Navigation Links
End-of-Life Advice Not Always Welcome
Date:8/25/2009

Many relatives want doctors to keep their opinions to themselves, study finds

TUESDAY, Aug. 25 (HealthDay News) -- When deciding whether to turn off life support for a loved one, family members aren't always interested in their doctor's advice, new research shows.

The finding runs counter to assumptions among critical-care providers that families making such a heart-wrenching choice would welcome a physician's impartial opinion.

Critically ill patients who don't have advance directives often require others to make medical decisions for them, said study author Douglas B. White, of the University of Pittsburgh Medical Center.

Family members often make the decision based on what they believe the patient would have wanted.

"This puts an enormous emotional burden on surrogates; not only are they losing a loved one, they also may feel burdened by guilt about allowing the patient to die," White said. "It was therefore assumed by some in the medical community that a doctor's dispassionate advice could reduce some of that burden and help surrogates make a good decision with less second-guessing themselves."

Researchers showed videos to 169 surrogates recruited from intensive care units at University of California San Francisco Medical Center. The videos depicted a dramatized "family conference" in which surrogates must decide whether to withdraw life support from a loved one who has a small chance of survival with continued treatment, but a high likelihood of being functionally impaired and needing a ventilator.

In one video, the doctor tells the surrogate to make the choice that's consistent with the patient's values, and that only the surrogate knows what that is. In the second video, the doctor tells the surrogate that the patient probably wouldn't want continued attempts to keep him or her alive.

About 56 percent of surrogates said they preferred the video in which the physician offered an opinion to limit life support, while 42 percent preferred the video in which no recommendation was offered. Two percent had no preference.

The study appears in the August 15 issue of the American Journal of Respiratory and Critical Care Medicine.

Dr. J. Randall Curtis, president of the American Thoracic Society, said the paper challenges current assumptions about dealing with families in end-of-life situations.

"This is an important article that has changed my clinical practice," said Curtis, a professor of medicine and section head of pulmonary and critical care medicine at Harborview Medical Center in Seattle. "I had previously assumed that almost all families would want physicians' recommendations, but these findings indicate that there is no such consensus among surrogates. I suspect that physicians can do more harm by withholding a recommendation that is desired than by providing a recommendation that is not desired, but this study suggests we should ask rather than assume."

About 51 percent of the surrogates who wanted their doctor's advice believed that it was the doctor's job to provide that opinion. Nearly 79 percent who preferred not to receive the advice saw it as overstepping.

"A very important part of American bioethics is respecting patients' choices," White said. "The family's most important job when acting as a surrogate decision maker is to give voice to the patient's values. I think our research highlights that the physician's job is to be flexible enough and insightful enough to respond to the surrogate's individual needs for guidance."

More information

The Family Caregiver Alliance has more on making end-of-life decisions.



-- Jennifer Thomas



SOURCE: American Thoracic Society, news release, August 2009


'/>"/>
Copyright©2009 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. Breaking Down Barriers to End-of-Life Care for Children
2. New UIC center to study end-of-life transition
3. Doctors Review End-of-Life Care Guidelines
4. Interview by Internet Can Decrease Greatest End-of-Life Fears: It Facilitates Creating Effective Advance Directives, Living Wills
5. National Healthcare Decisions Survey: Its Easier to Talk About Drugs and Sex Than End-of-Life Planning
6. Study shows false memories complicate end-of-life treatment decisions
7. Circle of Life Awards Recognize Innovative End-of-Life Care Providers
8. Patients Benefit From End-of-Life Discussions With a Doctor
9. Seniors Tend to Stick With End-of-Life Care Preferences
10. Doctors questions about end-of-life legalities may result in patient pain
11. Unique Planning Guide Helps Professionals and Families Through Healthcare and End-of-Life Decision Making
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
End-of-Life Advice Not Always Welcome
(Date:5/26/2017)... ... ... “When the Stars Lead Home”: a poignant story of loss, determination, and perseverance. ... an avid reader who lives in the Pacific Northwest with her husband, daughter, two ... Camp. She couldn’t be more grateful. , Twelve-year old Tizzy could not believe how ...
(Date:5/26/2017)... ... May 26, 2017 , ... Water damage to the flooring ... School District had left education officials with a number of critical issues to address ... flooring had to be accomplished with little or no disruption to class schedules. Second, ...
(Date:5/24/2017)... , ... May 24, 2017 , ... ... medical image management and interpretation, has received U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA) ... is a web-based, scalable and secure cloud platform for medical image management. At ...
(Date:5/24/2017)... , ... May 24, 2017 , ... Myers Jackson is ... has the ability to sell luxury homes anywhere on the planet. The luxury home ... side from Hattiesburg to Houston city-scapes. A quick search of “11 Spyglass Hill Auction ...
(Date:5/24/2017)... (PRWEB) , ... May 24, 2017 , ... If you are thinking of a visit ... interested in business architecture, October is the perfect time to visit. , Business Architecture Associates ... à la carte offering for individuals, as a 4-½ day package for individuals, and as ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/23/2017)... Calif. , May 23, 2017  Leaf ... most innovative medical devices for pressure ulcer prevention, ... the American Association of Critical Care Nurses, National ... May 22-25. The Leaf Patient Monitoring ... specifically for the hospital environment.  The system seamlessly ...
(Date:5/18/2017)... , May 17, 2017  Bayer announced today that ... will be presented at the 53 rd Annual ... taking place June 2-6 in Chicago ... ASCO span prostate, colorectal, liver and thyroid cancers, as ... the Phase II CHRONOS-1 trial of copanlisib in patients ...
(Date:5/11/2017)...  Thornhill Research Inc. ( Toronto, Ontario, ... USD five-year, firm-fixed-priced, indefinite-quantity/indefinite-delivery contract by the U.S. ... (CCC) ( Ottawa, Ontario, Canada ) ... anesthesia to patients requiring emergency medical procedures in ... Corps have been a longtime partner with Thornhill ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: