Navigation Links
Doctors who perform abortions are compelled by conscience, just like those who refuse
Date:9/13/2012

Ann Arbor, Mich. Exercising conscience in healthcare is usually defined as refusing to provide contested services, like abortion. But in an article to be published Sept. 13 in the New England Journal of Medicine, a University of Michigan faculty member says doctors can be "conscientious" providers of abortion.

Lisa Harris, M.D., Ph.D., assistant professor of obstetrics and gynecology at the University of Michigan Health System, highlights both historical and contemporary evidence that conscience motivates abortion provision. She cites sociologist Carole Joffe's study that shows skilled mainstream doctors offered safe, compassionate care before Roe v. Wade, risking fines, imprisonment and loss of medical license.

"They did so because the beliefs that mattered most to them compelled it. They saw women die from self-inducted abortion and from abortions performed by unskilled providers," Harris writes.

Harris says contemporary abortion providers are motivated by conscience as well: "Though today abortion providers work within the law, they still have much to lose, facing stigma, marginalization within medicine, harassment and the threat of (or actual) physical harm..However doctors continue to offer abortion care because deeply-held, core ethical beliefs compel them."

There are legal, clinical and ethical consequences of the false dichotomization of conscience and abortion provision, she says. Harris writes that federal and state laws continue to protect only conscience-based refusals to perform or refer for abortion, offering minimal legal protection for conscience-based abortion provision.

In addition, equating conscience with only the refusal to perform abortion continues to stigmatize physicians who are abortion providers.

"If physicians who offer abortion don't have a legitimate claim to act in 'good conscience,' as do their counterparts who oppose abortion, then the implication is that they act in 'bad conscience' or lack conscience altogether," Harris writes.

Harris says bioethicists have focused on moral claims to refuse care provision, largely neglecting that, as she writes, "moral integrity can be injured as much by not performing an action required by one's core beliefs as by performing an action that contradicts those beliefs."

Harris acknowledges that those who oppose abortion will likely argue that abortion providers have motivations other than conscience. While she disagrees, she says this highlights the importance of distinguishing claims of conscience from other types of claims:

"Certainly, if abortion providers' conscience-based claims require scrutiny, so do conscience-based refusals, to ensure that refusals are indeed motivated by conscience and not by political beliefs, stigma, habit erroneous understanding of medical evidence or other factors."

In addition to calling for recognition of "conscientious provision" of care, Harris calls for a standard curriculum and a standard of care for conscientious refusals.


'/>"/>

Contact: Mary F. Masson
mfmasson@umich.edu
734-764-2220
University of Michigan Health System
Source:Eurekalert

Related medicine news :

1. Few Doctors Discuss Exercise With Cancer Patients: Study
2. Worlds largest meeting of ear, nose, and throat doctors
3. Doctors Who Self-Refer to Radiation Clinics Add to Patients Burden: Study
4. Many U.S. Doctors Have Symptoms of Burnout: Survey
5. With Very Sick Infants, Doctors and Parents Often Miscommunicate
6. Nurses as effective as doctors in treatment of HIV patients
7. Doctors can now detect hard-to-diagnose prostate cancer
8. Humanities mini-courses for doctors sharpen thinking and creativity
9. Doctors often dont disclose all possible risks to patients before treatment
10. In muscular dystrophy, what matters to patients and doctors can differ
11. Doctors Spar Over Cholesterol Screening in Kids
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:5/4/2016)... ... May 04, 2016 , ... Olshan Properties ... real estate proudly announced that its service-based charitable program, Olshan Outreach, successfully raised ... will continue Olshan Properties’ annual philanthropic tradition in 2016 with the ‘Fight Against ...
(Date:5/4/2016)... ... May 04, 2016 , ... Hight-Doland Insurance Agency’s new community ... up with Big Brothers Big Sisters of Southwest Louisiana to help provide positive mentoring ... . , Big Brothers Big Sisters of Southwest Louisiana has been helping to guide ...
(Date:5/4/2016)... ... May 04, 2016 , ... Dr. Elyson and Dr. ... removal surgery at their office. Wisdom tooth removal, a common dental procedure, is performed ... they often are improperly erupted, resulting in risks of complications. By providing wisdom tooth ...
(Date:5/4/2016)... ... May 04, 2016 , ... Natalie Jill is a ... MitoXcell in preparation of the launch of her new book: Natalie Jill’s 7 Day ... nutritional guide designed to jump start a new healthy lifestyle featuring simple recipes using ...
(Date:5/4/2016)... ... May 04, 2016 , ... AudioEducator is the ... In upcoming months, AudioEducator has lined up some informative training session for the ... give complete compliance know-how and practical, easy-to-apply advice. , On Thursday, May 19, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:5/3/2016)... -- Research and Markets has announced the ... Market Outlook 2020" report to their offering. ... technology has improved significantly in past years due to ... coming years. Many cancer drugs have been developed by ... also expected to be developed with its help. They ...
(Date:5/3/2016)... , May 3, 2016   BIOTRONIK , ... today announced Food and Drug Administration (FDA) approval ... that provides heart failure patients with access to ... also have remote monitoring with daily automatic transmission ... heart rate in response to physiological demands. ...
(Date:5/3/2016)... May 3, 2016 Pharmaceutical giant ... million to a woman who says its talc-based powder ... Gloria Ristesund $5 million in compensatory damages ... (Logo: http://photos.prnewswire.com/prnh/20160330/349511LOGO ) , This ... the company. In February, the same court awarded $72 ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: