Navigation Links
Court's Verdict on Health-Care Reform Holds Surprises, Legal Experts Say
Date:6/28/2012

By Lisa Esposito
HealthDay Reporter

THURSDAY, June 28 (HealthDay News) -- After the U.S. Supreme Court's announcement Thursday that it would uphold most of the 2010 Affordable Care Act, many legal experts were quick to register their surprise at the decision -- and their sense that perhaps the battle over health-care reform was not yet finished.

The complicated 5-to-4 decision allows the law to proceed with its goal of covering more than 30 million uninsured Americans. That includes the controversial "individual mandate" provision, which requires most consumers to buy health care insurance or face a penalty. The court held that the mandate fell under the category of a tax, and as such was constitutional and could stand.

That came as a surprise to Stephen Presser, a professor of legal history at Northwestern University School of Law in Chicago. He had predicted that the Supreme Court would find the health-reform law unconstitutional and the whole package would go down.

"I had thought that the issue of whether [the individual mandate] was a tax was over and done with," Presser said. "This strikes me as a disappointing decision, which fails fully to preserve the limitations on the Constitution of the federal government," he added.

"It's disappointing that all the proponents of the Act had steadfastly said that this was not a tax. That this was not a bill to raise revenues, that this was not a bill to increase health care costs. Had it acknowledged that it was in fact a tax, it's much more doubtful that it would have passed, given the thin margin that it did pass by, it may have made a difference. So what the court has done is salvaged the Act in a Constitutional sleight of hand," Presser said.

But Renee Landers, a professor of law at Suffolk University Law School, had betted on the other side -- that the mandate could still survive -- and today's decision justified her confidence.

"It was hard t
'/>"/>

Copyright©2012 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Page: 1 2 3 4

Related medicine news :

1. Stanford researchers discover the African cichlids noisy courtship ritual
2. Health-care law gender gap
3. States' Next Steps on Health Reform - Will They Launch Exchanges?
4. Ethics should drive health policy reform, especially with physician-owned specialty hospitals
5. America Awaits Supreme Courts Ruling on Health Care Reform
6. Study finds Massachusetts health reform leads to increased inpatient surgical procedures
7. Americans Support Medicare Reform, But Not on Their Dime: Poll
8. Internal medicine physician specialists release policy paper on reforming Medicaid
9. Grb2 holds powerful molecular signaling pathway in check
10. 1 in 3 households misreports smoke alarm coverage
11. US Drug Watchdog Now Offers To Get A Free Legal Review For All DePuy ASR Recipients Who Received A Letter From Broadspire About Their Recalled DePuy Hip Implant
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Court's Verdict on Health-Care Reform Holds Surprises, Legal Experts Say 
(Date:9/19/2014)... using intact cells to treat and cure disease ... it is hindered by the inability of doctors and ... of these cells in patients without resorting to invasive ... September 17 in the online journal Magnetic Resonance ... San Diego School of Medicine, University of Pittsburgh and ...
(Date:9/19/2014)... published today in the online journal PLoS Outbreaks ... West Africa by the end of the month if ... State University and Harvard University researchers also discovered through ... significantly increased in August in Liberia and Guinea, around ... place, indicating that the mass quarantine efforts may have ...
(Date:9/19/2014)... Fla. Researchers at Jacksonville,s campus of Mayo Clinic ... they say contributes to both overproduction of toxic protein ... as well as loss of communication between neurons ... Their study, in the online issue of ... specific defect with drugs "may rejuvenate or rescue this ...
(Date:9/19/2014)... Sept. 19, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- When it comes ... in the United States, while the District of Columbia ... the past decade, deaths from gun-related violence -- including ... the United States, the study revealed. Hawaii,s rate was ... of the spectrum, the District of Columbia had the ...
(Date:9/19/2014)... (Sept. 19, 2014) Shahram Majidi, M.D., a ... the George Washington University School of Medicine and ... American Heart Association to study the presence of ... intracerebral hemorrhage (ICH). , "According to epidemiological studies, ... of all strokes, but is the least treatable ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:A better way to track emerging cell therapies using MRIs 2Health News:Research predicts possible 6,800 new Ebola cases this month 2Health News:Mayo researchers reveal pathway that contributes to Alzheimer's disease 2Health News:U.S. Gun Deaths Lowest in Hawaii, Highest in D.C. 2Health News:GW researcher receives grant to study brain swelling following bleeding in the brain 2
... Stem cell research holds promise for improving the quality of ... develop into any tissue in the human body. However, basic ... researchers are leading the way to inventive solutions. ... and safe therapeutic tool, we have to find strategies to ...
... cafeterias and other food-service providers? A new study from North ... cameras in commercial kitchens to see how precisely food handlers ... more often than previously thought. "Meals prepared outside the ... food poisoning outbreaks, making them a vital focus area for ...
... U.S. Food and Drug Administration,s abilities to discover potential ... illness are hampered by impediments to efficient use of ... and using information on risks, says a new report ... To more proactively tackle food safety problems, ...
... is influenced by our personality traits, according to new research ... published yesterday (7 June 2010) in the Proceedings of ... higher levels of neuroticism and more extravert men, are likely ... societies with traditionally high birth rates. The study ...
... extra sleep over an extended period of time improves ... abstract that will be presented Tuesday, June 8, 2010, ... annual meeting of the Associated Professional Sleep Societies LLC. ... significantly after seven to eight weeks of sleep extension. ...
... for patients in just the first six months after they ... in Canada, according to a study presented today at the ... Ischemic Stroke (BURST) study found that the direct and indirect ... in the six-month period following a new stroke. There are ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:A launchpad for stem cell research 2Health News:Video study finds risky food-safety behavior more common than thought 2Health News:Video study finds risky food-safety behavior more common than thought 3Health News:FDA should adopt risk-based approach to food safety 2Health News:FDA should adopt risk-based approach to food safety 3Health News:Research shows personality can predict fertility 2Health News:Getting extra sleep improves the athletic performance of collegiate football players 2Health News:Cost of caring for stroke patients double that of earlier estimates 2Health News:Cost of caring for stroke patients double that of earlier estimates 3
(Date:9/19/2014)... 19, 2014  For Cloud Pharmaceuticals, Inc., a ... development, partnering is an integral part of its ... new drugs and identify early stage, preclinical, IND, ... their development. The company also partners with funds ... business model, Cloud Pharmaceuticals will be participating in ...
(Date:9/19/2014)... STATION, N.J. , Sept. 19, 2014 Merck (NYSE: ... United States and Canada , is ... Desafiando La Diabetes: Logra Tus Metas , an educational program ... their blood sugar -- a key treatment goal to help reduce ... United States are at a higher risk for developing ...
(Date:9/19/2014)... , Sept. 19, 2014 UBM Medica US ... leading online community to help oncologists and other clinicians ... regarding the use of targeted therapies and immunotherapies, discusses ... and treatment.  Every September, Blood ... to raise awareness about blood cancers—helping to increase survival ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:Cloud Pharmaceuticals Announces Partnering Sessions and Presentation Schedule 2Celebrity Chef Leticia Moreinos Schwartz Partners with Merck on Desafiando La Diabetes: Logra Tus Metas to Urge Hispanics With Type 2 Diabetes to Get to Their A1C Goal 2Celebrity Chef Leticia Moreinos Schwartz Partners with Merck on Desafiando La Diabetes: Logra Tus Metas to Urge Hispanics With Type 2 Diabetes to Get to Their A1C Goal 3Celebrity Chef Leticia Moreinos Schwartz Partners with Merck on Desafiando La Diabetes: Logra Tus Metas to Urge Hispanics With Type 2 Diabetes to Get to Their A1C Goal 4Celebrity Chef Leticia Moreinos Schwartz Partners with Merck on Desafiando La Diabetes: Logra Tus Metas to Urge Hispanics With Type 2 Diabetes to Get to Their A1C Goal 5OncoTherapy Network Highlights National Blood Cancer Awareness Month 2OncoTherapy Network Highlights National Blood Cancer Awareness Month 3OncoTherapy Network Highlights National Blood Cancer Awareness Month 4
... Safety and Tolerability, PLYMOUTH MEETING, Pa., Aug. ... announced interim data from the first,Phase 1 clinical ... Anthony DelConte, M.D., Vice President, Clinical Research and,Development, ... Obesity and Related Metabolic Disorders," during the IBC ...
... BOSTON, Aug. 8 Erectile dysfunction after,surgery to remove ... damage that theoretically should heal over time.,But it can ... to recover enough for a,man to have an erection ... time,other damage may have occurred, according to an article ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Genaera Corporation Presents Interim Phase 1 Data for Obesity Compound Trodusquemine (MSI-1436) at IBC Conference 2Genaera Corporation Presents Interim Phase 1 Data for Obesity Compound Trodusquemine (MSI-1436) at IBC Conference 3Genaera Corporation Presents Interim Phase 1 Data for Obesity Compound Trodusquemine (MSI-1436) at IBC Conference 4'Use it or Lose it': A New Theory About Preserving Erectile Function After Prostate Surgery 2
... These objectives provide incredible image flatness over ... correction of chromatic aberration throughout the entire,visible ... for routine laboratory work but for photomicrography. ... series have more contrast than the DLL ...
... for this class of objectives. Correction ... with performance similar to the CFI Plan ... for spherical aberration and provide image flatness ... The DL phase contrast objectives in this ...
These objectives have more contrast than the DLL objectives for enhanced contrast with tissue culture specimens. These objectives are designed for use on inverted microscopes and therefore their mark...
... scientist who wants a fully automated, computer-controlled ... high precision Z-focus automated microscope featuring a ... possible to expand the infinity space to ... A five-way automated light path with ...
Medicine Products: