Navigation Links
Doctors and medical ethicist discuss whether doctors should participate in capital punishment
Date:9/4/2007

ROCHESTER, Minn. -- Should doctors be involved in the state-ordered administration of capital punishment? In the September issue of Mayo Clinic Proceedings, three anesthesiologists and a medical ethicist take an in-depth look at this question in a commentary and two editorials.

None of these articles debate whether capital punishment is justifiable. Instead, the authors explore the current position of the American Medical Association (AMA), which prohibits physician participation in legally authorized executions. Here are a few highlights of the arguments presented in these articles.

In a commentary column, David Waisel, M.D., an anesthesiologist practicing at Children's Hospital Boston, Harvard Medical School, asserts that it is time to reassess the AMA's position on this issue and allow doctors to participate in state-mandated executions to help provide the condemned a more humane path to death. Dr. Waisel cites numerous details about the technical problems associated with lethal injection, the form of capital punishment most commonly used in the United States today. Dr. Waisel reasons that doctors, particularly anesthesiologists, possess the skills to administer the medications used in lethal injections in a manner that prevents undue suffering.

"If state administration of capital punishment is legal and ongoing, humane methods of execution should be sought and applied. It is honorable for physicians to minimize the harm to these condemned individuals and organized medicine has an obligation to permit physician participation in legal execution," he writes.

Two editorials that follow Dr. Waisel's commentary arrive at the opposite conclusion. In one editorial, William Lanier, M.D., editor in chief, Mayo Clinic Proceedings, and Keith Berge, M.D., who are anesthesiologists at Mayo Clinic applaud Dr. Waisel for "bringing forward this emotional issue so that it can be pondered and discussed by a broad audience." But the auth
'/>"/>

Contact: John Murphy
newsbureau@mayo.edu
507-284-5005
Mayo Clinic
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Cancer Doctors Okays Controversial Prostate Therapy
2. Doctors needed urgently in Gujarat
3. Doctors operate upon patients in candlelight- latest from the quake scene
4. Two doctors suspended for wrong brain surgery
5. Doctors at risk- the ugly side of the noble profession
6. Lure of the home turf brings back NRI doctors
7. Thakur warns doctors
8. Negligent doctors asked to cough up 3 lakhs for death of patient
9. Doctors advice early anemia tests
10. Emphasis to ban Drugs ads by Doctors
11. Doctors not to accept gifts from drug companies
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/20/2014)... Tuberculosis is one of the most persistent and deadliest ... million people each year. , Scientists who study tuberculosis ... tuberculosis likely spread from humans in Africa to seals ... America and transmitted it to Native people there before ... Mycobacterial Genomes Reveal Seals as a Source of New ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... spawning grounds through fast-moving waters may be at risk, ... , When salmon encounter turbulent, fast-moving water such ... must move upstream using a behaviour known as "burst ... "Days after sockeye passed through extremely fast-moving water, we ... from their spawning grounds," said Nicholas Burnett, a research ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... York (PRWEB) August 20, 2014 As ... use of power morcellators ( http://www.injurybeacon.com/power-morcellator/ ) in ... that two U.S. Senators from New York are urging ... a recall of the devices. In a letter dated ... Democrats, also implored the agency to seriously consider the ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... 2014) Research from Columbia University Medical Center shows ... cancer growth and that blocking nerve signals using surgery ... the disease. The study was conducted by the laboratory ... Chen, MD, PhD, in Norway and is published in ... "Scientists have long observed that human and mouse cancers ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... stimulates stress responses in adults, researchers at Yerkes ... that the amygdala has an inhibitory effect on ... primates. , The results are published this week ... amygdala is a region of the brain known ... and learning about threats. Alterations in the amygdala ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:New research shows seals and sea lions likely spread tuberculosis to humans 2Health News:New research shows seals and sea lions likely spread tuberculosis to humans 3Health News:Salmon forced to 'sprint' less likely to survive migration 2Health News:Power Morcellator News: Bernstein Liebhard LLP Notes Senators’ Letter Seeking FDA Morcellator Recall 2Health News:Power Morcellator News: Bernstein Liebhard LLP Notes Senators’ Letter Seeking FDA Morcellator Recall 3Health News:Power Morcellator News: Bernstein Liebhard LLP Notes Senators’ Letter Seeking FDA Morcellator Recall 4Health News:Severing nerves may shrink stomach cancers: Botox injections slow growth of tumors in mice 2Health News:Maturing brain flips function of amygdala in regulating stress hormones 2Health News:Maturing brain flips function of amygdala in regulating stress hormones 3
... that Migration/Macrophage Inhibitory factor (MIF) which is an immune cell ... be used in finding drugs which reduces the amount of ... hindered. , Multiple Sclerosis: ,Multiple ... of its own body cells by the immune system leading ...
... A recent study published in the November issue ... that dyspnea, or shortness of breath may be ... ,Although dyspnea is a common symptom, there ... significance among patients referred for cardiac evaluation.,Cardiologists at ...
... plethora of medicinal properties it is a great food. ... such as vampires. Now scientists are finding that garlic, //or ... carcinogens produced by meat cooked at high temperatures. ... releases a chemical called PhIP, a suspected carcinogen. Epidemiological studies ...
... broccoli sprouts may help prevent gastric cancer by reducing Helicobacteri ... and is believed to be a major factor in peptic ... a Japanese team, found that taking a diet with 100 ... H. pylori infection experiencing a significant reduction of H. pylori ...
... Dr. Wan Lian Chua, Psychiatrist, Bradford District Care Trust ... had not given any effective improvement in their condition. ... use of estrogen therapy for treatment of Schizophrenia. Researchers ... used in treating patients before it is tested in ...
... Avian flu pandemic could kill 3 million people in Asia, ... a recession in the world, the Asian Development Bank has ... the likely effects on the region if bird flu produces ... workers being taken ill. 'Growth in Asia would virtually stop,' ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Macrophage Inhibitory Factor Causes Multiple Sclerosis Progression 2Health News:A Boon For Gastritis Patients In The Form Of Broccoli 2Health News:ADB Report Warns of Bird-Flu Catastrophe 2
(Date:8/20/2014)... , Aug. 20, 2014 Reportlinker.com ... available in its catalogue: The Market ... http://www.reportlinker.com/p02051938/The-Market-for-Medical-Devices-in-EMEA .html The European, Middle Eastern and ... medical devices. As part of its coverage, this ... concentrates on the EMEA medical device markets and ...
(Date:8/20/2014)... Aug. 20, 2014  Quantum Materials Corporation (OTCQB:QTMM) ... of patent families from Bayer Technology Services GmbH, the ... Bayer AG of Leverkusen, Germany ... broad intellectual property protection for advances Quantum ... dot (QD) manufacturing. In addition, the Bayer patents ...
(Date:8/19/2014)... , Aug. 19, 2014 Talyst, a market ... exhibiting at the 2014 NPPA Summer Conference in ... be showcasing its 340B software products and services.   ... splitting solutions, supplying over 400 customers with a variety ... 340B solutions including its latest solution, AutoSplit® Contract Pharmacy ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:The Market for Medical Devices in EMEA 2The Market for Medical Devices in EMEA 3The Market for Medical Devices in EMEA 4The Market for Medical Devices in EMEA 5Quantum Materials Acquires Bayer Technology Services Quantum Dot Manufacturing and Quantum Dot Solar Cell Patents 2Quantum Materials Acquires Bayer Technology Services Quantum Dot Manufacturing and Quantum Dot Solar Cell Patents 3Quantum Materials Acquires Bayer Technology Services Quantum Dot Manufacturing and Quantum Dot Solar Cell Patents 4Talyst Exhibits at the NPPA Summer Conference 2
... at American Society of Clinical Oncology 2009 Annual Meeting ... , , SAN FRANCISCO, June 2 Medivation, ... presentation of new clinical results from a Phase 1-2 ... castration-resistant prostate cancer (CRPC) patients. The new findings, ...
... , Panel Discussant Focuses on Longer Duration of Remission ... Complete Remissions Achieved with Standard Chemotherapy , , ... MTA: CTIC) announced today that at the poster and ... Section at the 2009 American Society of Clinical Oncology ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Medivation Announces Positive New Efficacy Data From Phase 1-2 Trial of MDV3100 in Advanced Prostate Cancer Patients 2Medivation Announces Positive New Efficacy Data From Phase 1-2 Trial of MDV3100 in Advanced Prostate Cancer Patients 3Medivation Announces Positive New Efficacy Data From Phase 1-2 Trial of MDV3100 in Advanced Prostate Cancer Patients 4Medivation Announces Positive New Efficacy Data From Phase 1-2 Trial of MDV3100 in Advanced Prostate Cancer Patients 5Pixantrone Produces High Rates of Complete and Partial Remissions Even Among Aggressive NHL Patients With Extensive Prior Doxorubicin Treatment or Prior Rituximab Treatment 2Pixantrone Produces High Rates of Complete and Partial Remissions Even Among Aggressive NHL Patients With Extensive Prior Doxorubicin Treatment or Prior Rituximab Treatment 3Pixantrone Produces High Rates of Complete and Partial Remissions Even Among Aggressive NHL Patients With Extensive Prior Doxorubicin Treatment or Prior Rituximab Treatment 4Pixantrone Produces High Rates of Complete and Partial Remissions Even Among Aggressive NHL Patients With Extensive Prior Doxorubicin Treatment or Prior Rituximab Treatment 5Pixantrone Produces High Rates of Complete and Partial Remissions Even Among Aggressive NHL Patients With Extensive Prior Doxorubicin Treatment or Prior Rituximab Treatment 6
An enzyme-linked immuno-sorbent assay for the detectionand quantitation of anti-tissue Transglutaminase in serum of patients with Celiac Disease and Dermatitis Herpetiformis....
Jerome Halo Traction Units provide optimum immobilization for unstable injuries of the spine. The Generation 80 superstructure is available with either 2-point (serrated disk), or 3-point (flexion/ex...
... Boston Scoliosis Brace™ for neuromuscular ... a lightweight, soft, and easy ... maximum comfort. The Soft ... of non-cracking orthopedic grade copolymer ...
An indirect immunofluorescence antibody test for the qualitative and semi-quantitative detection of endomysial antibodies (EMA) in human serum as an aid in the diagnosis of celiac disease and dermati...
Medicine Products: