Navigation Links
Disability System Sorely in Need of Reform
Date:9/27/2007

U.S. Could Use Serving of Chile-Style Reform, Says NCPA Study

DALLAS, Sept. 27 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- The number of workers receiving disability in the U.S. is growing so rapidly that these benefits are now the fastest rising component of Social Security spending -- growing at nearly twice the rate of retirement benefits, according to a new analysis from the National Center for Policy Analysis (NCPA). In a separate study also released today, the NCPA says Chile's disability system costs less than half of the U.S. system -- 1.8% of payroll in the U.S. versus 0.7% of payroll in Chile -- and provides more generous benefits.

"Older workers often have an incentive to use disability as a form of early retirement," said NCPA President John Goodman. "In Chile, the incentive is to keep working."

The NCPA concluded that the disability system has been growing so fast in part because of perverse incentives. For example:

-- According to the Social Security Trustees, the number of disabled

beneficiaries more than doubled, from 3.9 million in 1985 to 8.4

million in 2006, whereas people receiving retirement benefits grew

less than 25 percent over the same period. Annual disability

expenditures grew five fold, while retirement benefits grew less

than three-fold.

-- If workers claim early retirement benefits from Social Security, the

amount they receive for retirement is reduced. By contrast, a 62-

year-old worker can claim disability and receive monthly benefits that

are about 30 percent higher than early retirement benefits. This

creates an incentive to claim disability. And, disability benefits

stop if the beneficiary returns to work, therefore discouraging

productive labor.

-- Although less than 40 percent of disability applicants are initially

approved, about 60 percent are approved after appeals. Since appeals

are only made by the applicant, not Social Security, the number can

only go up, never down, during the appeals process.

Chile replaced its traditional social security system 25 years ago with a system of personal retirement accounts. Workers now put 10 percent of their wages into personal retirement accounts in pension funds of their choice and pay an additional 2.4 percent for survivors' and disability insurance and administrative fees.

Depending on the number of years they have participated and the degree of their disability, Chilean workers are guaranteed to receive as much as 70 percent of their wages -- a higher percentage than disabled workers in the U.S. Although workers have a lifetime to save for retirement, they can become disabled at any age. If a disabled worker's retirement account balance is insufficient to purchase an annuity that replaces a guaranteed percentage of his wages, he receives the rest from a group insurance policy purchased by the worker's pension fund. On the average, workers' own savings are projected to cover about 50 percent of the cost of their disability benefits; insurance covers the rest. Due to this reform, Chile's disability system will cost only a fourth of what it otherwise would have been, in the long run.

According to the NCPA's study, several features of Chile's disability system reduce costs and provide workers with incentives to continue working. For example:

-- Part of the benefit is financed by the worker's retirement account and

investment earnings on the annuity premium.

-- Since disabled workers draw on their own retirement accounts to fund

their benefits, workers have less of an incentive to claim disability

as a form of early retirement.

-- Pension funds in Chile participate in the disability assessment

procedure and can challenge disability determinations made by

independent medical boards.

-- Once workers in Chile are approved for permanent disability, they are

still permitted to work.

"The experience of Chile suggests disability costs can be contained in a way that benefits both workers and the economy," said former World Bank economist Estelle James, author of the NCPA study. "It is a model worth considering."

The NCPA is an internationally known nonprofit, nonpartisan research institute with offices in Dallas and Washington, D. C. that advocates private solutions to public policy problems. We depend on the contributions of individuals, corporations and foundations that share our mission. The NCPA accepts no government grants.


'/>"/>
SOURCE National Center for Policy Analysis
Copyright©2007 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Alcoholics are prone to disability
2. Hypertension drugs could lower Disability
3. Running delays disability in the aged
4. Restricted Activity Predicts Disability
5. Obesity More Likely to Cause Disability than Death in Elderly
6. Kalam Appeals to Eradicate Hearing Disability
7. Psychosocial Disability Varies In Accordance With Bipolar Symptom Changes
8. Depression And Chronic Pain Cause Disability In Women
9. The higher the income the lower the disability rates!
10. Life expectancy has increased… so has the disability rates!
11. Preventing Falls May Be Key to Avoiding Disability in Elderly
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:6/26/2017)... ... 26, 2017 , ... New patients with missing teeth in Fitchburg, ... a referral. Dr. Cotey is a trusted dentist who has placed many dental implants ... Patients with missing teeth in Fitchburg, WI, are encouraged to find out if they ...
(Date:6/25/2017)... ... June 24, 2017 , ... Create a feel-good lyric music video in Final Cut Pro X ... the timeline and write in the lyrics to any song. ProLyric flies in the text ... of the text can be added modularly for optimal control. ProLyric makes editing any music ...
(Date:6/25/2017)... ... 25, 2017 , ... An increase in wetter weather in the Northern California ... with that; a humdinger of an allergy season. A relief from drought conditions is ... misery-causing grass and weed pollen. , “Our patients have been reporting the typical ...
(Date:6/25/2017)... ... ... With a heatwave currently bearing down on Northern California pushing temperatures to the maximum, many ... is easy with laser hair removal. , The process of summer waxing and constantly ... all you want to do is get out, dive in and cool off. There is ...
(Date:6/24/2017)... , ... June 24, 2017 , ... ... offering genetic testing for medications in select Florida and Texas doctors' offices and ... , This new application of genetic testing recognizes the role genes play in ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:6/8/2017)... Fla. , June 8, 2017  Less than ... that hit more than 200,000 companies, including hospital networks, ... being heralded as one of the largest online extortion ... in the healthcare market, it is imperative that providers ... protect their data from this — and many other ...
(Date:6/7/2017)... June 7, 2017 Endo International plc (NASDAQ: ... 2017, the Hon. Joseph R. Goodwin , U.S. ... West Virginia , entered a case management ... Repair System Products Liability Litigation (the "MDL") that includes ... to provide expert disclosures on specific causation within one ...
(Date:6/5/2017)... 2017 The Cincinnati location ... Inc. (NYSE: DPLO), has been awarded a Top Workplaces ... Results are based on an employee survey administered by ... workplace improvement. The survey measures several aspects of workplace culture, ... ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: