Navigation Links
Clearing Kids for Sports Participation Sparks Conflicts

By Kathleen Doheny
HealthDay Reporter

THURSDAY, Sept. 9 (HealthDay News) -- Most teenagers think they're invincible, and that goes double for talented teenage athletes. They're young, immortal, at the top of their game, the envy of their friends.

So when news hits that an apparently healthy, high school or college athlete has dropped dead in the midst of playing his or her favorite sport, millions of parents get understandably anxious.

The uppermost question becomes: Should my child be screened before participating in sports? What tests are needed? And how can we be sure that he or she is truly healthy enough to compete?

Everyone agrees that a medical checkup before participating in sports is crucial. But the agreement seems to stop there. At the core of the conflict over further testing is how extensively young athletes' hearts should be tested before they're cleared for athletic participation.

"I think everyone should have a doctor who evaluates them, and the doctor should know the child is going to be participating in athletics," said Dr. Paul Thompson, the director of preventive cardiology at Hartford Hospital in Connecticut, who helped write a joint position statement in 2007 from the American College of Sports Medicine and the American Heart Association.

That statement recommends cardiovascular screening for high school and college athletes before they start participating in athletics and at two- to four-year intervals. The screening should include a family history, a personal history and an exam "focused on detecting conditions associated with exercise-related events," according to the groups' recommendation.

But, there's more: "The AHA does not recommend routine, additional noninvasive testing such as a routine EKG [electrocardiogram, which assesses the heart's electrical rhythms]."

The American Academy of Pediatrics seems to agree. "Every athlete should have a thorough history [taken] from the athlete as well as the athlete's family," explained Dr. Reginald Washington, a pediatric cardiologist and chief medical officer at Rocky Mountain Hospital for Children in Denver and past chairman of the academy's committee on sports medicine and fitness.

The doctor should ask about any chest pain and dizziness, and whether the athlete has ever passed out or experienced a racing or unusual heartbeat, Washington said. The physician should also ask if the athlete's parents have had early heart disease, before age 55 for a man and 65 for a woman. And the physical exam, he said, should be thorough and include listening to the heart, taking blood pressure and feeling the pulse.

"If all of that is normal and the family history is normal, no further tests need to be done," said Washington, echoing the academy's stand.

But others disagree strongly, calling for universal and extensive testing of all young athletes to avert future tragedy.

Heart experts from Johns Hopkins Medicine in Baltimore contend that both an EKG and an echocardiogram -- which is an ultrasound that measures heart size, pumping function and checks for faulty heart valves -- are crucial to detect early signs of heart defects in young athletes because neither test alone will catch all potential problems.

In testing 134 high school athletes competing in the Maryland state track and field championships in 2008, for instance, no life-threatening heart defects were found but blood pressure abnormalities that required further testing and monitoring were detected in 36 athletes, some by EKG and some by echocardiogram, the Hopkins doctors reported at an American Heart Association session in late 2009.

Testing in 2009, according to a Hopkins report, found a serious heart valve disease in one track-and-field athlete and another with an undiagnosed heart condition that could require a transplant in the future. Neither athlete had reported any symptoms.

"If you are going to screen, it has to be comprehensive," Dr. Theodore Abraham, an associate professor at Hopkins' School of Medicine and its Heart and Vascular Institute, said in a prepared statement.

Other studies have found pros and cons to extra screening.

For instance, Harvard researchers who looked at 510 college athletes found that screening with a history and physical exam alone has an overall sensitivity of 45.5 percent, meaning it would find existing problems in about 45 of every 100 athletes screened. But adding an EKG to the screening boosted it to more than 90 percent.

However, the EKGs were also linked with a false-positive rate -- suggesting a problem when none existed -- of nearly 17 percent, according to their report, published March 2 in the Annals of Internal Medicine.

A separate study in that issue, on the cost-effectiveness of such screenings, reported that adding EKGs to screenings of young athletes saves two years of life per every 1,000 athletes, at a per-athlete cost of $89.

Screening policies differ from region to region across the country. In Houston, for instance, athletic trainers at 10 high schools are using laptop systems to give young athletes EKGs, and a doctor in the city has launched a program to provide heart screening to all sixth-graders, eventually hoping to screen all sixth-graders in Texas.

But there are downsides to such universal screening, others say.

"About 10 percent of kids who get EKGs are thought to have something the matter with them by the EKG," Thompson, the Connecticut doctor, said. "That drives additional testing, and nearly all don't have anything wrong."

The problem, he said, is not just wasted health-care dollars but the anxiety caused by additional testing, for athletes and their parents.

Thompson said he is not oblivious to parental worry or to the sad reality that some athletes die unexpectedly each year.

"Every single one of these deaths is an incredible tragedy," he said, adding that he will do extra testing if parents are very worried. "But when people have looked at this, the death rate in the U.S. is about one in every 250,000 athletes. There is not really conclusive research to show [extensive testing] saves lives."

Also, in mass screenings -- where kids line up and are screened quickly -- accuracy may suffer, said Washington, the Denver pediatric cardiologist. "A good, thorough ultrasound should take a half-hour," he said. "If you line up all the kids [at a school or on a team] to have a portable ultrasound, you will miss some of these subtle abnormalities."

But Sharon Bates, a parent who founded the Anthony Bates Foundation after her athlete son, Anthony, died unexpectedly in 2000 and was found to have had an enlarged heart, disagrees with the arguments against mass screenings.

Even if a problem picked up is minor, she said, you have a right to know, and it needs to be addressed.

Bates's son had passed the typical pre-athletic physical with flying colors, she said, yet he still had a major cardiac problem.

Her Phoenix-based foundation promotes universal screenings for all youth, not just athletes, she said.

As Abraham said, "What is the price for a single life?"

More information

The Nemours Foundation has information for kids on sports physicals.

SOURCES: Paul Thompson, M.D., director, preventive cardiology, Hartford Hospital, Hartford, Conn.; Reginald Washington, M.D., pediatric cardiologist and chief medical officer, Rocky Mountain Hospital for Children, Denver; Sharon Bates, founder and chief executive, Anthony Bates Foundation, Phoenix; May 2007, Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise; Nov. 11, 2009, news release, Johns Hopkins Medicine, Baltimore; March 2, 2010, Annals of Internal Medicine

Copyright©2010 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Related medicine news :

1. Thesis investigates characteristics of society using sports activities as research tool
2. Study shows race, not experience, impacts hiring in sports world
3. Phoenix Volleyball Festival Championships Played on SnapSports Volleyball Surfaces
4. Allegheny Medical's SportsCare Programs Combine Lifestyle, Fitness and Behavior Management with Quality Medical Treatments
5. GTM Sportswear Introduces New Budget Friendly Team Warm-ups Priced at $34
6. HOPSports, Inc. Adds SandBell to Award-Winning Training System
7. AAU Big Mountain Jam Basketball Tournament To Be Played On SnapSports Flooring
8. Throwdown, a Leader in Impact and Action Sports, Debuts Latest Innovations at the Newest UFC Gym™ in Rosemead, California
9. Revolutionary Sports Bottle Unscrews at Both Ends for Easy Cleaning -- Never Deal With Stinky, Moldy Bottles Again
10. CONTEND – A New Sports Drink from Swanson FIT
11. CooperVision Launches Contact Sports to Help Teen Athletes Gear Up
Post Your Comments:
Related Image:
Clearing Kids for Sports Participation Sparks Conflicts
(Date:10/10/2015)... York, NY (PRWEB) , ... October 10, 2015 , ... ... some alarming numbers on the growth of cybercrime costs for US companies. The New ... on Tuesday, October 6th. With averages showing increases hovering around 20% among the companies ...
(Date:10/10/2015)... , ... October 10, 2015 , ... Isabel Healthcare will ... , On the heels of the release of the Institute of Medicine’s latest report ... their integration with Cerner solutions that assist healthcare providers and consumers to potentially reduce ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... The American Osteopathic ... for Graduate Medical Education J. Michael Finley, DO, as the recipient of the ... for his impact on graduate medical education opportunities for osteopathic residents, and his ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... 2015 , ... A new health tool that helps identify if a sore ... ) – just in time for the cold and flu season, which the ... many in the U.S., the real start of cold/flu season is the start of ...
(Date:10/9/2015)... ... October 09, 2015 , ... Dentist in Huntington ... orthodontic system that uses clear, plastic aligners. This alternative to braces has become ... which allow patients to complete treatment in privacy. Additionally, Invisalign aligners are removable, ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
... serious problem that can often be fatal. Methadone has ... addicts. However, the major concern in treating heroin addicts ... is one reason methadone therapy is usually only given ... that an alternative drug therapy combined with psychosocial treatment ...
... researchers are currently testing the safety of hypothermia ... injury. Hypothermia treatment has been shown to be ... but its effectiveness in treating children with traumatic ... decreases inflammation, excitotoxicity (excessive neurotransmitters released with injury ...
... of skin cancer and it has been shown through previous ... sunlight, whose UV rays cause damage to DNA that triggers ... are more prone than others to melanoma. Researchers have now ... people with melanoma that those with fair skin// have lowered ...
... Affective Disorder(SAD) is not all that well understood, but ... sunlight in the winter months. Winter depression involves suffering ... days get longer and nights get shorter. Other SAD ... sleeping for longer than usual. Researchers have now found ...
... hospital in Kolkatta, India recently received a patient, a two-month-old ... suffering from a rare disease caused due to a deficiency ... of 10 million children. Doctors said that the baby was ... On detection the baby, a boy child, was found to ...
... time to its ultraviolet rays, has always been said to be ... shown that even moderate sun exposure can result in moles that ... to sun has been shown as the main risk factor for ... rarest type of skin cancer, is much weaker. It has however, ...
Cached Medicine News:
(Date:10/8/2015)... Oct. 8, 2015  Clariant, a world leader in specialty ... facility in Belen, New Mexico , has ... including desiccant canisters and packets and other ... plant is the second Clariant site – the first in ... the ISO 15378:2011 standards, following only the Clariant manufacturing facility ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... , Oct. 8, 2015  Nektar Therapeutics (Nasdaq: ... pain and oncology portfolio during an Investor and Analyst ... p.m. Eastern Time in New York City ... of the NKTR-214 Phase 1/2 clinical program and biomarker ... cytokine designed to preferentially stimulate the production of CD8-positive ...
(Date:10/8/2015)... a clinical stage drug development company focused on advancing ... today the commencement of the US arm of an ... acebilustat, in patients with cystic fibrosis (CF). The study ... the United States and European Union, ... 2016. This landmark clinical trial testing once-daily oral acebilustat ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:
... Texas, Dec. 2, 2010 Ascension Orthopedics, Inc., ... another implantation of the TITAN™ Modular Total Shoulder. ... at Bucks County Specialty Hospital in Bensalem, Pennsylvania. ... postoperative x-rays showed a very anatomic replacement.  The ...
... 2, 2010 Medical devices, biotechnology and IT products ... will present to United States investors and the business ... business and investment opportunities. (Logo: ... successful Chilean Small and Medium Enterprises (SMEs) was selected ...
Cached Medicine Technology:
The IRN method used on the Dimension clinical chemistry system is an in vitro diagnostic test intended for the quantitative determination of iron in serum....
For the quantitative in vitro determination of Aspartate Aminotransferase (AST) in serum and plasma....
Enzymatic Clearance assay for the in vitro quantitative determination of HDL-cholesterol in human serum and plasma....
Immunoturbidimetric assay for the quantitative in vitro determination of Lipoprotein (a) in human serum or plasma...
Medicine Products: