Navigation Links
Critique 029: What should we advise about alcohol consumption? A debate amongst scientists
Date:1/18/2011

A Letter to the Editor entitled "What should we advise about alcohol consumption?" was recently published by Maurizio Ponz de Leon in Intern Emerg Med.1 Dr. de Leon argues that the message of health benefits of moderate drinking "seems to me hazardous and extremely dangerous to diffuse in the general population." His reasons included (1) many people may be unable to distinguish between lowmoderate and high consumption of wine, beer or spirits, and alcohol metabolism may differ remarkably from one subject to another; (2) alcohol remains a frequent cause of car crash, and governments (in almost all western countries) try to convince or force people to abstain from drinking before driving; and (3) to consider alcohol as a medication whose consumption may contribute to improved health is another source of concern. Dr. de Leon asks: "Are we truly at the point of prescribing alcohol consumption in order to reduce the risk of stroke and coronary damage?" He concluded "more studies are needed before we can give sensible recommendations on alcohol consumption to the general population."

The de Leon editorial has prompted considerable response from other scientists, including further Letters to the Editor of the journal by Di Castelnuovo, Costanzo, Donati, Iacoviello, and de Gaetano,2 and by Estruch and Lamuela-Raventos.3 In addition, the original editorial has stimulated considerable debate among members of the International Scientific Forum on Alcohol Research. Among key arguments presented by the Forum members, all experts in scientific research on alcohol, are that messages to the public should not be "paternalistic" (we will tell you what is best for you since you are not smart enough to understand the facts), and that guidelines must always be based on sound, balanced scientific data rather than on uninformed opinion. Forum members emphasized that there are certain people who should not drink at all (including former abusers of drugs or alcohol,
'/>"/>

Contact: R. Curtis Ellison
eillison@bu.edu
508-333-1256
Boston University Medical Center
Source:Eurekalert

Page: 1 2

Related medicine news :

1. Henry Ford Hospital study: Shoulder function not fully restored after surgery
2. Prevention of bad lifestyle habits should be tackled even before 13 years
3. E-Cigarettes Should Be Banned Until Made Safe: Study
4. Hospital perks: How much should hospitals be rewarded for the patient experience?
5. Women With Breast Cancer History Should Consider MRI: Study
6. Women with personal history of breast cancer should be screened with MRI
7. Fresh Seafood Shouldnt Smell Fishy, Food Science Expert Says
8. Radiation fears should not deter women from mammography screening
9. Most hysterectomies should be performed vaginally or laparoscopically
10. Severely injured should go directly to trauma center: Research
11. Concussion Should Sideline Athletes: Neurologists
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/27/2014)... For nearly two decades, audiences around the world ... Deva Premal & Miten with their rapturous Nepali flute ... album in May, their 2014 MANTRAS FOR LIFE TOUR ... globe, including Russia, Ukraine, Israel, Australia, the U.S., Canada, ... new album and a new five-piece band, the love ...
(Date:8/27/2014)... positive hospital blood culture samples are discarded every day ... skin germs instead of specific disease-causing bacteria. , ... clinicians may be able to use the resistance profiles ... patients with antibiotics appropriate to their ailment, Tel Aviv ... Alon of TAU,s Sackler Faculty of Medicine and the ...
(Date:8/27/2014)... (PRWEB) August 27, 2014 According ... Market Research "Ablation Technologies Market (Applications: Cardiovascular, Gynecology, ... Electrical, Ultrasound, Microwave, Cryotherapy) - Global Industry Analysis, ... 2020," the global ablation technologies market was valued ... estimated to reach a market worth USD 10,611 ...
(Date:8/27/2014)... NH 8/27/14)Dartmouth cancer researchers developed and tested an ... environmental interactions that contribute to disease as published ... , The approach fills a gap in current ... complex interactions among genetic and environmental factors. When ... interactions versus those that reflect chance combinations among ...
(Date:8/27/2014)... 2014 Nava Beauty Store and Spa aims ... patrons from those seeking luxury care products to the everyday ... high end luxurious brands like Valmont and Elemis to cater ... brands like Dermalogica and Bliss to provide easy to use ... also offer purely organic skin care products such as Jurlique, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Deva Premal & Miten's Mantras For Life Tour Announced 2Health News:Deva Premal & Miten's Mantras For Life Tour Announced 3Health News:'Junk' blood tests may offer life-saving information 2Health News:Global Ablation Technologies Market Expected to Reach USD 10.6 Billion in 2020: Transparency Market Research 2Health News:Global Ablation Technologies Market Expected to Reach USD 10.6 Billion in 2020: Transparency Market Research 3Health News:Global Ablation Technologies Market Expected to Reach USD 10.6 Billion in 2020: Transparency Market Research 4Health News:Global Ablation Technologies Market Expected to Reach USD 10.6 Billion in 2020: Transparency Market Research 5Health News:Dartmouth isolates environmental influences in genome-wide association studies 2Health News:Nava Beauty Store Announce Grand Opening in Great Neck, New York 2
... in the United States who undergo surgery to have ... a recent study shows that men who have their ... cancer returns . ,Researchers studied more than 500 ... study first had a radical prostatectomy and also underwent ...
... is the most common bacterial illness in children and ... of children may be getting treated unnecessarily with antibiotics ... they don’t need them may build up antibiotic resistance, ... a more serious infection. ,According to the new ...
... that certain hormones in the body may yield a ... events and death in people with no symptoms. Researchers ... the current standards used to diagnose heart failure. ... the participants’ blood looking for specific substances and compared ...
... their risk of birth defects. Now, new research shows ... say about 31,000 stroke-related deaths and about 17,000 heart ... fortification was implemented. ,Folic acid lowers homocysteine levels. ... risk for stroke and heart disease. Specialists from the ...
... new study shows the use of antibacterial products, such ... reduce the risk of infectious// disease symptoms in the ... households in New York with at least one preschool-age ... household cleaning and personal hygiene products that contained antibacterial ...
... study suggests drinking extra fluids may do more harm ... ,Researchers examined results from previous studies to determine if ... safe. Previous data has shown during a respiratory infection, ... large amounts of a specific hormone that conserves water. ...
Cached Medicine News:
(Date:8/27/2014)... NORWALK, Conn. , Aug. 27, 2014  UBM ... , a leading online community for medical imaging professionals, ... Association for Medical Imaging Management,s 2014 Annual Meeting ... the conference coverage: , 11 Principles ... management can lead to greater profitability. , ...
(Date:8/27/2014)... , Aug. 27, 2014 /PRNewswire-iReach/ -- Emergency ... design, blended emergency medical training and response technologies, ... defibrillator) training from the Department of Homeland ... Reserve 81 st Regional Support Command ... contract includes nationwide CPR/AED/First Aid training. The Army ...
(Date:8/27/2014)... , Aug. 27, 2014   Auxilium Pharmaceuticals , Inc. ... biopharmaceutical company, today announced that certain members of the ... Healthcare Conference to be held September 8-10, 2014 in ... , Chief Executive Officer and President, is scheduled to ... portfolio at 10:55 a.m. ET on Wednesday, September 10, ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Diagnostic Imaging Covers Association for Medical Imaging Management (AHRA) 2014 Meeting 2Diagnostic Imaging Covers Association for Medical Imaging Management (AHRA) 2014 Meeting 3Emergency University Equips Homeland Security, Army Reserve with SCA Response Program to Save Lives of Sudden Cardiac Arrest Victims 2Emergency University Equips Homeland Security, Army Reserve with SCA Response Program to Save Lives of Sudden Cardiac Arrest Victims 3Auxilium Pharmaceuticals, Inc. To Present At The Morgan Stanley Healthcare Conference 2Auxilium Pharmaceuticals, Inc. To Present At The Morgan Stanley Healthcare Conference 3
... Quark Pharmaceuticals, Inc., a pharmaceutical company engaged in ... it has dosed the first patient with recent onset ... ongoing Phase I study of QPI-1007, the Company,s proprietary ... The Phase I open-label, dose-escalation study was initiated ...
... PHILADELPHIA, Oct. 20 ERT (Nasdaq: ... for the third quarter 2010 on Thursday, November 4, 2010, ... host a conference call at 5:00 PM EDT that day. ... dial 1-800-860-2442 when calling within the United States or 1-412-858-4600 ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Quark Pharmaceuticals Doses First Non-Arteritic Anterior Ischemic Optic Neuropathy (NAION) Patient in Stratum II of its Clinical Study of siRNA Drug Candidate QPI-1007 2Quark Pharmaceuticals Doses First Non-Arteritic Anterior Ischemic Optic Neuropathy (NAION) Patient in Stratum II of its Clinical Study of siRNA Drug Candidate QPI-1007 3ERT to Announce Third Quarter 2010 Results on November 4, 2010 2
... High Throughput Screening (UHTS), Analyst GT ... Allows for smooth transfer of assays ... sharing all the detection modalities of ... fluorescence polarization, time-resolved fluorescence, luminescence, absorbance, ...
... Ultra High Throughput Screening (UHTS), Analyst ... performance. Allows for smooth transfer of ... by sharing all the detection modalities ... intensity, fluorescence polarization, time-resolved fluorescence, luminescence, ...
... exclusively for cell-based assays, the NOVOstar provides ... to the flexibility of an on-board reagent ... plate to plate or from three reagent ... the unit has two injectors that can ...
... cDNA and Oligonucleotides The Tecan GENios ... variety applications that are quantified by Fluorescence, Absorbance ... assays in Microplate formats from 6 to ... Cuvettes Independent whether you have to quantitate ...
Medicine Products: