Navigation Links
Eating disorder cutoffs miss some of sickest patients, Stanford/Packard study finds
Date:4/11/2010

STANFORD, Calif. Diagnostic cutoffs for anorexia nervosa and bulimia nervosa may be too strict, a study from the Stanford University School of Medicine and Lucile Packard Children's Hospital has found. Many patients who do not meet full criteria for these diseases are nevertheless quite ill, and the diagnosis they now receive, "Eating Disorder Not Otherwise Specified," may delay their ability to get treatment.

"There's mounting evidence that we should reconsider the EDNOS categorization for young people," said Rebecka Peebles, MD, the study's primary author.

The EDNOS diagnosis has become a "mosh pit," lumping dissimilar patients into a single category that gets poor recognition from clinicians and health insurers, she said. "It is a bit misleading to patients it can make them feel like they don't have a real eating disorder," said Peebles, an instructor in pediatrics at Stanford and an adolescent medicine specialist with the Comprehensive Eating Disorders Program at Packard Children's Hospital.

Anorexia and bulimia affect about 1 percent and between 2 and 5 percent of teen girls, respectively, and both diseases are more common among females than males. Their diagnostic criteria were developed by expert consensus, without the benefit of studies to track patients' health. An anorexia diagnosis is now based on being at less than 85 percent of the expected body weight, loss of menstrual periods for at least three months and fear of weight gain despite being dangerously thin. Bulimia patients repeatedly binge on large quantities of food, then "purge" calories by vomiting, abusing laxatives or diuretics, or overexercising. Both diseases can cause serious long-term health problems, and severe cases may lead to death.

Peebles' team conducted the first-ever large study to ask whether adolescents with EDNOS are less ill than those who meet the full diagnostic criteria for anorexia or bulimia. The research, which will be published online April 12 in Pediatrics, examined records from all 1,310 female patients treated for eating disorders at Packard Children's between January 1997 and April 2008. They verified patients' diagnoses of anorexia, bulimia or EDNOS, and created categories of "partial anorexia nervosa" and "partial bulimia nervosa" to analyze patients who barely missed cutoffs for these diseases.

"Our purpose was to ask if the diagnostic criteria now in use are really separating out the sickest of the sick," Peebles said. Patients' conditions were assessed by noting signs of malnutrition such as low heart rate, low blood pressure, low body temperature, low blood levels of potassium and phosphorus and long QT interval (an electrocardiogram measurement linked to risk of sudden cardiac death).

Nearly two-thirds of the patients studied had EDNOS. As the researchers suspected, the EDNOS category acted as a catchall; patients with partial anorexia were more similar to those with full-blown anorexia than to other EDNOS patients with partial bulimia, for instance. In addition, 60 percent of EDNOS patients met medical criteria for hospitalization and this group was, on average, sicker than patients diagnosed with full-blown bulimia.

The sickest EDNOS patients were those who had dropped more than 25 percent of their body weight before diagnosis. These patients had been overweight and had lost weight too quickly and dangerously in order to end up at what is typically considered a normal weight.

"People were initially just patting them on the back for their weight loss," Peebles said. "It often took months or years for others to realize that what they were doing didn't seem healthy." Despite their normal body weights, this group was in some ways worse off than underweight patients diagnosed with anorexia, she added. "They manifested criteria of severe malnutrition."

In sum, Peebles said, the study suggests that medical criteria for eating disorders should be re-evaluated. Though the current diagnostics cover the right general areas, "we erroneously treat these criteria in a very black-and-white way," she said. "Many practitioners interpret these to believe that menses has to be lost to get an anorexia diagnosis; bulimics have to binge and purge at least two times a week for three months. These findings illustrate the arbitrary nature of those cutoffs."

The issue is particularly urgent because many health insurers offer less coverage for EDNOS treatment than for treatment of anorexia or bulimia. And doctors and parents may be falsely reassured if a child is labeled with EDNOS.

"I think that when parents walk out of a doctor's office having heard their kid doesn't meet criteria for anorexia, they're relieved," Peebles said. But they shouldn't let their guard down: in many cases, the child's disturbed eating patterns still need treatment.


'/>"/>

Contact: Robert Dicks
rdicks@lpch.org
650-497-8364
Stanford University Medical Center
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Sinus Dynamics Reaches Milestone with Treatment of Nasal Allergy, Sinus Infection, Acute and Chronic Sinusitis Treating 25,000th Patient
2. Psychologist and Author Paul G. Swingle Talks about his Approach to Treating Depression and Mood Disorders in Online Forum
3. Diet of contaminated insects harms endangered meat-eating plants
4. Researchers identify potential new target for treating hepatitis C
5. Eating Habits Start Early - Parents must be Good Role Models for Healthy Kids
6. Avocados from Mexico Encourages Parents to Model Good Eating Habits
7. When mom has an eating problem
8. Vertebroplasty: Integral to treating back pain in blood marrow cancer patients
9. Discovery of cellular switch may provide new means of triggering cell death, treating disease
10. Thyroid hormone analogue for treating high cholesterol
11. Thyroid Hormone Analogue for Treating High Cholesterol
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/1/2016)... ... May 01, 2016 , ... Women’s Excellence has ... mothers a better understanding of what to expect after they deliver. The guide ... postpartum, · The blues and depression, · Breastfeeding beyond postpartum · Baby basics ...
(Date:4/30/2016)... ... April 30, 2016 , ... Create ... Abstract users can distort and manipulate three-dimensional shapes with ease all within ... ranks, point, lines, polygons, polygon texture animation, opacity texture animation, overall shape texture ...
(Date:4/30/2016)... (PRWEB) , ... April 30, ... ... by CBC News on April 4th, 2016 questioned the use of the ... to EOTTS-HyProCure as “a controversial procedure.” EOTTS-HyProCure is a minimally invasive procedure ...
(Date:4/29/2016)... ... 29, 2016 , ... In an article published April 16th on ... Botox and lip injections, which she underwent in order to feel more at home ... Arts Festival. The article explains that Ms. Mirmelli’s situation is not unique; many plastic ...
(Date:4/29/2016)... ... , ... On Tuesday, April 26, 2016 members of the HomeTown Health network, ... Nathan Deal on SB 258, the “Rural Health Care Relief” Bill. , The bill, ... credit to individuals and corporations which donate directly to a “rural hospital” in Georgia, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:4/27/2016)... FRANCISCO , April 27, 2016 ... expected to reach USD 2.06 billion by 2022, ... Research, Inc. Increasing consumer awareness towards a healthy ... the next seven years.      (Logo: ... diet intake coupled with rising health treatment expenditure ...
(Date:4/26/2016)... 2016 Diplomat Pharmacy, Inc. (NYSE: DPLO) is ... , Pharm D., to Vice President of Education and ... Hagerman will continue to lead and oversee Diplomat University, ... education and training to Diplomat employees and external professionals ... University also houses the quality assurance department, which focuses ...
(Date:4/26/2016)... -- US demand for infection prevention products and ... to $27.6 billion in 2020.  Increasing pressures on ... of healthcare-associated infections (HAIs) will boost revenues generated ... declining, the overall rate of certain HAIs in ... the CDC.  Recent statistics indicate that only 25 ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: