Navigation Links
Europe seeks consensus over 'living wills'
Date:10/31/2008

The question whether a common European position on advance directives, or "living wills" is ethically required and practically feasible was discussed at a recent workshop organised by the European Science Foundation (ESF). Just as a conventional will allows people to specify how they would like their property to be distributed after their death, so a living will is supposed to determine what medical treatment people would like to receive in the event of illness when they are still alive but of unfit mind to decide at the time. This is an extension of the basic human right across all of Europe that people can consent to or refuse medical treatment at any time.

Not all European countries yet have national legislation covering advance directives, with some such as Germany and Switzerland currently conducting heated debates over the subject. Even in countries that do have such legislation, advance directives are open to very different interpretations and their application differs widely across Europe. This is the case not just for the highly topical matters of euthanasia and assisted suicide, but also for administration of emergency treatments such as artificial ventilation and intravenous hydration (drips). The ESF workshop reflected this divergence, with disagreement even over the degree of consensus that could be achieved, according to the workshop's convenor Susanne Brauer and co-convenors Roberto Andorno and Nikola Biller-Andorno, from the Institute of Biomedical Ethics at University of Zurich in Switzerland.

According to Brauer, one group at the workshop felt there was a need for a more substantial pan-European agreement on the ethical, legal and political basis of advance directives. This group was concerned that the current consensus was too vague and open to widely varying interpretation. This consensus is based on article nine of the Convention on Human Rights and Biomedicine, established in Oviedo, Spain in 1997, stating that "the previously expressed wishes relating to a medical intervention by a patient who is not, at the time of the intervention, in a state to express his or her wishes shall be taken into account." "This group argued that the convention needs greater clarity on the significance and respect for autonomy, as well as clarification on the approach to decision-making for patients without a surrogate (person such as a relative empowered to make decisions on the patients' behalf)," said Brauer.

Others at the conference however argued that the complexity and diversity of approaches to advance directives across Europe limited the degree of consensus that could be achieved. "Such diversity has been echoed, for instance, in different standards for the provision of artificial nutrition and hydration, which leads also to practical challenges that are faced in implementation," said Brauer.

On the other hand these differences themselves mean there needs to be some mechanism for resolving conflicts that occur between patients' wishes and local practices in the event of people falling ill when travelling abroad for example. "It is important to reach a clear understanding of the implications of the different normative frameworks and/or policy choices for health care practices, including potential conflicts in standards between patients' countries of origin and the countries in which they are seeking health care," said Brauer.

The best known legal differences relating to advance directives relate naturally to euthanasia and assisted suicide. While euthanasia involves administration of a lethal dose by a doctor, in assisted suicide the patient does it and has to be therefore of sound mind to make the decision. The controversy concerns the right of patients to specify in an advance directive that they be killed at some future time when they are no longer able to make the decision and have reached a point where under some definition they no longer have any quality of life. Irrespective of an advance directive, most European countries forbid carrying out any instructions for euthanasia. However, those European countries with a law governing them honour advance directives specifying passive withdrawal of life support mechanisms or medicines. Europe does though have the only two countries in the world, the Netherlands and Belgium, where laws specifically permit euthanasia. Furthermore in February 2008, Luxembourg passed a law, yet to come into force, to permit euthanasia and assisted suicide, and while both euthanasia and assisted suicide are illegal in Switzerland, the latter is penalized only if it is carried out "from selfish motives".

Clearly the existence of such discrepancies among European countries and the existence of "suicide tourism", makes consensus hard to reach. However it makes it all the more important to establish common ground and understanding, which the ESF workshop helped to achieve. In particular the workshop grappled with many of the highly challenging legal, ethical and clinical issues relating to advance directives, such as how they can be implemented by physicians in the many situations where outcomes of treatment and even diagnoses are uncertain.


'/>"/>

Contact: Susanne Brauer
brauer@ethik.uzh.ch
41-446-348-380
European Science Foundation
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Dr. Henry Barnett becomes first person outside Europe to receive Karolinska Stroke Award
2. CPC Appoints Medical Product Service GmbH as Authorized European Representative for MedClose(TM) System
3. Stallergenes Partners With Catalent and the Medical House for Commercialization of Adrenaline Autoinjector in Europe
4. UCLH to Discuss Using Business Process Management to Meet Government Referral-To-Treatment Mandate at IRM BPM Europe 2008
5. ATS Medical Products Featured Prominently in Scientific Presentations at European Association for Cardio-Thoracic Surgeons (EACTS) Annual Meeting
6. Essilor Steps Up its Development in Eastern Europe
7. Hoana Medical Acquires CE Mark to Expand Patient Safety Technology to European Market
8. Frost & Sullivan Honours Redsense Medical With the 2008 European Hemodialysis Emerging Company of the Year Award
9. Sigma Breakthrough Technologies, Inc. (SBTI) Is Expanding Its Service Offering for Global Clients by Announcing the Public Listing of SBTI Europe GmbH
10. Cymbalta Receives European Approval for the Treatment of Generalised Anxiety Disorder
11. China Healthcare Acquisition Corp Signs Definitive Agreement to Acquire Europe Asia Huadu Environment Holding Pte, Ltd.
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/23/2017)... ... August 23, 2017 , ... Arizona ... hospitals nationally that earned the designation of High Performing Hospitals by U.S. News ... performing indicates a hospital was significantly better than the national average in a ...
(Date:8/23/2017)... ... August 23, 2017 , ... ... Golden Bridge Awards® - for Risk Management Solution Innovations and Security Solution for ... online platform released in 2017 and its DHS SAFETY Act-designated enterprise security assessment ...
(Date:8/22/2017)... ... August 22, 2017 , ... The ... health is as simple as eating healthy foods. But this well-known piece of ... making insulin, or breaking apart carbohydrates—depends not only on properties of the food ...
(Date:8/22/2017)... ... August 22, 2017 , ... Nurses at Apple Rehab Watch ... Cove, recently received training and certification in Closed Pulse Irrigation™ (CPI) for ... five-star rating from the Centers for Medicare and Medicaid Services, to have a CPI ...
(Date:8/22/2017)... ... August 22, 2017 , ... “Covert ... the creation of published author, Julianne Hale, a consultant for the Intelligence Community. ... counter-terrorism expert focusing on the Near East region. Julianne has written hundreds ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:8/7/2017)... Aug. 7, 2017 Insightin Health, provider ... retention, and engagement, announced the selection of ... Product Development, effective as of February 2017. In this ... implementation strategy for our clients. Wood brings with ... consulting and business analytics within the healthcare industry. ...
(Date:8/7/2017)... DUBLIN , Aug. 7, 2017  Endo International ... has reached agreements to resolve virtually all known U.S. ... in discussions to resolve the known remaining U.S. claims ... installment payments beginning in the fourth quarter of 2017 ... part of its second quarter 2017 results, the Company ...
(Date:8/2/2017)... , Aug. 2, 2017 Fenita ... Who as a Pinnacle Lifetime Professional in the ... Account Manager at Turing Pharmaceuticals, AG. Her skills ... and relationship building.                ... than 25 years of experience as a highly ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: