSAs. Some PSAs included disgusting images and some did not. Further, some PSAs included an explicit health threat while others did not. The researchers monitored the participants' emotional responses and how much attention they paid to both types of images through self-report questions as well as through sensors that measured heart rate and physiological negative emotional response from muscle activity above the eye socket on the brow.

The researchers found the PSAs which included either a threatening message or a disgusting image resulted in greater attention, better memory, and a heightened emotional response. However, PSAs that included both threatening and disgusting images caused participants to have defensive responses, where defensive reactions were so strong that the participants unconsciously limited the mental resources they allocated to processing the messages. They also had worse memories and a lower emotional responses when the threatening PSAs included disgusting images. Leshner says that when a disgusting image is included in a threatening PSA, the ad becomes too noxious for the viewer.

"We noticed in our collection of anti-tobacco public service announcements a number of ads that contained very disturbing images, such as cholesterol being squeezed from a human artery, a diseased lung, or a cancer-riddled tongue," Leshner said. "Presumably, these messages are designed to scare people so that they don't smoke. It appears that this strategy may backfire."

Bolls says that the recent MU study shows that new FDA regulations requiring cigarette companies to include potentially threatening and disgusting images on cigarette packages may be ineffective at communicating the desired message that smoking is unhealthy.

"Simply trying to encourage smokers to quit by exposing them to combined threatening and disgusting visual images is not an effective way to change attitudes and behaviors," Bolls said. "Effective communication is more complicated than simply showing a disgusting picture. That kind of communication will usually result in a defensive avoidance response where the smoker will try to avoid the disgusting images, not the cigarettes.

Bolls goes on to say that one of the major limitations of the new regulation is that the FDA is relying on smokers to take the disgusting images and make the cognitive leap that those images portray what they are doing to their bodies and that they should quit smoking to prevent those conditions.

"You can't get that kind of message out explicitly just by putting a gross picture on a package of cigarettes; yet, that is the kind messaging that needs to take place to have a chance at changing smokers' habits," Bolls said. "You have to talk to smokers in a meaningful and encouraging way that outlines the consequences of smoking, but also have messages designed to minimize the defensive avoidance responses."


'/>"/>

Contact: Nathan Hurst
hurstn@missouri.edu
573-882-6217
University of Missouri-Columbia
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Extreme Heat Calls for Smarter Workouts
2. Extreme Dieting Often Lasts From Early Teens to Adulthood
3. Extreme exertion does not impair the quality of CPR given by lifeguards
4. Could Extreme Low-Cal Diets Bring Longer, Healthier Life?
5. Extremely obese children have higher prevalence of psoriasis, higher heart disease risk
6. MRI locates prostate cancer recurrence at extremely low PSA levels
7. Difference in ICU care between the US and UK reflect extremes of bed availability
8. Extreme obesity associated with higher risk of death for 2009 H1N1 patients
9. Self-Embedding Takes Teen Self-Injury to the Extreme
10. Extremely obese children have 40 percent higher risk of reflux disease of esophagus
11. Columbia Extreme Job Makeover Slated for June 26
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/29/2017)... ... 29, 2017 , ... Thomas Dickerson, Ed. D, FACHE, chief ... of the Board of Directors for the Radiology Business Management Association , ... Board President Jim Hamilton, MHA, CMM, FRBMA, an administrator and business manager for ...
(Date:5/28/2017)... ... , ... HYPERAMS, LLC announced it will perform the inventory liquidation ... Ohio. The sale began this week and the inventory is expected to sell quickly. ... and medical accessories, including blood pressure cuffs, stethoscopes, CPR masks, as well as blank ...
(Date:5/27/2017)... , ... May 26, 2017 , ... A May 8 ... visit a doctor for colds or respiratory issues that are not responsive to antibiotics ... pressure on doctors may be largely responsible for the problem both in Canada and ...
(Date:5/27/2017)... ... ... Most us are familiar with the sound of occasional popping joints that ... shows that certain people who experience consistent joint popping, grating and grinding are ... opportunity to treat patients before the problem becomes pronounced, potentially hedging off more severe ...
(Date:5/26/2017)... VA (PRWEB) , ... May 26, 2017 , ... ... pleased to announce a new educational seminar to focus on current legislative activity ... News(LEARN) seminar will begin at 1 p.m. Sunday, Sept. 10, and will continue ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/6/2017)... -- May is Stroke Awareness Month and Omron Healthcare is ... to prevent a stroke: monitor and manage your blood ... Prevention, undetected and uncontrolled hypertension is a leading risk ... in personal heart health technology, recently evolved its mission ... stroke and is advancing a national public education effort ...
(Date:5/4/2017)... and SAN DIEGO , May 4, ... (ACOG) 2017 Annual Clinical and Scientific Meeting— OBP Medical ... medical devices, today announced the launch of a new ... OfficeSPEC and ER-SPEC vaginal specula. Already ... extra-small and extra-large sizes makes OBP Medical,s line of ...
(Date:5/3/2017)...  Kalorama Information notes that transplant diagnostics is ... and this is projected to continue to 2021. ... or bone marrow transplants require histocompatibility between the ... this task. This according to a new report ... various PCR-based methodologies, Sanger sequencing and NGS used ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: