Navigation Links
Can hospital readmission rates be trusted?

MAYWOOD, Il. - When hospital patients have to be readmitted soon after discharge, hospitals look bad.

A high readmission rate also can result in reduced Medicare reimbursements. But a study of spine surgery patients has found that the standard method used to calculate readmission rates is a misleading indicator of hospital quality. Loyola University Medical Center neurosurgeon Beejal Amin, MD, and colleagues found that 25 percent of the readmissions of spine surgery patients were not due to true quality-of-care issues.

Results are reported in a featured article in the February, 2013 issue of the Journal of Neurosurgery.

"We have identified potential pitfalls in the current calculation of readmission rates," Amin said. "We are working on modifying the algorithm to make it more clinically relevant."

Medicare is trying to improve patient care by penalizing hospitals with poor outcomes. One key outcomes measure is the readmissions rate. Medicare may begin to withhold reimbursements to hospitals with excessively high readmission rates.

In spine surgery, a high readmission rate can indeed reflect poorly on a hospital's quality of care if the readmissions are due to reasons such as infections, surgical complications, blood clots and failures of surgical hardware, Amin said.

But some types of readmissions are not a true indication of quality of care, Amin said. Such cases include:

  • Planned readmission for a staged procedure. For example, a procedure to straighten a curved spine in a scoliosis patient requires two surgeries performed in different stages.

  • Readmission unrelated to spine surgery. Occasionally, patients who undergo spine surgery will be readmitted within 30 days for surgery for an unrelated condition, such as a hip replacement.

  • Operation cancelled or rescheduled for unpreventable reasons. For example, a patient is admitted to the hospital but the spinal surgery is postponed due to an irregular heart rate. The patient is readmitted a couple weeks later for elective surgery, after the heart rhythm is controlled.

Amin and colleagues examined the records of 5,780 spine surgery patients treated at the University of California San Francisco Medical Center between October, 2007 and June, 2011. (Before joining Loyola, Amin did a clinical fellowship in complex spine surgery at UCSF under Dr. Praveen Mummaneni. Currently, Amin is an assistant professor in the Department of Neurological Surgery at Loyola University Chicago Stritch School of Medicine. His clinical expertise is in minimally invasive and complex spine surgery.)

The study found that, under the standard readmission formula, 281 patients were readmitted within 30 days of discharge. But 69 of these readmissions (25 percent) should not have been counted against the hospital. These included 39 cases that were planned readmissions for staged procedures, 16 cases that were unrelated to spine surgery and 14 cases that were cancelled or rescheduled due to unpreventable reasons.

"From the clinician's point of view, this 25 percent of readmission cases was appropriate and unavoidable," the authors wrote. "Efforts to curtail such readmissions would be unnecessary and potentially use resources that could be directed elsewhere."

Amin and colleagues concluded that their findings identify the potential pitfalls in the calculation of readmission rates from administrative data sets.

"Current algorithms overestimate clinically relevant readmission rates and cost," Amin and colleagues wrote. "This overestimated rate may then be used by payers (that is, Medicare) to deny payment for clinically unavoidable readmissions. Developing more sophisticated algorithms with spine surgeons' input will increase the reporting accuracy. Surgeons can play a vital role to help improve benchmarking and improve the value of health care provided."


Contact: Jim Ritter
Loyola University Health System

Related medicine news :

1. Little-Known Respiratory Infection Sends Many Kids to Hospital
2. For Hospitals, Lowered Death Rates May Not Mean More Readmissions
3. In Hospitals, Daily Antiseptic Bath May Prevent Dangerous Infections
4. FHA Unveils Section 242/223(f) Acquisition and Refinancing Program for Hospitals
5. ASU, Phoenix Childrens Hospital expand biomedical research partnership
6. Kish Hospital’s Center for Joint Care Celebrates Two Years of Patient Care
7. The Wellness Corporation announces Stellaris Health Network will offer Wellness Work/Life Program (EAP) services to employees of its member hospitals
8. Lorraine McLaren Joins Leading FHA Hospital Lender, AMS Health Care Mortgage Corporation
9. 1 in 5 Hospital Docs Reports Unsafe Workloads: Study
10. BrainTrain Announces Cognitive Training Software Giveaway to Veterans Hospitals
11. Baptist Health System Announces Expansion for North Central Baptist Hospital
Post Your Comments:
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... ... IBM software products, introduced a new company, RightSensor™ LLC, an Internet of Things ... capability. RightSensor™ provides a fully-managed approach for customers requiring sensor hardware for ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... October 13, 2015 , ... e-con Systems Inc., a leading embedded ... See3CAM_CU40, the industry’s first RGB-IR pixel format camera with a USB 3.0 interface ... e-con’s See3CAM family of UVC USB 3.0 cameras, is based on the 1/3-inch OV4682 ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... ... ... Protein is essential to good health. You need it to make the bricks ... does the average man need in order to stay healthy? , The answer ... Harvard Men's Health Watch . Most Americans get about 15% of their calories ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... October 13, 2015 , ... ... in McHenry County, Illinois with more than 59,000 emergency department visits per year, ... system (EDIS) from T-System, to help improve clinical, operational and financial outcomes. ...
(Date:10/13/2015)... (PRWEB) , ... October 13, 2015 , ... World ... Driveway Snow Blanket, a snow melting invention that helps people in clearing snow away ... and will continue to grow at 3.8% per year," says Scott Cooper, CEO and ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):
(Date:10/13/2015)... N.C. , Oct. 13, 2015  Yesterday Congresswoman ... Influenza Vaccines Holly Springs manufacturing site located in ... 2014, the facility has produced Flucelvax ® (Influenza ... the potential for faster start-up and is not reliant ... CSL Limited acquired the influenza vaccines business of Novartis ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... 12, 2015 Given the intricacy of ... challenging to deliver an ophthalmic drug effectively to a specific ... successful ocular drug delivery. These include dilution of a drug ... of conjunctiva and drug permeation issues with respect to the ... topical eye drops, is lost due to the aforementioned barriers. ...
(Date:10/12/2015)... CRANBURY, N.J. , Oct. 12, 2015 /PRNewswire/ ... that a securities fraud class action complaint was ... of New Jersey.  The complaint alleges that officers and ... Securities Exchange Act of 1934 between September 15, 2015 ... misleading statements about Amicus Therapeutics, business prospects.  Amicus is ...
Breaking Medicine Technology: