Navigation Links
Breast Cancer Charity Overstates Value of Mammograms: Researchers
Date:8/3/2012

By Amanda Gardner
HealthDay Reporter

THURSDAY, Aug. 2 (HealthDay News) -- The breast cancer charity that brought the world the pink ribbon exaggerates the benefits of mammography while minimizing its harms, researchers claim.

The organization in question is the Susan G. Komen for the Cure, which stated in a 2011 advertisement that the five-year survival rate for breast cancer when caught early is 98 percent, while it is only 23 percent if not caught early.

"The survival statistics they present are eye-catching and compelling. They imply that a woman would be crazy and irresponsible if they didn't go for screening," said Dr. Steve Woloshin, co-author of the article challenging the charity. "But the statistics are deceptive."

According to Woloshin's commentary, which appears online Aug. 2 in the BMJ, a woman in her 50s who goes for regular mammograms for 10 years will only cut her chance of dying by a fraction of a percentage point -- for every 10,000 women who are screened 7 deaths will be prevented.

The reason for the discrepancy?

Survival statistics calculate how long a woman lives only after diagnosis, the researchers explained.

If 100 women were diagnosed with breast cancer after feeling a lump at age 67 and all died three years later at the age of 70, the five-year survival rate would be 0 percent.

But, if the cancers were detected by mammography when the women were 64 and they still died at the age of 70, the five-year survival would be 100 percent.

Komen also minimizes the harms that can come from over-screening, according to the article.

For every woman whose life is saved by mammography, between two and 10 women are overdiagnosed, meaning they are told they have cancer when they do not and end up going through unnecessary treatment.

And up to half of women who are screened every year for a decade receive at least one false positive, meaning they have to
'/>"/>

Copyright©2012 ScoutNews,LLC.
All rights reserved  

Page: 1 2 3

Related medicine news :

1. Breast Cancer Drug Duo Wins Out in Study
2. Drug combo better for common type of metastatic breast cancer, UCI-led study finds
3. Spouses of breast cancer survivors hold on to hope
4. Study identifies barriers to breast health care in Pakistan
5. Research identifies a promising new therapeutic target for aggressive breast cancer
6. Mayo Clinic: Drug duo turns on cancer-fighting gene in kidney, breast cancers
7. Computational analysis identifies drugs to treat drug-resistant breast cancer
8. Breast cancer patients who lack RB gene respond better to neoadjuvant chemotherapy
9. Researchers find driver of breast cancer stem cell metastasis
10. Moms HIV Drugs May Pass to Baby in Womb, Breast-Feeding
11. FDA Gives Nod to New Breast Cancer Drug
Post Your Comments:
*Name:
*Comment:
*Email:
Related Image:
Breast Cancer Charity Overstates Value of Mammograms: Researchers  
(Date:7/10/2014)... THURSDAY, July 10, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- Nature, not ... intelligence of individual chimpanzees, a new study finds. ... it comes to cognitive [thinking] abilities in chimpanzees," William ... Atlanta, said in a news release from the journal ... give insight into the evolution of intelligence in humans, ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... THURSDAY, July 10, 2014 (HealthDay News) -- Men who ... aggressive prostate cancer, a new study suggests. But ... several urologists not involved with the study said more ... are truly accurate. For the study, Harvard researchers ... were followed for 24 years, starting in 1986. During ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... More than 200 experts on aggression, who research issues ... attend the 21st World Meeting of the International Society ... Hotel, July 15-19. , Georgia State University is hosting ... year on alternating continents. , "We are excited to ... different countries, which will help produce fresh ideas about ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... of Health and Human Services (HHS) has announced a ... Seidman Cancer Center totaling $4.7 million to support a ... with complex cancer. , Titled "Evidence-Conformant Oncology Care," ... UH to enhance care for adult cancer patients with ... health care utilization. , "We believe that ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... shown that more severe illness and even death are ... infection after developing influenza. Now, however, a team of ... if you reverse the order of infection, the bacteria ... protect against a bad case of the flu. ... which is described as a bacterial virulence factor, might ...
Breaking Medicine News(10 mins):Health News:Like Humans, Chimps' Smarts May Rely on Genes 2Health News:Study Links Vasectomy to Aggressive Prostate Cancer 2Health News:Study Links Vasectomy to Aggressive Prostate Cancer 3Health News:Georgia State hosts national conference on aggression 2Health News:Georgia State hosts national conference on aggression 3Health News:UH Case Medical Center awarded $4.7 million grant from HHS 2Health News:UH Case Medical Center awarded $4.7 million grant from HHS 3Health News:Bacterial colonization prior to catching the flu may protect against severe illness 2
... ,Hidden Health Tax, is the Undisclosed Premium Surcharge that Pays ... People Join the Ranks of the Uninsured, the ,Hidden Health ... Higher in 2009WASHINGTON, May 28 The so-called ... $1,017 in 2008 according to a report released today by ...
... Elsevier, would like to announce the publication of ... Treatment by Peter Miller, PhD. , The ... the field of addictions treatment is leading to ... based solely on clinical intuition rather than hard ...
... 2009) Kevin Bruhn, PhD, is the winner of the ... at nurturing excellence and providing support for a young scientist ... to LA BioMed in 2005 after receiving his PhD in ... Los Angeles in 2004 and completing a postdoctoral fellowship in ...
... BIRMNGHAM, Ala. An experimental drug derived from cottonseed ... widely considered the most lethal brain cancer, said researchers ... The new results are from a Phase II clinical ... compound in cottonseed that overcomes the abnormal growth patterns ...
... fractional laser was featured today on NBC,s Today ... for scars. During the broadcast, triplets who were severely ... story and discussed recent treatments with the Lumenis UltraPulse ... and DeepFX technologies, the triplets Jordan, Trae and Chandra ...
... Deliciously Cool, Smooth Drink While It,s HotBATTLE CREEK, Mich., May 28 ... season doesn,t feature the bells and whistles of most sought-after new ... to get their hands on it just the same. ... (R) brand is introducing the brand,s first ...
Cached Medicine News:Health News:'Hidden Health Tax' for Family Health Care Coverage Climbed to $1,017 in 2008 2Health News:'Hidden Health Tax' for Family Health Care Coverage Climbed to $1,017 in 2008 3Health News:Exciting Innovation in Burn Scar Treatment Using Lumenis(R) UltraPulse(R) Laser Treatments Revealed on the Today Show 2Health News:Exciting Innovation in Burn Scar Treatment Using Lumenis(R) UltraPulse(R) Laser Treatments Revealed on the Today Show 3Health News:Exciting Innovation in Burn Scar Treatment Using Lumenis(R) UltraPulse(R) Laser Treatments Revealed on the Today Show 4Health News:Special K(R) Brand Shakes Things Up with New Weight-Management Protein Shake 2Health News:Special K(R) Brand Shakes Things Up with New Weight-Management Protein Shake 3Health News:Special K(R) Brand Shakes Things Up with New Weight-Management Protein Shake 4
(Date:7/10/2014)... , July 10, 2014 Integrated Silicon Solution, ... advanced memory and analog IC solutions, today announced that ... July 24, 2014, at 7:00 a.m. Pacific Time (10:00 ... for the fiscal 2014 third quarter ended June 30, ... telephone, dial 1-888-556-4997 before 6:50 a.m. Pacific time on ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... JORDAN, Utah , July 10, 2014  BC ... solutions, and MiE America , Inc., a leading ... have entered into a long-term agreement naming BC Technical ... the US. MiE and BC Technical ... strategic agreement to establish BC Technical as the service ...
(Date:7/10/2014)... BURLINGTON, Mass. , July 10, 2014 /PRNewswire/ ... three-quarters of surveyed infectious disease (ID) specialists are ... Medicines Company,s Orbactiv (oritavancin) for use as OPAT, ... to prescribe these agents to their hospital inpatients. ... percent) of OPAT patients are initiated on OPAT ...
Breaking Medicine Technology:BC Technical Partners With MiE America To Be Authorized Provider Of Systems & Service 2Long-Acting Antibiotics Offering Once-Weekly Dosing Will See Favorable Uptake and Use as Outpatient Parenteral Antimicrobial Therapy (OPAT) 2Long-Acting Antibiotics Offering Once-Weekly Dosing Will See Favorable Uptake and Use as Outpatient Parenteral Antimicrobial Therapy (OPAT) 3
... ST. LOUIS , Feb. 1 Stereotaxis (Nasdaq: ... featured Dr. Mauricio Arruda , a leading electro-physiologist ... in Cleveland, Ohio , performing a live cardiac ablation ... The patient was a 69 year old woman who suffered ...
... BRISBANE, Calif. , Feb. 1 InterMune, ... Food and Drug Administration,s (FDA) Pulmonary-Allergy Drugs Advisory Committee (PADAC) ... for pirfenidone on March 9, 2010 .  Pirfenidone is ... idiopathic pulmonary fibrosis (IPF).   , "There is an urgent ...
Cached Medicine Technology:Stereotaxis System Procedure Featured on NBC's The TODAY Show 2InterMune to Participate in Pulmonary-Allergy Drugs Advisory Committee Meeting on March 9, 2010 2InterMune to Participate in Pulmonary-Allergy Drugs Advisory Committee Meeting on March 9, 2010 3InterMune to Participate in Pulmonary-Allergy Drugs Advisory Committee Meeting on March 9, 2010 4InterMune to Participate in Pulmonary-Allergy Drugs Advisory Committee Meeting on March 9, 2010 5
...
... Miditron Junior II ... urinalysis analyser for standardised ... hardware and software features ... high performance and convenience ...
... The Assistant Free ... retractors utilizing Velcro® straps. ... of the surgeon's operative ... personnel. Three retractor styles ...
... for four corner fusion of the capitate, ... hand. The plate is intended for use ... of function due to SLAC and SNAC ... rheumatoid arthritis. When combined with the specially ...
Medicine Products: