Navigation Links
Costly tests may not help detect bladder cancer recurrence, M. D. Anderson study finds

HOUSTON - In a new study from The University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center, researchers found that cystoscopy, the standard for screening for recurrence of early-stage bladder cancer, is a cost-effective method of detecting tumors.

Adding other tests to cystoscopy increases the cost, as well as the number of false positives that may result in emotional distress and unnecessary procedures, the investigators include.

The study was presented today in advance of the American Society of Clinical Oncology (ASCO) Genitourinary Cancer Symposium. Jose Karam, M.D., a fellow in M. D. Anderson's Department Genitourinary Oncology, presented the findings.

"Our research potentially will enable clinicians to make judicious use of the available ancillary 'urinary markers,' which would translate into costs savings plus less anxiety for bladder cancer patients," said Ashish Kamat, M.D., associate professor of Urology and director of M. D. Anderson's Urologic Oncology Fellowship Program.

"The tests frequently added to cystoscopy have many more false positives than commonly believed, and they can lead to unnecessary work-ups. Our findings also may help reduce the cost of caring for bladder cancer patients, which currently in is the range of $4 billion annually," continued Kamat, the study's senior author.

Early-stage bladder cancer, or non-muscle invasive bladder cancer (NMIBC), has a high rate of recurrence. Patients are tested every three to six months, often for the rest of their lives, with the goal of catching the cancer early if it returns.

Cystoscopy is an outpatient procedure in which a tiny tube with a small camera attached is inserted through the urethra into the bladder. Doctors then are able to visually examine the inside of the bladder for tumors. Many times, in efforts to ensure accuracy and early detection of bladder cancer recurrence, other tests are added to cystoscopy.

"In this study, we wanted to identify which bladder surveillance method provides acceptable tumor detection rate while minimizing costs," said Karam.

Kamat and his colleagues prospectively evaluated 200 M. D. Anderson patients with NMIBC. They compared the accuracy and cost of cystoscopy alone and cystoscopy combined with:

  • Cytology, examining bladder cells with a microscope
  • NMP22, a urine test that tests the level of NMP22 protein
  • FISH (fluorescence in situ hybridization), a urine test for chromosomal aberrations in bladder cells
  • NMP22 confirmed by FISH

By looking at the number of tumors detected and the cost of the tests (based on Medicare 2009 data) plus the cost of work-up for a false positive result, researchers arrived at a cost per tumor detected for each method. Cystoscopy alone was the least expensive at $7,692, while cystoscopy plus FISH was the priciest at $19,111.

But despite their added costs, additional tests did not give better results. Cystoscopy was most cost effective in finding tumors. Cystoscopy had two false positives, the fewest of any test, while cystoscopy plus FISH had the most false positives at 30.

"There are some who believe that the ancillary tests have the property to predict recurrences early," Kamat said. "In order to account for this, we took into account tumors detected later - at the first follow-up - to assess whether the tests added to detection rates. Our results suggest that, while the ancillary tests did turn positive prior to actual tumor recurrence in a handful of patients, the vast majority were still falsely positive."

Kamat said he would like to see the findings of this study confirmed in the near future by a multi-center co-operative study.


Contact: Laura Sussman
University of Texas M. D. Anderson Cancer Center

Related medicine news :

1. Why do physicians order costly CTs? Ultrasound yields better diagnosis, safer, less costly
2. Study Suggests Low-Consuming Medicare Beneficiaries With Chronic Disease Are More Costly to Program
3. Economy Has Patients Looking For Less Costly Ways To Enhance Appearance Says Dr. Phillip Langsdon, MD, FACS
4. Health Leaders Issue Recommendations to Improve Management of a Common, Costly and Misunderstood Cardiovascular Disease: Atrial Fibrillation
5. Stroke in Children Rare But Costly
6. Limiting Work Hours for Medical Residents Could Be Costly
7. Health and Advocacy Leaders Mobilize to Bring Attention to Atrial Fibrillation, a Costly and Misunderstood Cardiovascular Disease
8. In Time for Better Hearing and Speech Month: and Nexear Offers Consumers an Alternative to Traditional Costly Hearing Aids
9. For Some, More Costly Care Is Not by Choice
10. Less costly, more accessible and as effective: Simplified treatment for sleep apnea
11. The Seven Costly Mistakes Healthcare Organizations Make When Purchasing Electronic Medical Records and Health IT
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Costly tests may not help detect bladder cancer recurrence, M. D. Anderson study finds
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... The Lymphoma Research Foundation ... research and serving the lymphoma community through a comprehensive series of education programs, ... Hope; A Commitment to Cure last night at the Mandarin Oriental in New ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... — , ... ... Association of America (MOAA) will hold its 2015 annual meeting ... a free military career fair; informational seminars; a luncheon featuring ... the Joint Chiefs of Staff; and the Community Heroes Award ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... October 13, 2015 , ... Vision Group ... Vision of San Diego, California. With brands including The LASIK Vision Institute and TLC ... making it the nationwide leader in laser vision correction. , Global Laser Vision will ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... PhyMed Healthcare Group , ... its partnership with WPC Healthcare , a provider of predictive analytics solutions ... data into an aggregated data repository necessary to perform reporting and analytics on ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... Texas (PRWEB) , ... October 13, 2015 , ... Symposium ... for the 19th annual Dallas Cosmetic Symposium to be held March 2nd and 3rd, ... place immediately afterwards, draws plastic surgeons and cosmetic physicians from around the world. , ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:10/13/2015)... YORK , Oct. 13, 2015 Pomerantz ... filed against Amicus Therapeutics, Inc. ("Amicus" or the "Company")(NASDAQ: ... filed in United States District Court, District of ... a class consisting of all persons or entities who ... 1, 2015 inclusive (the "Class Period"). This class action seeks ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... , Oct. 13, 2015  Vitamin Angels – ... and mothers in need of nutritional support - announced ... by the United Nations (UN). The UN,s newly established ... – are a recent follow up to the Millennium ... deadline for completion. The new 17 Global Goals intend ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... , Oct. 13, 2015   Generational Equity ... middle-market businesses, is pleased to announce the acquisition of ... in Largo, Florida , by Meridian ... on September 11, 2015. Florida ... --> Florida . To learn ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: