Navigation Links
Consumer Watchdog Hails House Cost-Control Plan to Regulate Health Insurance Rates, Urges Lawmakers to Combine It With Strong 'Public Option'

Late Addition to House Health Reform Bill Should Adopt Key Details of Successful Insurance Regulation in California to Achieve Cost Controls, Says Group

WASHINGTON, Nov. 6 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Consumer Watchdog, which pioneered the nation's most successful insurance premium regulation law in California, praised Congress for including a key cost-control element in the final version of its health reform bill. Among amendments released this week is a requirement for health insurance companies to publicly justify any premium increases before they go into effect, a necessary element in containing future health care costs, said Consumer Watchdog.

The nonprofit, nonpartisan consumer advocacy group called on Congress to clarify that insurers must justify increases in their combined rates, including co-pays and deductibles, and require them to receive prior approval from state regulators before the rates go into effect. Congress must also insist that regulation be in addition to, not instead of, a publicly run option to private insurance.

"Rate regulation was the missing cost-control link in all of the Congressional bills, and this plugs a truck-sized loophole," said Jerry Flanagan, health policy director of Consumer Watchdog. "Now Congress needs to fill in some key details that will help states keep a firm lid on health insurance increases that have far outpaced increases in medical costs."

Read about California's landmark law to rein in gouging by property and casualty insurers at:

Consumer Watchdog expressed wariness that the rate regulation proposal might become a compromise alternative to a publicly run health insurance option in the final bill, and warned against it.

"Cost control over time depends on having multiple tools," said Flanagan. "The public option, by creating a free-market competitor to private insurers, would have a broad effect. Regulations, by stopping unjustifiable attempts to raise rates for different classes of policies, are the more specific tool."

The California regulations, which cover property and casualty insurance including auto insurance, have saved California drivers $62 billion dollars over 20 years, according to a 2008 Consumer Federation of America study. The regulations also curbed rates for medical malpractice insurance, succeeding where caps on court awards in malpractice cases did not.

The House amendment

Section 104, beginning on page 3 of the amendment to H.R. 3962, provides:

(1) The Secretary of Health and Human Services, in conjunction with states, shall require health insurance companies to justify the reasons for premium rate increases prior to implementing them. The insurers are required to post the justifications on their websites.

(2) The Secretary of Health and Human Services will provide $1 billion in grants to assist states "in reviewing and if appropriate under State law, approving premium increases for health insurance coverage . . . ."

(3) Any state receiving a federal grant shall provide the federal government information about increases in premium rates. In addition, states will be required to make recommendations about whether particular health insurers should be excluded from participation in the Health Insurance Exchange "based on a pattern of excessive or unjustified premium increases."

The amendment, offered by Representative John Dingell (D-MI), is available at:

What's still missing from the House amendment

Consumer Watchdog, which pioneered the most successful insurance premium regulation law in the nation, Proposition 103, called for particular changes to the House bill. Specifically, the House bill should adopt key provisions of California's landmark insurance reform law, including:

  • Mandatory prior approval, which means requiring insurers to seek permission from government regulators, in addition to justifying rate increases, before imposing the new rates. The language in the Dingell amendment conditioning such prior approval on whether it is "appropriate under state law" should be deleted. In its place states should be required to adopt Prop 103-styled prior approval in order to maximize saving and decrease insurance company waste and overhead. Since 1988, California's Proposition 103 has saved drivers $62 billion while fostering a competitive and profitable insurance market.
  • An intervenor system that allows the public to challenge unnecessary premium hikes. States should also provide consumers a forum to challenge excessive rate increases. Since 2003, Consumer Watchdog has saved the state's consumers $1.7 billion by challenging unnecessary premium increase and insufficient decrease requests using the public intervention process.

In addition to these two elements, to ensure that the reforms would be properly enforced, Proposition 103 made the state insurance commissioner an elected position accountable directly to the voters, not a political appointee.

A 2008 Consumer Federation of America report found Proposition 103 to be the nation's most effective insurance regulation and detailed the savings on the 1988 law. The report can be downloaded at: A related press release is available at:

Download Consumer Watchdog's report detailing how rate regulation and the intervenor system could be applied to health care at:

Consumer Watchdog is a nonpartisan consumer advocacy organization with offices in Washington, D.C. and Santa Monica, CA. Find us on the web at:

SOURCE Consumer Watchdog

SOURCE Consumer Watchdog
Copyright©2009 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Consumers Offer to Pay More to Satisfy Health Demands
2. CIGNA Group Insurance Shows Consumers Theres More to Life Through a New Consumer Education Toolkit
3. Draxis Health selected by Johnson and Johnson Consumer Companies, Inc. for major contract manufacturing relationship
4. Naked Juice Brings Consumers Happiness by the Billions With First 100% Juice Smoothie Containing Probiotics
5. Consumer Reports Analysis: Drugs for Nerve Pain, Fibromyalgia Effective, But Not Always Best
6. Hospitals Agree to Pay Fees in Exchange for More Income, but Consumers in the Dark About What Theyll be Charged Under Nunez Plan
7. PA Agriculture Department Warns Consumers of Tainted Raw Milk Sold by Perry County Dairy
8. Injuries, Deaths Tied to Consumer Drugs Rise Sharply
9. Highmark Blue Cross Blue Shield Introduces New Health Plan Comparison Tool for Consumers
10. Highmark Blue Shield Introduces New Health Plan Comparison Tool for Consumers
11. PA Department of Public Welfare Begins Outreach to Medical Assistance Consumers Following Burglary at State Office Building
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/28/2015)... ... November 28, 2015 , ... Pixel Film Studios is back again with ... the possibilities are endless. Users have full control over angle of view, speed method, ... users are sure to get heads to turn. , ProPanel: Pulse offers fully customizable ...
(Date:11/27/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... November 27, 2015 , ... According to ... out by the University of Toronto and the University of British Columbia suggested that ... for head injuries. The article explains that part of the reason for the controversial ...
(Date:11/27/2015)... ... November 27, 2015 , ... A team of Swiss doctors has ... it. Surviving Mesothelioma has just posted the findings on the website. Click here ... the cases of 136 mesothelioma patients who were treated with chemotherapy followed by EPP ...
(Date:11/27/2015)... ... 2015 , ... Lizzie’s Lice Pickers just announced a special promotion that will ... their purchase of lice treatment product. In addition, customers will receive a complimentary head ... “Finding lice is a sure way to ruin the holidays, so we encourage all ...
(Date:11/27/2015)... ... November 27, 2015 , ... MPWH, the No.1 Herpes-only dating community in the world, revealed that ... ). More than 3.7 billion people under the age of 50 – or 67% ... WHO's first global estimates of HSV-1 infection . , "The data shocks us highly!" ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/25/2015)... Nov. 25, 2015  Amgen (NASDAQ: AMGN ) ... (BLA) with the United States ... a biosimilar candidate to Humira ® (adalimumab). Amgen ... submitted to the FDA and represents Amgen,s first BLA ... E. Harper , M.D., executive vice president of Research ...
(Date:11/25/2015)... N.Y. , Nov. 25, 2015  Linden Care, ... and optimizing treatment outcomes for patients suffering from chronic ... request for a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) enjoining Express ... the two companies. --> ... pursuing all of its legal options. ...
(Date:11/25/2015)... On Tuesday, November 24, 2015, the ... Wright Medical Technology, Inc. for product liability and ... implant device, awarded $11 million in favor of ... and three days of deliberations, the jury found ... designed and unreasonably dangerous, and that Wright Medical ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: