Navigation Links
Court's Verdict on Health-Care Reform Holds Surprises, Legal Experts Say
Date:6/28/2012

By Lisa Esposito
HealthDay Reporter

THURSDAY, June 28 (HealthDay News) -- After the U.S. Supreme Court's announcement Thursday that it would uphold most of the 2010 Affordable Care Act, many legal experts were quick to register their surprise at the decision -- and their sense that perhaps the battle over health-care reform was not yet finished.

The complicated 5-to-4 decision allows the law to proceed with its goal of covering more than 30 million uninsured Americans. That includes the controversial "individual mandate" provision, which requires most consumers to buy health care insurance or face a penalty. The court held that the mandate fell under the category of a tax, and as such was constitutional and could stand.

That came as a surprise to Stephen Presser, a professor of legal history at Northwestern University School of Law in Chicago. He had predicted that the Supreme Court would find the health-reform law unconstitutional and the whole package would go down.

"I had thought that the issue of whether [the individual mandate] was a tax was over and done with," Presser said. "This strikes me as a disappointing decision, which fails fully to preserve the limitations on the Constitution of the federal government," he added.

"It's disappointing that all the proponents of the Act had steadfastly said that this was not a tax. That this was not a bill to raise revenues, that this was not a bill to increase health care costs. Had it acknowledged that it was in fact a tax, it's much more doubtful that it would have passed, given the thin margin that it did pass by, it may have made a difference. So what the court has done is salvaged the Act in a Constitutional sleight of hand," Presser said.

But Renee Landers, a professor of law at Suffolk University Law School, had betted on the other side -- that the mandate could still survive -- and today's decision justified her confidence.

"It was hard t
'/>"/>

Copyright©2012 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. Stanford researchers discover the African cichlids noisy courtship ritual
2. Health-care law gender gap
3. States' Next Steps on Health Reform - Will They Launch Exchanges?
4. Ethics should drive health policy reform, especially with physician-owned specialty hospitals
5. America Awaits Supreme Courts Ruling on Health Care Reform
6. Study finds Massachusetts health reform leads to increased inpatient surgical procedures
7. Americans Support Medicare Reform, But Not on Their Dime: Poll
8. Internal medicine physician specialists release policy paper on reforming Medicaid
9. Grb2 holds powerful molecular signaling pathway in check
10. 1 in 3 households misreports smoke alarm coverage
11. US Drug Watchdog Now Offers To Get A Free Legal Review For All DePuy ASR Recipients Who Received A Letter From Broadspire About Their Recalled DePuy Hip Implant
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Court's Verdict on Health-Care Reform Holds Surprises, Legal Experts Say 
(Date:4/25/2015)... 2015 Carinsurancequotesinfo.com has released a new ... cost auto insurance for flatbed trucks. , ... sometimes other vehicles. They are mainly used for commercial ... released blog post explains that by comparing multiple offers, ... and other commercial vehicles. , It is now possible ...
(Date:4/25/2015)... Islands, BWI (PRWEB) April 25, 2015 ... has celebrated three months of successfully welcoming visitors to ... 5, 2015. , As part of a major ... Providenciales airport was completely redesigned to speed up arrivals. ... the process of getting out of the airport and ...
(Date:4/25/2015)... York New York (PRWEB) April 25, 2015 ... that Dr. Jerry Blaivas has been chosen by the New ... for his contributions to medicine in the field of Urology. ... the best in his speciality, Genito-Urinary diseases. He was ... specifically in the field of urology. Not only did ...
(Date:4/25/2015)... 2015 For thirteen years, the Twin Cities ... education event in the nation! This year, on May 5th, ... US to take DI Day on the road by supporting ... CLU, ChFC, RHU, DIA, CLTC, Chief Executive Officer at Secura ... on the change by stating, "The first Twin Cities DI ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... 24, 2015 Multi Customer Discount , ... pumping ( http://www.zeitersseptics.com/multi-customer-discount.html ) of 1000-1500 gallons in Zeiter's ... program. This does not include any Dig fees, or ... per person. If someone is part of this group ... totaling approximately 2500 gallons or more, the cost would ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Auto Insurance Quotes for Flatbed Trucks Available Online! 2Health News:The Tuscany on Grace Bay Celebrates Providenciales Airport Expansion With Summer Specials to Travelers! 2Health News:The 2015 Valentine Award Comes From The Heart and Goes To Famous New York Urologist 2Health News:The 2015 Valentine Award Comes From The Heart and Goes To Famous New York Urologist 3Health News:Secura Consultants Takes DI Day On The Road 2Health News:Zeiter's Septics Inc. Offers Multi Customer Septic Tank Cleaning Program in Cook, Putnam & Will Counties in May 2015 2Health News:Zeiter's Septics Inc. Offers Multi Customer Septic Tank Cleaning Program in Cook, Putnam & Will Counties in May 2015 3
... Qiao Xing,Mobile Communication Co., Ltd. (,Qiao Xing Mobile, or ... domestic manufacturers of mobile,handsets through its subsidiary CEC Telecom ... C7000A cardiograph mobile handset., The C7000A has ... will be able to perform a basic ...
... form of breast cancer are being tested in a ... six continents -- a clinical trial that investigators hope ... This trial, dubbed ALTTO (Adjuvant Lapatinib and/or Trastuzumab Treatment ... initiatives in which two large, academic breast cancer research ...
... affected by ... rare diseases, NEW YORK, Feb. ... Day will be launched on Friday 29,February...because it,s a rare day that ... Shire plc at:, http://media.medialink.com/WebNR.aspx?story=34701 ), Collectively, rare diseases aren,t ...
... Firm,s Growing Healthcare Practice, BROOKFIELD, Wis., Feb. ... human resources outsourcing company, has added,Gordon Warner to ... Services,Director., Warner brings extensive HR experience and ... Warner comes to Pinstripe from,M&I Bank in Milwaukee, ...
... 28 Millennium,Pharmaceuticals, Inc. (Nasdaq: MLNM ... 2008 Susquehanna Healthcare Conference will be webcast ... Investors section of the Company,s website, http://www.millennium.com ... The presentation will include an overview ...
... Idaho, Feb. 28 NightHawk,Radiology Holdings, Inc. (Nasdaq: ... groups across the United States, today announced,that Ernest G. ... of the,company,s Board of Directors for personal reasons. Mr. ... company intends to immediately begin a search,to identify a ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:Qiao Xing Mobile's CECT Subsidiary Releases Newest Handset Model; C7000A Offers Cardiograph, 120 Days Ultra-Long Standby and 3.0'' LCD Screen 2Health News:Qiao Xing Mobile's CECT Subsidiary Releases Newest Handset Model; C7000A Offers Cardiograph, 120 Days Ultra-Long Standby and 3.0'' LCD Screen 3Health News:New study of targeted therapies for breast cancer -- model for global clinical trials 2Health News:New study of targeted therapies for breast cancer -- model for global clinical trials 3Health News:New study of targeted therapies for breast cancer -- model for global clinical trials 4Health News:VIDEO from Medialink and Shire plc: Rare Diseases Must Be Top of the Health Agenda 2Health News:VIDEO from Medialink and Shire plc: Rare Diseases Must Be Top of the Health Agenda 3Health News:Pinstripe Healthcare Group Adds Veteran HR Executive Warner as Client Services Director 2Health News:2008 Susquehanna Healthcare Conference to Webcast Millennium Presentation 2Health News:NightHawk Radiology Holdings, Inc. Announces Board Member Departure 2
(Date:4/24/2015)... ATLANTA , April 24, 2015 Allowing ... naloxone could reduce drug overdose deaths that involve opioids, ... (CDC) study, "Disparity in Naloxone Administration by Emergency Medical ... Rural Communities," published in the American Journal of ... 16,000 deaths in the United States ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... , April 24, 2015  IGI Laboratories, Inc. ... based specialty generic pharmaceutical company, announced the Company ... on Tuesday, April 28, 2015 to discuss the 1st ... to listen to the call by dialing 1-888-346-3479. International ... Participants should ask to be joined into the IGI ...
(Date:4/24/2015)... , April 24, 2015   Vestagen Technical ... technology, VESTEX ® , has recently received two notable ... a global competition that recognizes innovations with potential to ... ceremony last night in New York City ... the Material Science "Protection & Safety" category. The awards ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Expanding Naloxone use could reduce drug overdose deaths and save lives 2Expanding Naloxone use could reduce drug overdose deaths and save lives 3VESTEX Wins Innovation Honors from Edison Awards & Apparel Magazine 2VESTEX Wins Innovation Honors from Edison Awards & Apparel Magazine 3
... 8, 2011 Novation, the leading health care supply ... Medical (St. Paul, MN) to its portfolio of agreements ... Jude Medical is a leading provider of medical devices ... company provides a full portfolio of arrhythmia management products, ...
... HOFFMAN ESTATES, Ill., April 8, 2011 Life Spine, ... markets products for the surgical treatment of spine disorders, ... out of nine new products scheduled for launch in ... (AANS) Annual Meeting in Denver, Colorado. ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Novation Announces the Addition of St. Jude Medical to the Cardiac Rhythm Management Products Portfolio 2
... ARUP Laboratories is a national reference laboratory ... research and development. ARUP offers an extensive ... medical tests in clinical and anatomic pathology. ... Laboratories' clients include more than half of ...
... Laboratories is a national reference laboratory and ... and development. ARUP offers an extensive test ... tests in clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned ... clients include more than half of the ...
... is a national reference laboratory and a ... development. ARUP offers an extensive test menu ... in clinical and anatomic pathology. Owned by ... include more than half of the nation's ...
... reference laboratory and a worldwide leader in ... an extensive test menu of highly complex ... anatomic pathology. Owned by the University of ... half of the nation's university teaching hospitals ...
Medicine Products: