Navigation Links
Experts question merits of extending competition to improve hospital care
Date:10/10/2011

More research is needed before conclusions can be drawn about the effect of recent reforms on hospital quality, let alone about the merits of the coalition government's proposals to extend competition, warn experts on bmj.com today.

Professor Gwyn Bevan and Matthew Skellern at the London School of Economics and Political Science argue that the jury is still out on the effects of hospital competition on quality of care within the English NHS.

Their views come as the Health and Social Care Bill has its second reading in the House of Lords on Tuesday 11 October.

The health secretary, Andrew Lansley, has proposed changes to the English NHS that will extend the hospital market introduced by "New Labour" in the 2000s. This was the second era of hospital competition within the NHS; the first, the "internal market," applied throughout the UK from 1991 to 1997.

Bevan and Skellern review evidence from three recent econometric studies of the New Labour market, which all show a seemingly causal relation between greater competition and lower hospital mortality. These studies have proved highly controversial because they contradict previous findings that competition in the NHS was largely ineffective, or even had negative consequences.

The authors argue that the three recent econometric studies are "serious and rigorous responses to the challenge of estimating the effects of competition on hospital outcomes." However, they question their use of hospital mortality rates (HMRs) to judge the impact of competition on the quality of elective surgery because deaths following elective surgery are so rare that another measure is needed to assess its quality.

Two econometric studies examining the effects of introducing patient choice in elective surgery assume that this competition will improve elective surgery, which will require improving hospital management in ways that lead to across the board improvements in hospital quality. The authors argue that: "It is equally plausible, however, that such competition for elective surgery might, through diversion of management effort, negatively affect the quality of other hospital services." Hence the authors believe that "a key finding of these two studies is that introducing patient choice for elective surgery in the New Labour market did not reduce quality elsewhere in hospitals."

"We believe there are strong grounds for introducing patient choice into the NHS as an end in itself, given its potential to empower patients and give them greater control over the conditions of their care," say the authors. Nevertheless, they add, how patient choice has affected outcomes in elective surgery "remains an open question."

They conclude: "More research is required before conclusions can be drawn about the effect of recent reforms on hospital quality, let alone about the merits of the Mr Lansley's proposals further to extend competition."


'/>"/>

Contact: Emma Dickinson
edickinson@bmjgroup.com
44-020-738-36529
BMJ-British Medical Journal
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Panels Rejection of PSA Test Spurs Mixed Reaction From Experts
2. Experts Assess What Works for Weight Loss
3. Experts Point Out Signs of Dangerous Heart Rhythm
4. Check Plastic Surgeons Credentials or Risk Tragic Results, Experts Warn
5. Experts Revise Guidelines for Whooping Cough Vaccination
6. Bone experts to present strategies for osteoporosis prevention and care in Dubai
7. Experts offer solutions at ACR Imaging Informatics Summit & Radiation Dose Monitoring Forum
8. Less Play Time = More Troubled Kids, Experts Say
9. Movement Disorders on YouTube Not What They Seem, Experts Warn
10. Health Experts Say HPV Vaccine Is Safe
11. Trauma experts criticize BBCs Holby City for peddling dangerous drugs
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:9/20/2017)... ... 20, 2017 , ... Announced that Clear Global ... services market) has entered into an agreement on September 1, 2017 with The ... is the first private Dental School to launch an online, accredited Post Graduate ...
(Date:9/20/2017)... ... September 20, 2017 , ... ... gather for the National Athletic Trainers’ Association Annual Clinical Symposium and Expo. New ... It is also when Athletic Trainers are acknowledged by their peers with accolades ...
(Date:9/20/2017)... ... 2017 , ... Five consumer packaged goods (CPG) products were selected by the ... Nopavera Plus was named to the short list in the Specialty Supplements ... during presentations at SupplySide Central on Sept. 27 and 28 at Mandalay Bay Resort ...
(Date:9/20/2017)... Eugene, OR (PRWEB) , ... September 20, 2017 , ... ... OSHA 10- and 30-Hour and HAZWOPER 8-, 24- and 40-Hour courses from now until ... , In addition to offering these discounted prices to all businesses and government ...
(Date:9/20/2017)... ... ... “RECYCLED Ezekiel's Plan for Freedom from ADDICTION”: A Bible-inspired ... the creation of published author, Bill Miller. Bill Miller has a unique ... than a decade of addiction to prescription drugs. He has a Bachelor ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:9/6/2017)... N.Y. , Sept. 6, 2017   PDI , ... announced it will host an educational session focused on ... bloodstream infection (CLABSI) prevention at the 2017 Annual Scientific ... which will take place at the Phoenix ... from Sept. 16-19, will also feature PDI,s ...
(Date:9/5/2017)... N.J. , Sept. 5, 2017  Getinge, ... has created a vibrant charitable donation program -- ... and support congenital heart defect research by The ... providers and the general public are encouraged to ... and submit the completed artwork to the gallery ...
(Date:9/1/2017)... 1, 2017  Bayer will present the latest research from ... Medical Oncology (ESMO) 2017 Congress, September 8-12 in ... preclinical and clinical data on Bayer,s marketed portfolio and late-stage ... "We value the ... cancer research at ESMO," said Carsten Brunn , Head ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: