Navigation Links
Colonoscopy Quality Critical Factor to Thorough Exam and Best Colon Cancer Detection
Date:1/13/2009

Flawed Analysis Misleading on Key Quality Indicators

BETHESDA, Md., Jan. 13 /PRNewswire-USNewswire/ -- Publication of a meta-analysis by Wilkins et al. on colonoscopy screening for colorectal cancer performed by primary care physicians raises several important issues regarding the quality of the exam, the safety of patients and the effectiveness of detecting colorectal cancer and pre-cancerous changes in the colon.

"The clinical evidence supports the College's position that the training and experience of the endoscopist are critical to a quality colonoscopy and cancer detection," explained Eamonn M.M. Quigley, M.D., FACG, President of the American College of Gastroenterology. "The College advises patients to seek a well-trained endoscopist who performs many of these tests and has a record of performing a complete examination of the colon. A patient undergoing a colonoscopy must be assured that their examination will truly be capable of detecting any and all abnormalities that could indicate disease or a predisposition to cancer. Otherwise, colon cancer will not be prevented."

"Any physician who performs colonoscopy needs to meet a high standard, and must be capable of interpreting all possible abnormalities seen, dealing with any therapeutic interventions that may arise, and managing the patient's safety," added Dr. Quigley.

The College believes that the findings of the Wilkins study are potentially misleading.

"This study is a meta-analysis of reports from selected centers reporting detection rates of adenomas and cancers in screening colonoscopies by primary care physicians. These data from selected centers are less generalizable than data obtained from population-based studies on detection rates of neoplasia," according to Douglas K. Rex, M.D., FACG, a representative of the ACG to the U.S. Multi-Society Task Force on Colorectal Cancer.

Available evidence directly comparing primary care physicians to gastroenterologists for the most important endpoint in colonoscopy, i.e. detection of cancer, indicates that gastroenterologist performance on average is clearly superior to primary care physicians'. According to Dr. Rex, all three population-based studies that have determined miss rates for colorectal cancer during colonoscopy by specialty have found that primary care physicians are more likely than gastroenterologists to miss colorectal cancer during colonoscopy (Rex et al Gastroenterology; 1997: 112:17-23; Bressler et al Gastroenterology 2007; 132:96-102; Singh et al Gastroenterology 2007; 132:A-149).

Dr. Rex noted that the Wilkins study is seriously flawed with regard to the detection rate, since 13,363 (73 percent) of 18,292 colonoscopies are derived from a single study which was not reported in a peer reviewed journal. The colonoscopies from this study should have been excluded because the center employs a gastroenterologist and colorectal surgeon, one of whom is on site full-time to rescue procedures when primary care physicians fail to reach the cecum. Moreover, this center has claimed that primary care physicians have equal success rates in their initial procedures compared to those performed after they are fully trained. This could only be achieved with assistance from the specialist. Since this situation is seldom if ever seen elsewhere in clinical practice, the procedures in this report should have been excluded from the study by Wilkins et al.

An additional concern with the Wilkins study is its claims regarding primary care physicians' success rates in reaching the cecum. The cecum is an anatomical landmark in the colon, and visualizing the cecum is considered a thorough exam. The overall reported rate of 89 percent in this meta-analysis is 6 percent below the recommended threshold for screening colonoscopy by the U.S. Multi-Society Task Force on Colorectal Cancer. "All published studies of screening colonoscopy by gastroenterologists in the United States have exceeded the 95 percent threshold, which in fact is the basis for the 95 percent recommendation," explained Dr. Rex.

When the data from the non-peer reviewed single-center study are excluded, only 4,929 procedures are available for analysis, and in these cases the cecal intubation rate was 83.5 percent, more than 10 percent lower than the recommended 95 percent threshold.

Furthermore, other data indicate that primary care physicians are less likely than gastroenterologists to recommend colonoscopy at appropriate intervals according to widely accepted guidelines (Boolchand et al Ann Intern Med; 2006; 145:654-9).


'/>"/>
SOURCE American College of Gastroenterology
Copyright©2009 PR Newswire.
All rights reserved

Related medicine news :

1. Annals colonoscopy study underscores importance of quality standards
2. ASGE urges patients to seek a qualified endoscopist before undergoing a colonoscopy
3. Colonoscopy Has a Right Side Blind Spot
4. Narrow-band imaging comparable to white light colonoscopy in differentiating colorectal polyps
5. Visage Imaging and Viatronix Sign Comprehensive Marketing Agreement for Virtual Colonoscopy Product
6. Risk of colorectal cancer extremely low 5 years after a normal colonoscopy screening
7. Study finds that competency in colonoscopy requires experience with 150 cases or more
8. Popular Colonoscopy Prep Solution May Pose Kidney Risks
9. African Americans less likely than whites to get colonoscopy despite family history of colon cancer
10. American Cancer Society Recommends Virtual Colonoscopy
11. Colonoscopy used to identify and remove flat colon lesions
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... ... affiliations and de novo development, today announced Cumberland Skin Surgery and Dermatology ... Surgery and Dermatology, with offices in both Hermitage and Lebanon, Tennessee, provides comprehensive ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... 2017 , ... Paul Vitenas, MD, FACS , is honored to announce ... list identifies the nation’s top physicians, in a variety of specialties. This marks the ... of Castle Connolly’s coveted ranking. , Castle Connolly is the nation’s trusted provider of ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... SGNA Standards of ... every reprocessing cycle, both between patient procedures and before storage, is a requisite ... as important to the prevention of disease transmission and nosocomial infection as cleaning ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... , ... August 16, 2017 , ... ... $5.99, eBook, 9781498499620    ) shares that during the time of a cancer diagnosis, surgery ... of God's love, and all the many ways God shows love to those ...
(Date:8/16/2017)... ... August 16, 2017 , ... ... an opportunity for men and women to train as hospice volunteers. Volunteers provide ... life-limiting illness. For over 30 years, the agency has trained volunteers to be ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:7/31/2017)... Tenn. , July 31, 2017 Three Tru-D SmartUVC ... Yongsan, South Korea . Tru-D, short for "Total Room ... and operating rooms after an environmental services (ES) professional cleans the area ... ... "Although the ...
(Date:7/28/2017)... 2017 Hill-Rom Holdings, Inc. ("Hill-Rom") (NYSE: HRC), ... ended June 30, 2017, and updated its financial outlook ... For the fiscal third quarter, Hill-Rom reported earnings ... diluted share in the prior-year period. These results reflect ... diluted share primarily related to the non-cash write-down of ...
(Date:7/27/2017)... WARSAW, Ind., July 27, 2017  Zimmer Biomet Holdings, ... the quarter ended June 30, 2017.  The Company reported ... of 1.1% over the prior year period, and an ... approximately 240 basis points of contribution from the LDR ... from the second quarter of 2016, or 0.3% on ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: