Navigation Links
Charges for blood tests vary across California hospitals

New UC San Francisco research shows significant price differences for ten common blood tests in California hospitals, with some patients charged as little as $10 for one test while others were charged $10,169 for the identical test.

The analysis of charges at more than 150 California hospitals looked at blood tests that are often required of patients, such as lipid panel, basic metabolic panel, and complete blood cell count with differential white cell count.

Hospital ownership and teaching status help explain a portion of the variation prices generally were lower at government and teaching hospitals. Factors such as location, labor costs, patient capacity and percentage of uninsured population generally did not account for the price differences, the authors said, making it difficult for patients to know their costs in advance and to "act as rational consumers."

The report will be published in BMJ Open on August 15, 2014.

Charges for a basic metabolic test ranged from $35 to $7,303, depending on the hospital; the median charge was $214. The most extreme price difference was found in charges for a lipid panel: the median charge was $220, but overall charges ranged from $10 to as much as $10,169.

The results are of particular concern, said the authors, since there isn't much room for variability in blood tests. Moreover, because the tests are identical across providers, consumers might be expected to think that hospital charges would be similar.

"You may hear people say that, 'Charges don't matter' or that 'No one pays full charges,'" said senior author Renee Y. Hsia, MD, an associate professor of emergency medicine at UCSF and director of health policy studies in the Department of Emergency Medicine. She is also an attending physician in the emergency department at San Francisco General Hospital and Trauma Center.

"However, uninsured patients certainly face the full brunt of raw charges, especially if they don't qualify for charity care discounts," Hsia said. "And as employers are switching to more consumer-directed health plans with higher deductibles and co-pays, the out-of-pocket costs of even insured patients can be affected by these charges."

The blood test analysis was based on charges assessed in 2011 by general, acute care medical/surgical hospitals. The majority of the hospitals were not-for-profit, urban, non-teaching facilities. On average, 41 percent of their patient populations were on Medicare and 25 percent were on Medicaid.

The blood test charges were based on hospital full rates before pre-payments or contractual adjustments.

The scientists noted that they were unable to quantify some factors which could help influence medical charges for blood tests: "For example, many quality hospitals may choose to invest in higher quality facilities, supplementary services and social services than others," they wrote in their report. "The costs of these differences, while of value to patients, are not easy to measure, However, they likely do trickle down into charges for all basic services, including blood tests."

Still, they wrote, few of these factors were significant predictors of the charges patients ultimately faced.

Price variation similarly occurs when patients are hospitalized, according to a separate study also led by Hsia and published in the August 2014 issue of PLOS ONE. In that analysis, hospital charges for an average California patient admitted for uncomplicated percutaneous coronary intervention ranged from $22,047 to $165,386, with a median charge of $88,350. Charges were higher at California hospitals located in areas with higher costs of living, in rural hospitals, and in hospitals with higher proportions of Medicare patients. However, these factors accounted for less than half the price variation, said the authors.

"To expect patients to be rational consumers is unrealistic when the system itself is irrational," Hsia said. "There is very little that we are able to point to that explains the variation, suggesting that the variations are not predictable and therefore a sign of huge inefficiency within the health care pricing system."


Contact: Elizabeth Fernandez
University of California - San Francisco

Related medicine news :

1. New Super Digestive Enzyme, DZ10, Supercharges The Digestion Process
2. Law Offices of D.R. Jones Defendant, Rhonda Kay Romero's Vehicular Homicide/DUI Charges Dropped
3. Meratol Turbocharges the Metabolic Process and Promotes Fast Fat Burn: As Featured in Bella Magazine
4. Health Data Intelligence Introduces a New Dashboard to Analyze Hospital-Level Medicare Provider Charges and Payments
5. Plastic Bag Bans, Bag Charges, and a New Solution for Controlling Bag Waste
6. Goodman and Amana Air Conditioners Allegedly Violated Consumer Warranties, Charges Class Action Lawsuit Filed by Parker Waichman LLP
7. Integrated stroke care system results in fewer deaths, discharges to long-term care facilities
8. ORIENTplus upgrade supercharges EU-China collaborative research and education
9. Charges for emergency room visits often based on incorrect assumptions
10. DrugRisk Update: Court Allows Charges of Prior Fraud Into Pradaxa Lawsuit
11. A second victim comes forward in the sexual assault charges filed against Dr. Mike Adam.
Post Your Comments:
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... 2015 , ... Holcomb – Kreithen Plastic Surgery and ... in Florida, is proud to announce that Dr. Joshua Kreithen, one of its ... a Johnson & Johnson Company. , Ethicon is a global medical device company ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... ... for “Value-Based Payer-Provider Partnerships: Three Case Studies,” an upcoming Dec. 8 virtual ... Essentia Health and UCare, MissionPoint Health Partners, and Intel Corp. Leaders from ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... Sikka Software announced today that they are showcasing ... dentists to make complex business decisions by providing the tools and information they need ... survey with 10 procedures customized by zip code. , The Sikka Software Ecosystem ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... The successful filing of ... company. Because it is so important to this key industry segment, Regis Technologies has ... IND Filing” on December 4th at 11am EST. , Federal law does not allow ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... ... November 30, 2015 , ... Vasont ... their Vasont Universal Integrator (VUI) extension unites with Syncro Soft’s latest software update, ... as a continuous process with the latest release of oXygen® XML editor and ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:11/30/2015)... HANOVER, N.J. , Nov. 30, 2015  Novartis ... portfolio at the 57 th American Society of ... leukemias, lymphomas and myelomas as well as supportive care, ... in addition to personalized cell therapies. The ASH Annual ... Orlando, Florida . Novartis Oncology . ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... , Belgium , Nov. 30, 2015 ... sciences company focused on developing blood-based diagnostic tests for a ... the Company will present at the LD Micro Conference, which ... Los Angeles, CA. Attending from VolitionRx will be ... Scott Powell , Vice President of Investor Relations. ...
(Date:11/30/2015)... , Nov. 30, 2015  Precision Image ... services, is pleased to announce a dramatic expansion ... imaging services. Building on its ISO-9001:2008 certification for ... implemented comprehensive Core Lab protocols and procedures. This ... of research activities.  Their Core Lab services include ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: