Navigation Links
Economist Finds Highmark/IBC Merger Would Result in 70 Percent Share in Pennsylvania, Far Higher Than Initial Reports
Date:7/8/2008

HARRISBURG, Pa., July 8 /PRNewswire/ -- An economist examining the proposed merger of Highmark, Inc. and Independence Blue Cross testified today that the combined companies would have a market share far greater than has been represented so far. According to testimony presented to the Pennsylvania Insurance Department today in Pittsburgh by a prominent economist, Dr. Monica Noether of CRA International, the proposed merger would result in a combined entity with more than 70 percent of the statewide health insurance market, even more than the substantial 53 percent share frequently cited in press reports and elsewhere.

The 53 percent share figure incorrectly includes a variety of insurance products that consumers do not view as substitutes for commercial medical insurance, such as Vision, Medicare, and Dental, and fails to include Highmark and IBC's sizable self-insured health business, which consumers do regard as substitutes, according to Dr. Noether, whose study was commissioned by Capital BlueCross. Focusing on both fully-insured and self-insured commercial health business in Pennsylvania, the merger would result in a combined entity with more than 70 percent of the statewide market. In other words, seven out of every 10 commercially insured Pennsylvanians would be covered by the merged company.

"When competitive entry is difficult, as appears to be the case in Pennsylvania, a single company with more than 70 percent of the market is likely to have the ability to exert market power, which means they possess the ability to profitably raise price or reduce quality, innovation or choice in ways that can harm consumers," Dr. Noether testified.

Additionally, Dr. Noether disagreed with the assertion by Highmark and IBC that their merger would not impact competition because they do not compete today. She noted that Highmark and IBC do not compete because they have chosen not to do so through a 10-year non-compete agreement that expired on the eve of their announced plan to combine -- and further that Highmark likely would compete with IBC, and thus enhance competition in Pennsylvania's health insurance marketplace, if the merger did not proceed.

"This proposed merger would mean a fundamental, long-term change in Pennsylvania's health care landscape, one that requires careful examination of its long-term impacts on consumers, providers and competition," said Anita M. Smith, president & CEO of Capital BlueCross. "That is why Capital BlueCross has commissioned CRA International to fully examine this important issue. As a noted economist who specializes in health care, Dr. Noether's findings will enhance this essential public dialogue and help public policymakers to determine appropriate conditions to assure a fair and level playing field in any post-merger environment."

A full copy of Dr. Noether's written testimony, along with all other publicly available documents from the consolidation proceedings, can be obtained from the Department's Web site at the following link -- http://www.ins.state.pa.us/ins/cwp/view.asp?a=1347&Q=547942&PM=1.

Capital BlueCross is an independent licensee of the Blue Cross and Blue Shield Association


'/>"/>
SOURCE Capital BlueCross
Copyright©2008 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Former Senate Majority Leader, Princeton Economist Joust on Future of Health Care
2. Consumer Group Finds Use of Outdated Data and Other Major Flaws in Economists Defense of Mandatory Purchase of Private Health Insurance
3. Doctors, economist, write prescription for protecting people from themselves
4. Research!America Honors Univ. of Chicago Economists for Study Showing Economic Impact of HIV/AIDS Drug Development
5. Kaiser Permanente Study Finds Keeping a Food Diary Doubles Diet Weight Loss
6. Kaiser Permanente study finds keeping a food diary doubles diet weight loss
7. New study finds coronary arterial calcium scans help detect overall death risk in the elderly
8. American Lung Association Report Finds Lung Disease Death Rates Increasing While Cancer, Heart Disease and Stroke Death Rates Are Decreasing
9. Improving university recruitment process may increase female surgical faculty, study finds
10. Study finds Childrens Hospital patient safety program improves caregiver/family communications
11. AMA Finds High Fructose Syrup Unlikely to Be More Harmful to Health Than Other Caloric Sweeteners
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:12/7/2016)... ... December 07, 2016 , ... ... that its fully redesigned website, which launched October 17, 2016, features comprehensive information ... design and easy-to-navigate layout. Visitors and patients can discover the latest clinical dermatology ...
(Date:12/7/2016)... , ... December 07, 2016 , ... The medical profession ... and winter seasons. One major study analyzing heart attacks among 138,602 people recorded ... of a given year. We would all agree of course–no time of year is ...
(Date:12/7/2016)... ... ... “The Road To Restoration”: an informative and enlightening book for those who believe ... hands. “The Road To Restoration” is the creation of published author, Thomas Fitzhugh Sheets, ... that you could reach out for, and grab, on the old carousels. If ...
(Date:12/7/2016)... , ... December 07, 2016 , ... ... fifth annual Business Architecture Innovation Summit in Reston, VA on March 21-22, 2017. ... will share a range of experiences from a cross-section of industries such as ...
(Date:12/6/2016)... (PRWEB) , ... December 06, 2016 , ... ... have agreed to collaborate in developing a vaccine against the Middle East Respiratory ... vaccine can be available in South Korea for emergency deployment in the event ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:12/6/2016)... 6, 2016  Nearly 30 million people in ... epidemic of diabetes. 1 However, nearly 40% of ... levels (hyperglycemia) and significant glucose variability. 2 These patients ... cardiovascular events. If left untreated, hyperglycemia can lead to ... or blindness. 3 As part of ...
(Date:12/6/2016)... Miss. , Dec. 6, 2016 Two ... rescue personnel in a simulated mass casualty event Tuesday ... . The technology debuted before an audience including ... and representatives from Homeland Security, Federal Law Enforcement ... Drone Project, known as HiRO (Health Integrated Rescue Operations), ...
(Date:12/6/2016)... JUPITER, Fla. , Dec. 6, 2016 With opioids ... a newcomer in the prescription drug market that has led to ... is approximately seven to eight times stronger than heroin or morphine, ... ... Suzanne Smolkin , vice president, clinical operations, Behavioral Health for ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: